NOTICES
COPYRIGHT ROYALTY TRIBUNAL
[Docket No. 85-1-84JD]
Final Determination of the Distribution of the 1984 Jukebox Royalty Fund
Tuesday, December 2, 1986
*43455 AGENCY: Copyright Royalty Tribunal.
ACTION: Notice of final determination.
SUMMARY: The Tribunal announces the adoption of its final determination in the proceeding concerning the distribution to certain copyright owners and performing rights societies of jukebox royalty fees deposited for 1984 performances.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:Robert Cassler, General Counsel, Copyright Royalty Tribunal, 1111 20th Street NW., Suite 450, Washington, DC 20036.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
Authority
17 U.S.C. 116(c)(3) authorizes the Copyright Royalty Tribunal (Tribunal) to distribute annually royalty fees paid by jukebox operators to certain copyright owners and performing rights societies. First, the Tribunal is to assess the claims of, and make appropriate award to, "every copyright owner not affiliated with a performing rights society." 17 U.S.C. 116(c)(4)(A). Second, the remainder is to be distributed to "the performing rights societies . . . as they shall by agreement stipulate among themselves, or if they fail to agree, the pro rata share to which such performing rights societies prove entitlement." 17 U.S.C. 116(c)(4)(B).
The Claimants
In this proceeding, the Tribunal takes up the distribution of the royalty fees deposited by jukebox operators for the calendar year 1984. Five parties filed claims in the 1984 proceeding: Asociacion de Compositores y Editores de Musica Latinoamerica (ACEMLA), ASCAP, BMI, SESAC, Inc. and Italian Book Company.
Italian Book Company subsequently withdrew its claim, and is no longer a party to this proceeding. Letter of Dennis Angel, dated November 11, 1985. ASCAP, BMI, SESAC, Inc. reached an agreement for division of the jukebox royalties among themselves, and prosecuted their claims jointly. Justification of Claim, filed November 1, 1985.
The Controversy
As a result of the settlement among BMI, ASCAP, and SESAC, Inc., (hereinafter the Settling Parties), and the withdrawal of Italian Book Company, the controversey in this proceeding is between ACEMLA and the Settling Parties.
ACEMLA asserts that it is a performing rights society, and that it is entitled to 10% of the jukebox fund. The Settling Parties assert that ACEMLA is not a performing rights society, and that the Settling Parties are entitled to 100% of the fund.
Whether a party in this proceeding is determined to fall under section 116(c)(4)(A), as a copyright owner, or under 116(c)(4)(B), as a performing rights society has no bearing upon the ultimate amount of its award. In the context of this decision, the determination to be made, whether ACEMLA is a performing rights society, arises solely from the question of who has the burden of going forward with the evidence. The Copyright Act, as just cited, requires the Tribunal to consider first the claims of copyright owners, and then second, performing rights societies, but only in the event that the societies are in disagreement as to their share of the fund.
If ACEMLA is a copyright owner, the Tribunal must consider it first, and the burden is on ACEMLA alone to affirmatively show its entitlement. After consideration of ACEMLA's entitlement has been rendered, the Tribunal's task in this proceeding would be complete because the three performing rights societies are in agreement.
If, on the other hand, ACEMLA is a performing rights society, there would exist a disagreement among performing rights societies, and each society must go forward to prove its entitlement to the amount of the fund which is in controversy.
Background and Chronology
On November 15, 1985, the Tribunal published a notice declaring a controversy existed concerning the distribution of the 1984 jukebox royalty fund, effective December 2, 1985, and ordered that all evidence to be considered in the matter be filed by May 15, 1986. In the same notice, the Tribunal ordered a partial distribution to the Settling Parties of 90% of the 1984 jukebox royalty fund. 50 FR 47794 (November 15, 1985).
The written direct cases were filed on May 15, 1986, and, by leave of the Tribunal, supplements to the direct cases were permitted to be filed on September 12, 1986. Order, dated September 4, 1986.
The Tribunal conducted four days of evidentiary hearings. ACEMLA presented its direct case on September 22, 1986, and September 30, 1986. The Settling Parties presented their direct case on September 23, 1986.
ACEMLA presented no rebuttal case. The Tribunal heard the rebuttal testimony of the Settling Parties on September 30 and October 1, 1986.
The record of the proceeding was closed October 16, 1986. ACEMLA and the Settling Parties filed their Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law on October 20, 1986. Reply Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law were filed on October 24, 1986.
Findings of Fact--Status of ACEMLA.
17 U.S.C. 116(e)(3) defines a performing rights society as "an association or corporation that licenses the public performances of nondramatic musical works on behalf of the copyright owners, such as the American Society of Composers, Authors and Publishers, Broadcast Music, Inc., and SESAC, Inc." The Tribunal first engaged in a detailed determination as to whether ACEMLA is a performing rights society in the consolidated 1982/1983 distribution proceeding. 50 FR 47577 (November 19, 1985.) The Tribunal concluded that ACEMLA was not a performing rights society in 1982 or in 1983. Id., at 47581. Based on the facts developed in that proceeding and in this proceeding, and breaking down the definition into its three constituent parts, the Tribunal finds the following:
"An association or corporation . . ."
L. Raul Bernard (Bernard) is president and sole stockholder of Latin American Music Co., Inc. (LAMCO), a music publishing company incorporated in *43456 April, 1981. LAMCO has entered into contracts with one domestic music publishing company, and with certain foreign entities (whether publishers or performing rights societies was not established) to represent the rights to their music in the United States. 50 FR 47578-47579.
Bernard stated that it was his intent as early as 1980 to create a subdivision of his music publishing company which would be a performing rights society, ACEMLA, the purpose of which would be to license the performing rights to the music of which he had acquired control. In an effort to accomplish this, Bernard filed a certificate of assumed name with the state of New York on April 24, 1984 which stated that ACEMLA is the assumed name of LAMCO. Bernard took no other structural steps to create a performing rights society. Id.
Although using the word "asociacion" in its title, ACEMLA Has not claimed to be an association. ACEMLA Proposed Findings, p. 16, par. 2, ACEMLA has not registered as an unincorporated membership association under New York law. New York General Associations Law, Article 4, Section 18.
ACEMLA does not claim to be a corporation by virtue of its own incorporation, but because it is the assumed name of LAMCO. ACEMLA Proposed Findings, p. 16, par. 2.
In the 1982 proceeding, and for part of the 1983 proceeding, Bernard claimed that his sole proprietorship, Latin American Music (LAM), his corporation, LAMCO, and ACEMLA were all three performing rights societies. Later, he amended his claim to state that LAM and LAMCO were not performing rights societies. They were copyright owners. 50 FR 47578. In the 1984 proceeding, Bernard again represeted that LAMCO is a copyright owner, and that ACEMLA is a performing rights society. Tr. 27-29.
ACEMLA is not an association of members, or a corporation of affiliates. For the period 1982-1984, Bernard has not established a system for membership or affiliation with ACEMLA. Tr. 45. The method by which ACEMLA obtains rights to music is from Bernard's other entities, except for one instance noted below. Some contracts are signed with LAM, LAMCO or International Music Co. (another assumed name of LAMCO). Bernard asserts that the performing rights obtained by these contracts are assigned to ACEMLA, but there is no documentation of this. 50 FR 47579; Tr. 11. Bernard represented that any agreement with LAMCO would act automatically as an authorization to ACEMLA because ACEMLA Is an assumed name of LAMCO. 50 FR 47579.
One contract was submitted in the 1984 proceeding by which an entity contracted directly with ACEMLA. Musica Dominicana, S.A. (MUDOSA) subscribed to a contract February 7, 1983, later executed sometime in 1984, which gave ACEMLA the right to license the performing rights on behalf of MUDOSA. Response of ACEMLA to Tribunal's Requests for Additional Documents Supporting ACEMLA's Direct Case.
". . . that licenses the public performances of nondramatic musical works on behalf of the copyright owners . . ."
In the 1982-83 proceeding, ACEMLA attempted to show the efforts it had made to license the public performance of the music it controlled. 1982-83 ACEMLA Direct. Of the 18 letters either from ACEMLA to potential licensees, or to ACEMLA from potential licensees, only one letter was sent in 1982, and only one letter was received in 1984, the rest was correspondence occurring in 1985. Id.
The letter sent by ACEMLA in 1982 was to WXTV, Channel 41, a UHF television station in Paterson, New Jersey. Id., at 12. The letter received by ACEMLA in 1984 was from PBS acknowledging a letter dated September 4, 1984, asking ACEMLA for which ACEMLA-controlled music was used by public television in 1984. Id., at 21-22.
In the 1984 proceeding, ACEMLA submitted a letter to WADO Radio, New York, New York, soliciting WADO to obtain a license for ACEMLA-controlled music sent June 16, 1982. ACEMLA Direct, Ex. 2, p. 1. By letter dated January 29, 1986, WADO indicated a willingness to enter into a license agreement in the near future. Id., at 3.
However, in the period 1982-1984, ACEMLA did not license performing rights to anyone (radio station, television station, bar, grill, nightclub, college or school) for any purpose. 1982-83 Tr. 229; Tr. 142-143.
". . . such as the American Society of Composers, Authors and Publishers, Broadcast Music, Inc., and SESAC, Inc."
ASCAP, BMI and SESAC, Inc. have certain features as performing rights societies. Among them are, they have members or affiliates who authorize them in writing to license the use of the members' or affiliates' music. Performing rights societies are not copyright owners, but rather collect performing rights royalties as a service for the copyright owners. Music users are licensed by the societies, fees are collected and distributed to the copyright owners. The societies monitor the airwaves to ascertain if there are any unauthorized uses of their music. They bring infringement actions where necessary to enforce the rights of their members or affiliates. 1982-83 Tr. 120-121, 140-141, 150-151; Tr. 244.
For the period 1982-1984, ACEMLA did not license a single user, receive a single royalty, or make a single distribution. 1982-83 Tr. 183-184, 229-230; Tr. 141-143. ACEMLA has no standard rate schedule for licensees, 1982-83 Tr. 293. Bernard stated that although ACEMLA monitors five stations in the New York City area, ACEMLA has not brought any infringement actions. Tr. 140-145.
Conclusions of Law
ACEMLA was not a performing rights society in 1984
The Tribunal concluded in the 1982-83 proceeding that ACEMLA was not a performing rights society in 1982 or in 1983. The Tribunal found in that proceeding that Mr. Bernard had not taken any structural steps at all in 1982- 83 to create a performing rights society. In addition, the Tribunal found that Mr. Bernard's entity had none of the features of a performing rights society. It had not licensed a single user, received a single royalty, or made a single distribution. ACEMLA had brought no infringement actions. It had no members or affiliates. It had no written documents of transfers from any member or affiliate (not even LAMCO) to it as a performing rights society granting authorization to license music. It had no rate schedules to give to prospective licensees.
The situation in 1982-83, we concluded, was that Mr. Bernard, as president of LAMCO, a music publisher, had drafted a new letterhead, used the name ACEMLA, and sent out one letter (out of 18 letters he put into evidence) asking for a license and got no result. We described this as a situation devoid of any activity.
Having found both the form and the substance deficient, we resolved Mr. Bernard's only remaining argument--that a music publishing company could also be a performing rights society if it licensees performing rights. We stated in the 1982-83 decision that any holder of a copyright of music can license the performing rights to that music; but to declare that every entity which does so is a performing rights society would make a nullity of the distinction Congress made in Section 116 between copyright owners not affiliated with a performing rights society, and performing rights societies.
*43457 In the 1984 proceeding, there is very little changed circumstances. Mr. Bernard has submitted a certificate of assumed name filed with the state of New York on April 24, 1984 stating that the assumed name of LAMCO is ACEMLA. Mr. Bernard has also submitted another letter which ACEMLA sent out in 1982, and a draft of a contract between MUDOSA and ACEMLA subscribed in 1983.
We do not believe the device of "assumed name" is a structural step to create a performing rights society. The law and logic dictate that an assumed name is not a separate entity from its original name. They are taken as one and the same. Additionally, here the use of this device establishes a very difficult contradiction. Mr. Bernard claims that LAMCO is a music publisher, and that ACEMLA is a performing rights society, and that they must be considered quite different. But he also claims that ACEMLA is a corporation by virture of it being the assumed name of LAMCO, and he asserts that ACEMLA has obtained the rights to represent the music obtained by LAMCO without any transfer documents because ACEMLA and LAMCO are the same. Evidently sometimes ACEMLA is different than LAMCO and sometimes they are one and the same. We conclude that ACEMLA is simply another name for LAMCO, and that LAMCO is a music publishing company. Therefore, ACEMLA is a music publishing company. FOr this reason, and for the additional belief that the potential for self-dealing is evident from an "assumed name" set-up, we believe that "an association or corporation" was intended by Congress to mean an organization at least independent enough of copyright owners to have its own organizational papers and structure.
We also find that the substance of ACEMLA has not changed at all significantly from 1982-83. ACEMLA still lacks the features of a performing rights society.
The only new evidence of substance is the contract between MUDOSA and ACEMLA. However, we are not persuaded that that contract establishes that ACEMLA has enrolled any members or affiliates. Rather, we interpret that contract as being a subpublishing agreement with ACEMLA as the assumed name of LAMCO (and we note that it was subscribed in February, 1983, a time when the name ACEMLA could not be used by LAMCO because LAMCO had not filed a certificate of assumed name with the state of New York, reinforcing our belief that Mr. Bernard represents his entity to the public and the Tribunal in a confused way).
To put ACEMLA's assertion to be a performing rights society in the best, but most accurate, light, ACEMLA claims that it is a corporation by virtue of being the assumed name of LAMCO; that it holds itself out as licensing the performing rights of the music which LAMCO controls, but that it hasn't yet the features of the three performing rights societies, ASCAP, BMI, and SESAC, Inc. ACEMLA's argument that this makes it a performing rights society must fail. The Tribunal holds that for ACEMLA to prevail in its claim it must (1) be an association or corporation in its own right (2) it must license the performance of music, rather than merely hold itself out as licensing the performance of music; and (3) it must have the other features of a performing rights society.
To have the features of a performing rights society, and to have some success in the licensing of music is not to require that ACEMLA be "big." The Tribunal resolved the question of "bigness" in the last proceeding and considered it irrelevant. But the Tribunal does require some substance to the term, "performing rights society," in order to differentiate it from other entities, such as music publishing companies.
We caution that the Tribunal has not concluded more than what is necessary to decide this case, i.e., we have stated how any of the features of a performing rights society an organization must have, or which features are essential to be a performing rights society and which features are nonessential. Nor have we concluded how much success in the licensing of music an organization must have. We have simply concluded that based on the evidence submitted by ACEMLA, they have not sustained any success in licensing in 1982-1984, nor shown any of the other features of a performing rights society.
Finally, the Tribunal restates that the purpose for determining whether an organization before the Tribunal is a performing rights society is simply to determine the burden of going forward with the evidence. The Tribunal has no purpose in eigher regulating the field of performing rights societies, creating industry standards, or lowering or raising entry barriers. The Tribunal has only engaged in a definitional question, and intends that its decision will have no effect other than determining which party goes first in the presentation of its evidence. So the Tribunal has attempted to decide in this area with that narrow purpose in mind.
Effect of the Tribunal's First Conclusion
The Tribunal has concluded that ACEMLA was not a performing rights society in 1984, but rather that ACEMLA, as the assumed name of LAMCO, was a copyright owner. The next step is to consider the value of the music ACEMLA, as LAMCO, controls.
The Settling Parties have argued that ACEMLA has specifically filed its claim and appeared before the Tribunal solely as a performing rights society, that Mr. Bernard specifically excluded LAMCO, the music publisher which has the copyrights being valued, from his claim, so that if ACEMLA's claim to be a performing rights society fails, its claim to royalties must also fail.
The Tribunal does not agree with the Settling Parties in their view of the issue. We have concluded that ACEMLA is the assumed name of LAMCO, so that LAMCO and the repertory it represents has come before the Tribunal. Our conclusion that ACEMLA is not a performing rights society does not affect the valuation of the music ACEMLA, as the assumed name of LAMCO, controls, and we proceed to that consideration next.
ACEMLA's Proofs of Entitlement
In the 1984 proceeding, ACEMLA submitted three different types of evidence to prove its entitlement. It also incorporated by reference evidence submitted in the 1982-83 proceeding, including demographic evidence which ACEMLA relied upon in its proposed findings. ACEMLA Direct; ACEMLA Proposed Findings, paras. 12-15. In the 1982 proceeding ACEMLA asserted that it represented 20,000 copyrighted musical works. In the 1983 proceeding, ACEMLA asserted that it represented 30,000 musical works. In this proceeding ACEMLA asserted that it represents 50,000 or more musical works. 50 FR 47580; Tr. 62.
Jukebox title strips. ACEMLA Exhibit 3 consisted of copies of jukebox title strips provided to ACEMLA by Enrique Reyes, an employee of A-1 Record Sales, New York, New York, a company which distributes records to jukebox owners and operators. The exhibit purported to show 24 song titles which were sold to jukebox operators during 1984 and which are in ACEMLA's catalogue. ACEMLA Ex. 3. ACEMLA stated that it was its intent to support the exhibit with the affidavit of Enrique Reyes, but never provided the affidavit.
On cross-examination, Bernard was unable to recall when he obtained the jukebox title strips from Reyes. He said that he had acquired some within one *43458 month of filing ACEMLA's direct case, May 15, 1986, and others in 1985. Tr. 92-93. He was certain, however, that he did not acquire any of the jukebox title strips in 1984. Tr. 93. ACEMLA did not indicate in its exhibit which or how many jukebox operators recevied the title strips. ACEMAL Direct, at 2.
ACEMLA analysis of 1985 Jukebox survey. ACEMLA Exhibit 4 was an analysis of the underlying data of the "Limited Survey of 76 Jukeboxes in Hispanic Neighborhoods" performed by the Settling Parties during July and August, 1985, and submitted during the consolidated 1982-83 proceeding. ACEMLA Direct, at 3. Of the 11,592 song titles listed on the 76 jukeboxes in the survey, the Settling Parties asserted that 45 listings of 23 works were undisputedly represented by ACEMLA. 1982-83 Settling Parties Direct, Testimony of Gloria Messinger, at 8. The Settling Parties extrapolated from this finding an entitlement of approximately 0.02% for ACEMLA. Id.
ACEMLA disagreed with the Settling Parties' assertion. ACEMLA asserted in Exhibit 4 that, in fact, 509 listings of 352 compositions were in ACEMLA's catalogue. ACEMLA Ex. 4.
The method by which ACEMLA did its analysis was flawed. The exhibit was prepared by some of Bernard's employees who compared the titles listed in the "Limited Survey" with titles in the ACEMLA catalogue, noting the ones which they believed to be ACEMLA's. Tr. 76-77. This comparison was done on the basis of titles only. If the titles matched, the song was claimed by ACEMLA. Id. But Bernard conceded that many different songs may have the same title. Tr. 77.
In addition, although the "Limited Survey" identified the performing artists for each title listed in almost every case, ACEMLA did not use this information to identify the particular songs listed. Tr. 79-80. Bernard agreed that use of the performer information would have enabled more accurate identification of listings. Tr. 80.
In rebuttal, the Settling Parties testified that 129 of the 352 songs claimed by ACEMLA, and 189 of the 509 listings claimed by ACEMLA were works in the Settling Parties' combined repertories. SP Exs. 28R, 29R; Tr. 374.
Further, the Settling Parties disputed another 145 titles, representing 203 listings, because, going on titles alone, they were songs whose title could be found in both the ACEMLA and the Settling Parties combined repertories. Id. Although the Settling Parties did not positively claim those 145 titles, they stated that they had a majority of the songs with a particular title in their combined repertories. Tr. 371-374.
Hit songs charts. Hit songs charts from three regions, New York City, Miami, and Puerto Rico, and one national chart, Billboard, were submitted. ACEMLA Exs. 5-10. ACEMLA Exhibit 5 consisted of two hit Latin records charts for the months January 1984 through November 1984 from the publication "Canales," published in New York City. On the charts, ACEMLA circled which titles were in ACEMLA's catalogue. ACEMLA Direct, at 3. One of the charts, "Hit Parade Latino de Nueva York" listed top-selling singles. Tr. 116. However, the other chart, "Salsa: Los 12 Exitos," listed top-selling long-playing albums. Bernard could only represent that those were albums that contained at least one song in the ACEMLA catalogue. Id. The Tribunal requested ACEMLA to provide the titles of the individual compositions controlled by it appearing on long-playing albums listed in ACEMLA Exhibit 5, and additionally, in ACEMLA Exhibits 6, 7, 8, and 9. Id.
For ACEMLA Exhibit 5, ACEMLA identified specific songs for only 9 of the 18 albums circled by ACEMLA. ACEMLA Ex. 11. In those 9 albums, ACEMLA identified 12 songs, but one of them was never released as a single. Id. Only songs released as singles are played on jukeboxes. Tr. 300.
ACEMLA Exhibit 6 consisted of pages from the publication, "Guia Radial del Show," weekly published in Puerto Rico. It contained two hit records charts from January through December, 1984, compiled by the Music City Record store in Puerto Rico. ACEMLA circled which titles were in ACEMLA's catalogue. ACEMLA Direct, at 3. All titles on those charts were singles, not albums. Response of ACEMLA to Tribunal's Requests for Additional Documents Supporting ACEMLA's Direct Case, at 5.
ACEMLA Exhibit 7 consisted of the "Hit Parade Hispano of the United States," which appeared in the May 5, 1984 edition of "23 Milliones," an Hispanic publication published in Miami, Florida. ACEMLA circled 4 titles which were in ACEMLA's catalogue. ACEMLA Direct, at 4. However, Bernard conceded these were actually albums, not singles, and in response to a request to provide the titles to the singles, ACEMLA could specify songs for only 3 of the 7 albums listed in Exhibit 7. These 3 albums contained 4 songs in ACEMLA's catalogue, but all four songs were not released as singles, so jukebox play of these songs could not have occurred. ACEMLA Ex. 12; Tr. 300.
ACEMLA Exhibit 8 consisted of hit records charts which appeared in the publication, "Farandula," published in New York and Puerto Rico, in May and December, 1984. ACEMLA Ex. 8. Again, in response to Tribunal inquiry, ACEMLA identified specific songs for 8 of the 11 albums listed in Exhibit 8. ACEMLA Ex. 13. These 8 albums contained 13 songs in ACEMLA's catalogue, but 6 of the 13 songs were not released as singles. ACEMLA Ex. 13.
ACEMLA Exhibit 9 consisted of charts for Latin long-playing records which appeared in Billboard Magazine from January to September, 1984. ACEMLA Ex. 9. ACEMLA identified specific songs for 23 of the 32 albums listed in Exhibit 9. ACEMLA Ex. 14. These 23 albums contained 36 songs, but 9 of the songs were not released as singles. ACEMLA Ex. 14.
In all, in Exhibits 5, 7, 8, and 9, ACEMLA listed 65 albums, including duplicate listings. However, ultimately, ACEMLA identified only 33 separate songs (out of 45 listings) having been released as 45 RPM singles. ACEMLA Exs. 11-14.
ACEMLA Exhibit 10 included hit records charts distributed by radio station WJIT, a Spanish-language station in New York City. The lists were dated January, March, April, and December, 1984. ACEMLA circled which titles were in ACEMLA's catalogue. ACEMLA Direct, at 4.
Settling Parties' Rebuttal
The Settling Parties sought to rebut the value of the ACEMLA catalogue by challenging the representation by ACEMLA that its most-performed songs were actually in ACEMLA's catalogue. SP Exs. 15R-18R.
The Settling Parties analyzed 261 titles claimed by ACEMLA. The 261 titles represented the 179 songs ACEMLA lsited in the 1982-83 proceeding which were its most performed songs, plus every additional title listed by ACEMLA in all its exhibits in the 1984 proceeding. SP Ex. 15R. The list of 261 titles was submitted to the Copyright Office for a search of registrations. Tr. 359. At the time the Settling Parties submitted the list of 261 titles to the Copyright Office, they did not know that the circled items in Exs. 5-8 were sometimes album titles, instead of song titles. This occurred in 40 instances, so that the actual total individual songs identified by ACEMLA in the 1982-1984 proceeding were 221. SP Ex. 16R.
Of the 221 titles, the Settling Parties found Copyright Office registrations for 21 songs which placed them in the Settling Parties combined catalogue. SP Ex. 18R. Later, at hearing the Settling *43459 Parties also disputed the song, "Golpe Con Golpe." Tr. 489-492.
The Copyright Office found no registrations for 171 of the song titles. SP Ex. 19R. The Office found 8 titles registered in the name of Latin American Music Co., Inc. SP Ex. 21R. 21 titles were registered at the Copyright Office, however, the author, publisher and performer information was different from that provided by ACEMLA, so that the only thing that was in common was the song titles. SP Ex. 20R. Bernard stated that he had registered over 100 song titles with the Copyright Office. Tr. 108.
ACEMLA was given an opportunity at surrebuttal on the issue of their right to represent the 21 above-mentioned titles plus "Golpe Con Golpe." ACEMLA yielded on 6 of the titles, "Cerveza Humo Y Licor," "El Gusto," "La Verdad," "Mala Muger," "Mi Ultima Cancion," "Oh Puerto Rico." Certain of ACEMLA's explanations failed to surrebut the Settling Parties' contentions. For "Caballo Viejo" and "La Banana," these songs were allegedly transferred to West Side Music Publishing, Inc. which in turn were assigned to ACEMLA, but the registration certificates only show West Side Publishing as an addressee for correspondence, and that Selemusica, C.A. is the copyright owner. The Settling Parties showed that Selemusica, C.A. conveyed its rights to Barnegat Music Corp, an ASCAP member. ACEMLA Ex. 18, Att. B, at 1-2; SP Ex. 42R, at 4-7. For the songs, "El Bailador," and "Golpe Con Golpe," ACEMLA only showed evidence regarding mechanical rights, but did not show anything regarding performing rights. ACEMLA Ex. 18, at 4-5, 10. For "El Cachimbo," since the composer had conveyed his performing rights to LAMCO/ACEMLA by a contract dated July 27, 1985, and had represented that all his works were previously unpublished, no distribution to jukeboxes in 1984 could have occurred, because that would have constituted publication. ACEMLA Ex. 18, at 5; 17 U.S.C. 101.
Settling Parties' Radio Surveys. For the 1984 proceeding, as they had done in the 1982-83 proceeding, the Settling Parties offered into evidence ACEMLA's track record of performances on radio. According to ASCAP's methodology, if ACEMLA had been an ASCAP member in 1982-84, it would have earned 2,989 radio credits for 1982; 2,648 radio credits for 1983; and 3,053 radio credits for 1984. The 1984 results were based on the 200 titles described above. The 1982 and 1983 results were based on the 179 titles submitted in the 1982-83 proceeding. Total radio credits earned by all ASCAP members were 13,320,833 in 1982; 14,263,660 in 1983; and 14,784,981 in 1984. Therefore, ACEMLA's radio credits as a percentage of all ASCAP radio credits were: 1982-- 0.02244%; 1983--0.01856%; 1984--0.02065%. Settling Parties Rebuttal, Testimony of Paul S. Adler, at 12-15.
BMI used the same parameters as ASCAP did in its study. BMI determined that if the earnings of ACEMLA's 200 claimed songs had been part of BMI's distribution for 1984, they would have accounted for 0.00185% of BMI's distribution for radio performances. Settling Parties Rebuttal, Testimony of Alan H. Smith, at 4-6. This compares with BMI's surveys for 1982 and 1983 which yielded a result of 0.002517%, and 0.003319%, respectively. Comments of ASCAP, BMI and SESAC, filed September 3, 1985, at 6-7.
Conclusions of Law--ACEMLA's entitlement
It is the Tribunal's conclusion that ACEMLA, appearing before the Tribunal as the assumed name of LAMCO, has shown entitlement to 0.06% of the 1984 jukebox royalty fund.
In the 1982-83 proceeding, the Tribunal stated the elements which LAMCO had shown which indicated to us that it merited some award (it was then LAMCO being considered because LAMCO had not yet filed its certificate of assumed name). LAMCO showed that: "it has agreements with some foreign entities; that it has a catalogue of thousands of songs; that it has demonstrated the production and distribution of some of its songs on 45 rpm records; it has demonstrated some popularity of its songs on hit songs charts" and that the Settling Parties had shown "that there has been some air play and some jukebox play of LAM(CO)'s songs." 50 FR 47582.
But we expressed immediately thereafter that although recognizing that some entitlement had been established, we were faced with the impossibility of determining a perfectly accurate mathematical approach. We began with the Settling Parties' radio surveys and their limited jukebox survey. ASCAP's radio survey would have given LAMCO approximately 0.02% entitlement; BMI's radio survey would have given LAMCO approximately 0.003% entitlement. The limited jukebox survey would have given LAMCO approximately 0.02% entitlement. However, we stated our belief that the radio surveys did not establish a direct relevance to jukebox play and could only be used by analogy, and we recognized too, that the Settling Parties' joint limited jukebox survey had imperfections.
We, therefore, made an award to LAMCO of 0.15%, which was several times higher than the numerical evidence offered by the Settling Parties, choosing to resolve most of the problematical parts of the record in LAMCO's favor. We did this given the very fragmentary state of the record, and the difficulties of being precise in this area. However, we stated, "we expect that better efforts and better evidence will be attained in future proceedings." 50 FR 47582.
It is our belief that despite the opportunities afforded ACEMLA, that not only has there been no improvement in the record in the 1984 proceeding, rather, the record is weaker than in 1982-83. ACEMLA has submitted three types of evidence: the jukebox title strips, their analysis of the limited jukebox survey, and the hit songs charts for 1984. [FN1]
FN1 In addition to this new evidence, ACEMLA incorporated by reference all the evidence of previous proceedings. Much of this related to 1982-83 which would be of limited relevance to our 1984 analysis. For ACEMLA's reintroduction of earlier demographic evidence, without any new facts or analyses, we restate our conclusion in last year's proceeding that general demgraphic evidence on Spanish-language music in the United States is not specifically probative of ACEMLA's claim. 50 FR 47580.
The exhibit on the jukebox title strips lacked any utility for the Tribunal. ACEMLA did not obtain the affidavit it promised to support the exhibit. ACELMA did not indicate in its exhibit which or how many jukebox operators used the jukebox title strips, and on cross-examination, it was learned tht the jukebox title strips were supplied to ACEMLA in 1986 or 1985, not in 1984, and no relevance to 1984 was established.
ACEMLA's analysis of the limited jukebox survey was careless and inaccurate. ACEMLA resolved every doubt that the ownership of a song in favor of ACEMLA by looking at titles alone, when many songs are known to have the same title. ACEMLA ended up claiming a numbers of songs which were in the Settling Parties' cataglogues, and because of the time limitations of our proceedings, many other songs were left in a state of dispute between ACEMLA and the Settling Parties. However, ACEMLA's analysis of the limited jukebox survey can be afforded some credit because it did rebut somewhat the Settling Parties' view that there were only 45 listings of 23 songs in the jukebox survey which were in ACEMLA's catalogue. However, it was our view last year that there were *43460 probably more ACEMLA works in the limited survey than the number if works determined by the Settling Parties. This view was one of the problematical parts of the record which we resolved in ACEMLA's favor in the last proceeding.
The hit songs charts submitted by ACEMLA continue to have some validity and tend to show that ACEMLA has some entitlement to the jukebox fund. However we note several things: ACEMLA's level of activity on the hit songs charts has remained the same as in 1982-83, so no more has been shown in this proceeding than in last proceeding. Further, we learned this year that a number of this year's charts and one of last year's charts did not represent 45 rpm records, but rather albums in which ACEMLA had a song or two. The activity of albums on hit records charts has only a tenuous connection with jukebox play. It is not known which are the songs on the albums which are responsible for the album's popularity, and which songs are not. We also observe that, for albums, it is not known, unless further proof is made, which songs are released as singles and are therefore eligible for jukebox play. Last, the Settling Parties raised challenges which were successful to the right of ACEMLA to represent some of its songs, and, as in the case of "La Banana," and "Caballo Viejo," songs appearing on the hit songs charts, it affected the probity of the charts.
Far from any perception that the state of the record has improved, the state of the record has noticeably declined. We note our frustration at the manner of the proofs offered by ACEMLA over the past two proceedings. Incompletion. The state of many of ACEMLA's exhibits were incomplete. We have already recited the example of the jukebox title strips. We also note the incomplete state of the certificate of assumed name exhibits in both the 1982-83 proceeding and the 1984 proceeding, and other examples exist as well. Relation back. ACEMLA exhibits often involved events taking place in 1985 or 1986, yet the Tribunal was not clearly informed of this. ACEMLA filed 18 letters in one exhibit to show the activity it had engaged in to license its music, yet only one letter was sent in the years in question, 1982-83. The jukebox title strips were delivered to ACEMLA in 1985-86, but we have no evidence that they were used in jukeboxes in 1984. Photocopies of 45 rpm records were offered in the 1982-83 proceeding, but some of them were copyrighted in 1984. Where something occurs in a year subsequent to the year in question, it must be clearly stated in the testimony so that the relevance can be ascertained, as the Settling Parties did when they submitted the limited jukebox survey they conducted in 1985. Inflation or exaggeration. Finally, we perceived claims which were inflated or exaggerated. (1) Many album listings were circled, when only some of them contained ACEMLA-represented singles; (2) the Settling Parties successfully rebutted ACEMLA's right to represent many of ACEMLA's claimed songs; (3) ACEMLA claimed to have registered over 100 songs, yet so far only 8 have been found; (4) The 1982-83 exhibit of photocopied 45 rpm singles was submitted with many duplicates of the same songs; (5) ACEMLA claimed in the 1982 proceeding to have 20,000 titles, in the 1983 proceeding to have 30,000 titles, and in the 1984 proceeding to have 50,000 titles or more. While not being able to contradict this, we find we cannot give the benefit of the doubt to this last unsubstantiated claim, because ACEMLA has so often been rebutted on many of its other assertions.
It is not our inclination to fault small claimants, but we believe these patterns must be noted, because the resources of the Tribunal are not intended to be used to sort out a poorly constructed record. It is our view in all proceedings that the burden of persuasion is on the claimant, but it is particularly true for ACEMLA because of the manner of its evidence and testimony.
Therefore, the Trubunal believes that the record has declined this year, and that many of the doubts we resolved in ACEMLA's favor in the last proceeding will not be resolved in its favor in this proceeding.
We have determined to allocate 0.06% of the jukebox fund to ACEMLA, an amount approximately three times higher than the levels recommended by the Settling Parties. We retain doubts about the Settling Parties' recommended level, because the play of music in ethnic neighborhoods on jukeboxes, we believe, is of a different nature than radio play. We also have been satisfied by ACEMLA's assertion that the Settling Parties' determination of 45 listings of 23 songs in the jukebox survey may have been too low. In any event, given the limited nature of the 1982-83 jukebux survey, we believe that the mathematical range of error should be resolved in ACEMLA's favor.
Allocations
Accordingly, the Tribunal awards 0.06% of the 1984 jukebox royalty fund to ACEMLA as the assumed name of Latin American Music Co., Inc. The remainder of the fund is awarded to ASCAP, BMI, and SESAC, Inc.
Dated: November 25, 1986.
Edward W. Ray,
Chairman.
[FR Doc. 86-27003 Filed 12-1-86; 8:45 am]
Please refer to the IP Mall Copyright Royalty Tribunal homepage for details on this valuable resource.