NOTICES
COPYRIGHT ROYALTY TRIBUNAL
[Docket No. CRT 85-3-85CA]
Adjustment of Cable Copyright Royalty Rates
Monday, October 28, 1985
*43605 On March 25, 1985, a petition was filed with the Copyright Royalty Tribunal by Turner Broadcasting System, Inc. (TBS) to commence a proceeding solely for the purpose of adjusting the cable compulsory license royalty rate for carriage of WTBS, Atlanta, Georgia in certain circumstances. On April 8, 1985, the Motion Picture Association of America, Inc. (MPAA) requested the Tribunal to establish a notice and comment procedure for resolving preliminary questions presented by the TBS petition. The Tribunal granted the motion and established a comment period ending July 8, 1985, and a reply comment period ending August 8, 1985. Notice of Inquiry, 50 FR 23349 (June 3, 1985).
One of the questions which the Tribunal requested comment was whether TBS has the requisite "significant interest" to initiate a cable royalty proceeding. Section 804(a)(2) of the Copyright Act states that "During the calendar years specified in the following schedule any owner or user of a copyrighted work whose royalty rates are specified by this title, or by a rate established by the Tribunal, may file a petition with the Tribunal declaring that the petitioner requests an adjustment of the rate. The Tribunal shall make a determination as to whether the applicant has a significant interest in the royalty rate in which an adjustment is requested. If the Tribunal determines that the petitioner has a significant interest, the Chairman shall cause notice of this determination, with the persons therefor, to be published in the Federal Register, together with notice of commencement of proceedings under this chapter."
The Tribunal received comments from the MPAA and from ASCAP, BMI, and SESAC, Inc. asserting that TBS does not have a significant interest.
Major League Baseball, the National Basketball Association and the National Hockey League (Professional Sports Leagues) commented on the timetable of a TBS proceeding should the Tribunal find the requisite "significant interest." They argue that the copyright owners who would have a substantial interest in a TBS proceeding are currently involved in the 1983 cable royalty distribution proceeding, which is consuming a substantial amount of time and resources of the copyright owners and of the Tribunal, and that the commencement of a TBS proceeding should be scheduled after the 1983 cable distribution proceeding has been substantially completed. They also argue that efforts are currently underway to negotiate an industry-wide compromise concerning the cable royalty rates and might render unnecessary the need for any cable rate adjustment proceeding before the Tribunal. Third, the Tribunal may find it inefficient to initiate a proceeding to deal solely with the TBS petition. In the view of the Professional Sports Leagues, it would be more efficient to await the filing of other petitions during the calendar year of 1985 and hold one consolidated proceeding dealing with all issues.
The Tribunal agrees with all three points raised by the Professional Sports Leagues. The direct case of the 1983 cable distribution proceeding ended on October 11. The rebuttal cases are due to be heard beginning November 18 and ending about December 20. Between October 11 and November 18, the Tribunal has scheduled its consideration and rendering of a final determination of the consolidated 1982 (remand) and 1983 jukebox distribution proceedings.
The Tribunal has decided to defer ruling to January 1986 on whether TBS has a "significant interest" in the copyright royalty rate. The Tribunal intends to afford all parties the full extent of calendar year 1985 to reach either a negotiated settlement, or file additional petitions. Determinations of whether any of the petitioners have a "significant interest," whether petitions should be consolidated or considered separately, and what procedures might govern the consideration of the petitions will be made in 1986.
Statutory Construction Problem
Section 804(a)(2) states that an owner or a user may petition the Tribunal, "during the calendar years specified in the following schedule. . ." Section 804(b) states, "Any change in royalty rates made by the Tribunal pursuant to this subsection may be reconsidered in 1980, 1985, and each fifty calendar year thereafter, . . ." There is a potential conflict between these sections because to give full force to section 804(a)(2) means that a petitioner may file up to December 31, 1985. However, a literal reading of section 804(b) would require a reconsideration of the cable rate at least to begin in 1985. It would not be possible for the Tribunal to consider a petition and initiate a proceeding in 1985 if a petitioner waited until mid or late December to file.
*43606 The Tribunal proposes to favor section 804(a)(2) over section 804(b) and intends to give all interested petitioners until December 31 to file with the Tribunal. We do this given the very apparent reality that the major parties are attempting to negotiate a settlement and may need as much time as we can afford to give them under the law. If any party believes that this construction of the Copyright Act is improper, the Tribunal orders that petitions for reconsideration shall be filed by November 22, 1985,
Edward W. Ray,
Acting Chairman.
October 23, 1985.
[FR Doc. 85-25620 Filed 10-25-85; 8:45 am]
Please refer to the IP Mall Copyright Royalty Tribunal homepage for details on this valuable resource.