NOTICES
COPYRIGHT ROYALTY TRIBUNAL
[Docket No. CRT 87-2-85CD]
1985 Cable Royalty Distribution Proceeding
Friday, March 4, 1988
*7132 AGENCY: Copyright Royalty Tribunal.
ACTION: Notice of final determination.
SUMMARY: The Copyright Royalty Tribunal announces the adoption of its final determination in the proceeding concerning the distribution to certain copyright owners of royalty fees paid by cable systems for secondary transmissions during 1985.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Robert Cassler, General Counsel, Copyright Royalty Tribunal, 1111 20th St. NW., Suite 450, Washington, DC 20036, (202-653- 5175).
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
Authority
Section 111(d)(3) of the Copyright Act, as amended August 27, 1987, authorizes the Copyright Royalty Tribunal to distribute annually royalty fees paid by cable systems to those among the following copyright owners who claim that their works were the subject of secondary transmissions by cable systems during the relevant semiannual period:
(A) Any such owner whose work was included in a secondary transmission made by a cable system of a nonnetwork television program in whole or in part beyond the local service area of the primary transmitter; and
(B) Any such owner whose work was included in a secondary transmission identified in a special statement of account deposited under paragraph (1)(A); and
(C) Any such owner whose work was included in nonnetwork programming consisting of aural signals carried by a cable system in whole or in part beyond the local service area of the primary transmitter of such programs.
This Proceeding
In this proceeding, the Tribunal takes up the distribution of the royalty fees deposited by cable operators for the calendar year 1985. In accordance with past procedure, the Tribunal resolved that the 1985 distribution proceeding would be conducted in two phases. In Phase I, the Tribunal would determine the allocation of cable royalties among various program categories of claimants. The Phase I categories were: Program Suppliers, Sports, Public Broadcasting Service, U.S. Commercial Television, Music, Devotional Programs, Canadian Programs, Noncommercial Radio and Commercial Radio. In Phase II, the Tribunal would allocate cable royalties to individual claimants within a program category.
For this 1985 proceeding, there were no controversies in Phase I. All Phase I parties settled based upon the allocations made by the Tribunal in the 1983 cable distribution proceeding. (The 1984 Phase I controversy was similarly settled on the basis of the 1983 allocations.) In Phase II, there were three controversies.
Controversy one: Within the Program Suppliers category, two parties advanced claims which, when combined, exceeded 100% of the category. The Motion Picture Association of America, Inc. (MPAA) claimed 99.74%. Multimedia Entertainment, Inc. (Multimedia) claimed 1.1%.
Controversy two: Within the Music category, the American Society of Composers, Authors and Publishers (ASCAP), Broadcast Music, Inc. (BMI), and SESAC, Inc. (SESAC) jointly claimed 100%. Asociacion de Compositores y Editores de Musica Latinoamericana (ACEMLA) claimed 1.235%.
Controversy three: In the 1984 proceeding, both the National Broadcasting Company (NBC) and Worldvision Enterprises, Inc. (Worldvision) claimed the royalties attributable to secondary transmissions of "Little House on the Prairie." The Tribunal determined that Worldvision was the proper claimant. NBC appealed the Tribunal's determination. In this proceeding, NBC and Worldvision have again claimed for "Little House on the Prairie," but have agreed that whatever disposition the Court of Appeals renders in the appeal of the 1984 determination shall apply as well to the 1985 royalties. Consequently, no new evidence was introduced regarding "Little House on the Prairie" in this proceeding.
Background and Chronology
Six hundred and ninety-six (696) individual or joint claims were filed with the Tribunal for the 1985 cable royalty fund. On January 13, 1987, the Tribunal published a notice directing all claimants to inform the Tribunal by March 2, 1987 whether a controversy existed with regard to the distribution of the 1985 cable copyright royalty fees. 52 FR 1373.
In response to a request filed by the Phase I claimants, the Tribunal ordered an extension of the date for controversy comments to 15 days after publication in the Federal Register of the Tribunal's determination of the Phase II controversies of the 1984 cable distribution, which turned out to be April 1, 1987. Order dated February 27, 1987.
Based upon the written comments filed April 1, 1987, the Tribunal concluded that controversies existed regarding the distribution of the 1985 cable copyright royalty fees, both in Phase I and in Phase II of the proceeding, effective April 22, 1987. The Tribunal ordered that written direct cases in Phase I be filed by June 22, 1987. 52 FR 13118 (April 21, 1987).
On July 2, 1987, after having requested the Tribunal to postpone the filing of written direct cases due to settlement negotiations, the Phase I claimants notified the Tribunal that they had reached a settlement of all Phase I controversies, and that they had agreed to accept the same Phase I shares as had been allocated in the Tribunal's final determination in the 1983 cable distribution proceeding. Consequently, the Tribunal published a notice terminating Phase I of the 1985 cable royalty proceeding. 52 FR 27044 (July 17, 1987).
At the same time, the Tribunal ordered a complete distribution of 1985 cable royalties for all Phase I categories, except Music and Devotional, reserving such amounts as was deemed necessary to resolve the remaining Phase II controversies in those categories. Although there was a controversy within the Program Suppliers category, a 100% distribution of the royalties in that category was ordered based upon the stipulation by the parties that in the event any party received an excess amount, that party would refund to the Tribunal the difference plus the interest that would have accrued had that amount remained in the 1985 royalty fund. Id.
On September 2, 1987, the Tribunal ordered written direct cases in the MPAA-Multimedia controversy to be filed by October 6, 1987, and all other direct cases to be filed by October 5, 1987.
On October 5, 1987, ASCAP, BMI and SESAC filed their joint written direct case, and ACEMLA filed its written direct case in the Music controversy. No written direct cases were filed in the Devotional category, the Tribunal having been notified by that date that all the claimants in the Devotional category had agreed upon a division of the royalties among themselves.
The hearing of the direct cases in the Music controversy took place on October 20, 1987. ASCAP, BMI and SESAC filed their joint rebuttal case on October 30, 1987. ACEMLA did not submit a rebuttal case. The hearing of the ASCAP, BMI and SESAC rebuttal case took place on November 10, 1987.
*7133 The hearing of the direct case in the Program Suppliers controversy took place November 4, 5, and 10, 1987. Written rebuttal cases were filed November 16, 1987, and hearings on those cases took place November 23 and 24, 1987.
The Music claimants filed their Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law on December 4, 1987. The Reply Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law were filed on December 11, 1987.
The Program Suppliers claimants filed their Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law on December 11, 1987. The Reply Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law were filed on December 18, 1987.
Controversy One: MPAA and Multimedia
Findings of Fact
The claimants. MPAA is a trade association which represents 94 producers and/or syndicators of syndicated movies, television series and specials. MPAA Ex. 1. Collectively, the 94 claimants seek the cable royalties attributable to 5,954 different syndicated series, movies and specials representing 503,221 quarter-hours of programming on 104 commercial broadcast stations which were retransmitted by cable systems in 1985. Test. of Allen Cooper, pp. 6-7; MPAA Ex. 4.
Multimedia is the producer and syndicator of the following programs: "Donahue"--260 hours of news/interview programs, including 210 original programs, and 50 repeat programs in 1985; "Sally Jessy Raphael"--260 half-hours of interview/talk programs, including 225 original programs and 35 repeat programs in 1985; "Pop! Goes the Country"--36 half-hour country music programs; "Music City U.S.A."--38 half-hour country music programs; "New Music City U.S.A."--14 half-hour country music programs; "Young People Specials"--10 half-hour children's features: "My Mother the Witch," "The Day Dad Got Fired," "Buddies," "Crazy Carlita" (original and repeat), "Danny & the Killer Rain," "That Funny Fat Kid," "Zerk the Jerk," "My First Swedish Bombshell," and "A Christmas Story" (six of these were first-run programs in 1985); "Music and Entertainment Specials"--six prime time country music specials and one entertainment special, including: "19th Annual Music City News Country Awards," "5th Annual Top Country Hits," "Family Affair: Osmonds' 25th Anniversary," "Statlers' Christmas Present," "Winning Hand" (original and repeat), and "American Beauty Search." Multimedia-owned broadcast stations also produced and distributed "Robbins Report," a bimonthly show, 20 sports related shows and three holiday programs. Test. of Richard Thrall, pp. 3-5.
MPAA's claim. As a part of its case for several distribution proceedings, MPAA has commissioned a special Nielsen study to prove its entitlement. 47 FR 9880; 48 FR 9554; 51 FR 12794; 52 FR 8416. The study measures the hours of distant signal nonnetwork programming which are viewed by cable households. Id.
For this proceeding, MPAA selected to be included in the Nielsen study all U.S. commercial television broadcast stations which reached a minimum average of 100,000 cable subscribers, as determined from the statement of accounts filed by the cable systems during the two semiannual accounting periods of 1985. Test. of Allen Cooper, p. 3. A total of 104 commercial stations met MPAA's criteria: 64 network-affiliates stations, and 40 independent stations (including 2 Spanish-language specialty stations). Id. The 104 broadcast stations account for 86.5% of all distant signal carriage of U.S. commercial programs by Form 3 cable systems. Id., p. 4.
MPAA commissioned the A.C. Nielsen Company to provide data derived from the Nielsen Station Index (NSI) surveys conducted during January, February, May, July, October and November, 1985. The NSI surveys encompass a four-week period during each of these six months. The February, May and November surveys provide data for all stations in all markets. The July survey measures the viewing of stations in 203 of the 219 markets. The January and October surveys are limited to stations in major markets only--23 in October and 17 in January. The markets surveyed in October cover 45.6% of all U.S. television households; the January markets encompass 38.1% of all households. The data developed by Nielsen during all six survey periods are projected to reflect national audiences. Id., pp. 2-3.
The 104 broadcast stations designated for the special Nielsen study broadcasted a total of 750,178 quarter-hours of nonnetwork programming during the survey periods. (Nielsen surveys exclude programs broadcast between 2:00 a.m. and 6:00 a.m., Monday-Friday, and between 2:00 a.m. and 7:00 a.m. on Saturday and Sunday.) Total household viewing hours of distant signal programs in cable households exceeded 3.1 billion. Of these totals, programs classified by Nielsen upon instruction from MPAA as syndicated series, specials and movies accounted for 574,213 quarter-hours of programming and 2,578,642,581 household viewing hours. Id., p. 5.
Of the 2,578,642,581 household viewing hours, the household viewing hours attributable to the MPAA-represented claimants were 2,451,567,190, and the household viewing hours attributable to Multimedia's programs were 6,388,437. Id., p. 7; MPAA Ex. 4R. In terms of percentages, MPAA has 99.74% and Multimedia has 0.26% of the total of viewing hours attributable to MPAA and Multimedia programs. Id.
In the 1984 proceeding, Multimedia's programs were measured to have garnered 6,376,193 household viewing hours, or 0.266% of the total of all household viewing hours attributable to 1984 Phase II claimants. 52 FR 8417. The MPAA, representing 86 claimants for 5,796 works, were measured to have achieved 2,381,600,000 household viewing hours. Id.
In the 1983 proceeding, Multimedia's programs were measured to have garnered 7,998,202 household viewing hours, or 0.358% of the total of all household viewing hours attributable to 1983 Phase II claimants. 51 FR 12817. The MPAA, representing 83 claimants for 6,008 works, were measured to have achieved 2,217,169,720 household viewing hours. Id.
MPAA contends that the distribution methodology it has devised for the claimants it represents, based upon the special Nielsen study, should be applied by the Tribunal to all claimants, because, in MPAA's view, the special Nielsen study objectively reflects the criteria enunciated by the Tribunal for assessing the relative value of the programs the claimants own. Test. of Allen Cooper, p. 8. Consequently, MPAA believes that it has shown entitlement to 99.74 of the Phase II royalties, and Multimedia has shown entitlement to 0.26%. Reb. Test. of Allen Cooper, p. 13.
Criticisms of Nielsen Study. Multimedia disagrees with MPAA's contention that the Nielsen study should be the sole basis for the Tribunal's allocation. Multimedia argues that the Nielsen study is statistically flawed, which flaws are particularly detrimental to Multimedia's claim, and further that the Nielsen study is not directly relevant to the Tribunal's stated criteria. Reb. Test. of Richard Thrall, pp. 2-10.
Statistical flaws. The Nielsen study is not a census of all cable household viewing of all distant-signal programs. Only the viewing of those programs shown on broadcast signals reaching a minimum average of 100,000 cable households are measured. The 104 broadcast stations used for the 1985 *7134 special study account for 86.5% of all distant signal carriage of U.S. commercial programs by Form 3 cable systems. Test. of Allen Cooper, p. 4.
The Nielsen study does not measure every program aired by the 104 broadcast stations. Only those programs broadcast during the four sweep periods and the two partial sweep periods were measured. The partial sweep in October covered 45.6% of all television households; the partial sweep in January covered 38.1% of all television households. Id., pp. 2-3. Giving the October partial sweep 45.6% credit, and the January partial sweep 38.1% credit, the Nielsen study measures 37.2% of the year's programming on the average selected broadcast station. (16 full sweep weeks plus 1.824 weeks in October, and 1.524 weeks in January divided by 52 weeks in a year.)
Combining the testimony that the 104 measured broadcast stations account for 86.5% of distant signal carriage of U.S. commercial programs by Form 3 cable systems, and that the study measures 37.2% of the programming on those stations, the special Nielsen study measures 32.2% of all distant signal programming carried by Form 3 cable systems (86.5% x 37.2%).
Multimedia listed in its evidentiary showing its 16 specials, the broadcast stations on which they were aired, when they were aired, which cable systems carried them, and the number of subscribers to those systems. Multimedia Exs. 16-20. Multimedia performed an analysis of the total number of instances of carriage multiplied by Form 3 cable subscribers of Multimedia programs which occurred during 1985 versus the number of instances of carriage multiplied by Form 3 cable subscribers which the Nielsen study measured. Multimedia Ex. R-2. The number of instances of carriage times Form 3 cable subscribers which the Nielsen study measured (15,190,583) was 11.4% of the total number of 1985 instances of carriage times cable subscribers (133,336,682). Id. Consequently, Multimedia argues that its specials were significantly undermeasured by the 1985 special Nielsen study.
The Nielsen study does not measure viewing by cable subscribers of Form 1 and Form 2 cable systems (those systems grossing less than $292,000 per half-year). Test. of Allen Cooper, p. 3. According to Multimedia's research, approximately 4.6 million cable subscribers of Form 1 and Form 2 cable systems received Multimedia programming on a distant signal basis. Tr. 135; Multimedia Ex. 18. Less than 3% of copyrignt royalty payments are attributable to Form 1 and Form 2 cable system. 51 FR 12796.
The Nielsen projections of household viewing hours are based on diary entries. The sample diaries are projected to the universe of cable viewing, but the MPAA does not give a statistical error or reliability factor for the resulting total viewing hours. Multimedia argues that because the Nielsen study lacks a statistical error factor, MPAA cannot say that the 1985 Multimedia Nielsen figures are absolutely correct, nor can they say that the 1983, 1984 or 1985 viewing hour totals for Multimedia are in fact materially different. Multimedia Reply Proposed Findings, p. 5.
Multimedia repeated its contention raised in previous proceedings that the Nielsen diary system is seriously flawed. Reb. Test. of Richard Thrall, p. 8. Criticisms of the Nielsen diary system which appeared in articles in Forbes, Broadcasting Magazine, The Washington Post, The New York Times and other publications were submitted by Multimedia. Multimedia Ex. R-6. The concerns raised in these articles relate to the Nielsen Television Index (NTI) study, and in particular the NAC portion of that study. The NAC measures audience demographics based on a fixed, constant sample of about 600 households. Tr. 561. These demographics are later merged with the NTI meter results from about 1800 households to give the audience composition of those watching the programs. Tr. 561-562. The MPAA-Nielsen study relies upon Nielsen Station Index (NSI) diary information which relies upon approximately 450,000 in-tab diaries (some of which are rejected when believed to be inaccurate or incomplete). Test. of Allen Cooper, p. 3. None of the articles submitted by Multimedia addresses the validity of the NSI diaries. Tr. 563-564.
Multimedia sought to show that MPAA's instructions to the Nielsen company regarding which counties were distant and which were local were often in error. Reb. Test. of Richard Thrall, pp. 8-9. However, on cross-examination, it was shown that in every instance raised by Multimedia, MPAA had correctly identified the distant counties and the local counties in its instructions to Nielsen. Tr. 529-37; MPAA Exs. 1RX-4RX.
Multimedia also sought to establish that in the great volume of data generated by the Nielsen study, six volumes of almost 2,700 papers containing more than 64,000 individual entries, there were numerous errors, such as several of the series airing on WTBS having the same time and date entry. Multimedia R. Ex. 7. On cross-examination, it was shown that although there were three programs in the May, 1985 data listed for the 7:30 a.m. time slot, there were no programs listed in the 8:00 a.m. or 8:30 a.m. time slots. MPAA Ex. 7RX. MPAA contends this shows that although there were some data errors, they did not result in doublecounting, and were later corrected when the data was reviewed and verified by Cable Data Corporation, MPAA and the individual claimants. MPAA Reply Findings, pp. 21-22. Test. of Marsha Kessler, pp. 8-9, 11-16.
Relevance of Nielsen study. Multimedia contends that the Nielsen study is not relevant to at least two of the Tribunal's criteria for valuating claims: quality and marketplace value. Reb. Test. of Richard Thrall, pp. 4- 8.
Regarding quality, Multimedia contrasted 10 MPAA-represented movies, "Shalako," "The Ambushers," "Night of the Generals," "Where Angels Go, Trouble Follows," "The Last Safari," "Journey to Shiloh," "Krakatoa, East of Java," "Five Card Stud," "The Revengers," and "Hook, Line and Sinker," each of which would receive under the Nielsen methodology, by Multimedia's estimation, more than $40,000 in royalties, with critical reviews by recognized movie critics. The critics gave each of the 10 named movies poor reviews. Multimedia R. Ex. 3. An MPAA exhibit indicated that "Shalako," one of the movies named by Multimedia for its poor reviews, received favorable reviews from other recognized movie critics. MPAA Ex. 9RX; Tr. 582-585.
Regarding marketplace value, Multimedia prepared an analysis of eight movies which appeared in the 1985 Nielsen study, and which were also purchased for exhibition by Multimedia-owned broadcast stations. Based upon the confidential price actually paid by Multimedia-owned broadcast stations, Multimedia projected the value of one run of the movies as if it were aired in 100% of the U.S. television markets. Then Multimedia calculated what one run of the movies would receive in terms of cable royalty compensation based upon the Nielsen methodology. Reb. Test. of Richard Thrall, p. 6; Multimedia R. Ex. 5. Comparing the projected value of the movies on U.S. television broadcast markets with the estimated cable royalty value of the movies under the Nielsen methodology, Multimedia contends that the Nielsen-based cable compensation is "significantly out of whack with the true marketplace value of the product * * *" Id., p. 7. Specifically, Multimedia cited the example of "The Hellfighters," which, by Multimedia's calculations, is worth *7135 about $11,000 per run for the entire U.S. television market, including all cable and off-the-air households, but is compensated by MPAA at about $21,000 per run from its share of the cable royalties due solely to the viewing hours it garnered under the Nielsen study. Id. Multimedia conceded when presenting its analysis that its projection to 100% of the U.S. television markets was not based upon a scientific sample, that the sample was very small, and that there are competitive forces within each television market that will lead to variation in the price paid, so that the actual per run value might be two, three or four times greater than reflected in the Multimedia analysis. Tr. 504, 607.
Richard Thrall, senior Vice President of Programs for Muitimedia posited his view of why the Nielsen data is "out of whack" with the marketplace value of the works. In his view, movies no longer go directly to the broadcast market after their theatrical runs. Instead they go into the home video rental market, then into the pay cable market such as HBO and Showtime, and then finally to the broadcast market, so that by the time they have reached the broadcast market, their marketplace value has declined greatly. Tr. 500-501.
MPAA challenged the validity of the comparisons rendered by Multimedia between 1985 television market prices and 1985 cable royalty valuations. Because the Multimedia analysis of the television market was a straight-line amortization of the price of movies over many years, the television market estimated price per run remains constant year-in, year-out. Yet, the MPAA royalty compensations change dramatically from year to year, based as they are on Nielsen viewing data. MPAA argues that for the Multimedia analysis to have any validity, the analysis must be expanded to include more years. MPAA introduced an exhibit regarding 1984 royalty compensations for the same eight movies. Specifically, the example of "The Hellfighters," which would get an estimated royalty compensation in 1985 of $20,806 would only get $3,168 from the 1984 fund. MPAA Ex. 11 RX. Another film, "Jubilee Trail" which was estimated by Multimedia to have a U.S. television market value of $16,025 in 1985, and which was estimated to be eligible for a Nielsen-based royalty compensation of $36,426 in 1985, would only have received $837 for 1984. Id.
Multimedia's claims. Multimedia advanced five factors to support its request for an increase in its award from 0.825% to 1.1%: (1) Increase marketplace value and popularity of "Donahue"; (2) increased ratings and number of households reached by the "Young People's Specials"; (3) an increase of total audience and in average audience for its country music specials; (4) the first full year of national syndication of "Sally Jessy Raphael"; and (5) the showing that much cable carriage of Multimedia specials was not measured by the MPAA-Nielsen study. Multimedia Proposed Findings, pp. 4-5.
"Donahue". In 1985, "Donahue" was broadcast live on WNBC, New York, New York, and was carried by 205 affiliates. Test. of Richard Thrall, p. 6; Tr. 168, 181. Total cable household viewing hours of "Donahue" as a distant signal rose from 5,397,397 from 1984 to 5,872,269 in 1985, an increase of approximately 8.8%. MPAA Ex. 2R. "Donahue" received daytime broadcast ratings in 1985 of 7, 6, 6, and 6 for the four sweep periods, as compared to daytime ratings of 6, 6, 5, and 6 for the same periods in 1984. Multimedia Ex. 4. The daytime share for "Donahue" was 28, 30, 27 and 28 for the four sweep periods in 1985, as compared with 28, 28, 23, and 27 for the same sweep periods in 1984. Id.
Multimedia performed an advertising analysis comparing how much revenue "Donahue" generates for its affiliates with the total of all nonnetwork, non-local news spot sales. Assuming a 100% sellout rate, "Donahue" generated $121,502,360 in advertising revenues or 1.61% of all 1985 nonnetwork, non-local news spot sales. Multimedia Ex. 3. Multimedia's advertising study performed for previous proceedings assumed an 80% sellout rate. Tr. 154-55. MPAA adjusted all data presented by Multimedia in all years to be on the basis of a 100% sellout rate. On that basis, "Donahue's" advertising share was 1.93% in 1983, 1.77% in 1984 and 1.61% in 1985. MPAA Ex. 1X.
"Young People's Specials". In 1985, ten "Young People's Specials" were broadcast in 148 broadcast stations, compared with 143 broadcast stations in 1984. Multimedia Ex. 15; 1984 Multimedia Ex. 18. The average rating for the increase of approximately 7% over 1984. Multimedia Ex. 6 revised. The Nielsen study identified 17,146 household viewing hours attributable to the 10 specials, down from 43,954 household viewing hours measured in 1984. MPAA Ex. 2R.
Country Music Specials. In 1985, Multimedia syndicated 7 country music and entertainment specials (six originals and one repeat). These specials' averaged ratings were 13.0 and average total audience were 11,078,500, and average average audience were 5,435,700. Multimedia Ex. 10. In 1984, Multimedia syndicated 25 country music and entertainment specials (15 originals and ten repeats). The seven 1985 Multimedia specials had average total audiences and average average audiences of 76% and 68% higher than the 25 1984 Multimedia country music and entertainment specials. Multimedia Ex. 10.
The time for all Multimedia country music and entertainment specials on all broadcast stations during 1985 was 41.1 hours. Multimedia Ex. 15. The time for all Multimedia country music and entertainment specials on all broadcast stations during 1984 was 84.3 hours. 1984 Multimedia Ex. 18.
The Nielsen viewing hours measured for Multimedia country music and entertainment specials in 1985 were 64,512. MPAA Ex. 2R. The Nielsen viewing hours measured for Multimedia country music and entertainment specials in 1984 were 361,738. Id
"Sally Jessy Raphael"--"Sally Jessy Raphael" is a news/interview program first introduced in mid-1984. 1985 was the first full year of syndication. Test. of Richard Thrall, pp. 5, 8. The program's carriage of station affiliates increased to 71 during 1985, up from 25 in 1984. Tr. 123; 1984 Multimedia Ex. 18. The cable household viewing hours, according to the MPAA-Nielsen study rose from 83,392 in 1984 to 298,912 in 1985. MPAA Ex. 2R. "Sally Jessy Raphael" garnered a broadcast daytime rating of 3, and its daytime total persons reached rose from 529,000 in November, 1984 to 1,382,000 in November, 1985. Multimedia Ex. 8.
In response, MPAA contends that "Sally Jessy Raphael" is not an addition to Multimedia's line-up, but a substitute for other series which have been discontinued by Multimedia. MPAA Proposed Findings, pp. 30-31. MPAA noted the discontinuance of "Braun & Company," a series which had 229,620 cable household viewing hours in 1984, and which had a broadcast rating of 5 in 1983. MPAA Ex. 2R; 1983 Multimedia Ex. 7. MPAA also noted the discontinuance in 1985 of "Pop! Goes the Country," another Multimedia series. MPAA Proposed Findings, p. 31; Multimedia Ex. 15, fn. 4.
Specials underrated by Nielsen study methodology. Multimedia argues that its showing regarding the extent to which the Multimedia specials are not measured by the Nielsen study merits increasing its award. Multimedia Proposed Findings, p. 5.
Conclusions of Law
MPAA and Multimedia have shown entitlement to 99.175% and 0.825% of the *7136 Program Suppliers Phase I allocation, respectively.
In the 1984 proceeding, the Tribunal awarded the Phase II litigants as follows: MPAA--98.475%; Multimedia--0.825%; NAB--0.7%. In this year's proceeding, MPAA reached a settlement with NAB, so that the only two claimants before the Tribunal are MPAA and Multimedia.
The 1985 proceeding was characterized by two main issues: the role of the MPAA-commission Nielsen study of cable household viewing, and whether circumstances had changed for either of the parties since 1984.
Nielsen Study
MPAA's basic argument is that the Tribunal should use the MPAA-commissioned special Nielsen study of cable household viewing hours as the sole measure by which to make Phase II allocations. Accordingly, MPAA argues that Multimedia should be reduced from 0.825% to 0.26%.
Multimedia argues against the sole use of the Nielsen study data on two grounds, that the study itself is incomplete, and that the study is not directly relevant to the task before the Tribunal.
In every one of the previous Phase II decisions rendered by the Tribunal, the Tribunal has expressed a view that lies between those who favor complete adherence to the Nielsen study and those who argue against its relevance, and that is, that the Nielsen study provided by MPAA is the starting off point, but not the sole basis, upon which the Tribunal makes its allocations.
The reason for this is as follows:
The Tribunal attempts to simulate a marketplace--the importation by cable operators of distant broadcast signals--which, by virtue of the compulsory license, does not exist. Hence, the Tribunal must reason by analogy. The marketplace closest to the importation of distant signals marketplace is the one that exists between the cable operator and the cable subscribers and that is the choice of whether cable subscribers will subscribe to the cable system or not. That, in turn, is aided greatly by a knowledge of the cable subscribers' viewing habits. However, we have agreed with those who argued in previous proceedings that the cable industry is not as driven by audience viewing as the broadcast industry is, because the cable industry is not advertising-based, but depends instead on selling subscriptions, so that adding to the diversity of the offerings which may induce more people to subscribe could be more valuable to a cable operator than the actual viewing achieved by the individual programs.
MPAA has offered no new arguments in this proceeding to show why the Nielsen data is the sole relevant information for royalty allocations, but only repeated its view that the Nielsen data perfectly reflects the marketplace. Therefore we once again decline to make our allocations upon the Nielsen study data alone.
However, having said that, we give great reliance on the Nielsen data and we note that all but one of Multimedia's criticisms of the Nielsen's statistical reliability fail. First, Multimedia unsuccessfully attempted to show that either MPAA or Nielsen is less than diligent in its production and analysis of the data. MPAA's instructions to the Nielsen company, and Nielsen's reporting of the data and its conclusions from the data seemed to us especially careful, certain typographical errors notwithstanding. Multimedia's complaints about the diary method were addressed to the Nielsen Television Index Study, and in particular to the NAC portion of that study, and not to the Nielsen Station Index diary information which is what MPAA-Nielsen uses. Hence, its criticism of the diary method was not on point. Finally, although Multimedia correctly points out that the Nielsen study does not measure Form 1 and Form 2 systems, they account for less than 3 percent of the distant signal cable royalties, and it is doubtful that including any information from Form 1 and 2 systems would alter the data significantly.
We do agree with Multimedia that its specials were undermeasured by the Nielsen study. Nielsen, on the average, measures approximately 32.2% of all programming during the calendar year. According to an analysis in Multimedia's case, their specials were studied only 11.4%. Last year, we gave credit to Multimedia's argument that its specials were undermeasured, and accordingly, did not lower them any further than the 17.5% which we determined in the 1984 proceeding. We stated, however, that for Multimedia to continue to prevail in its argument, the Tribunal would have to be given additional data--the amount of Multimedia programs on broadcast stations, when they were aired, whether the programs aired inside or outside of a sweep period, which cable systems carried them, and their subscribership. In this year's proceeding, Multimedia has sustained its burden of the argument with the pertinent information, and the Tribunal has decided not to lower Multimedia's award any further.
MPAA and Multimedia engaged at various times in argument over how and whether to improve the Nielsen data. The Tribunal does not seek changes in the study. The Tribunal is satisfied that MPAA has gone to great lengths in devising a study which measures a great amount of programming, and we agree with MPAA that any extra efforts might well prove too costly in relation to the value of the additional data. On the other hand, the Tribunal will give credit, when shown, that a claimant's programs have not been measured at all, or have been significantly undermeasured.
However, Multimedia's criticism was more than just that the Nielsen study is flawed. Multimedia attempted to show that the Nielsen study was largely irrelevant to what the Tribunal should decide. Multimedia raised the examples of movies whose compensation from MPAA under the Nielsen formula were fairly substantial, but which received poor reviews from the critics. MPAA countered with fairly good reviews from the critics for one of the movies. Multimedia also attempted to show that the 1985 royalties which MPAA would distribute were far in excess of what those same movies would obtain in the broadcast television markets. MPAA countered with a showing that the 1984 royalties which MPAA distributed were quite different than the 1985 royalties, that such royalties vary greatly from year to year, and so they were not out of line with the revenues from broadcast television markets which are averaged over a longer period of years.
In the Tribunal's view, Multimedia did not succeed in establishing its point. Its statistical analysis of the broadcast television markets were, Multimedia conceded, flawed, and its analysis of the 1985 cable royalties had to be expanded to other years, as MPAA states, to have validity. Most important, Multimedia was attempting to compare one analogous marketplace--cable subscriber viewing--with another analogous marketplace--broadcast station payments to syndicator--on the assumption that it is the broadcast station market which is the most relevant market for the Tribunal. We do not agree. As we said, we favor a measure of cable subscriber viewership over a measure of broadcast station payments for syndicated programs, while at the same time, finding neither to be a perfect measure. Accordingly, we do not find that Multimedia is correct that the Nielsen viewing data is "out of whack" with the marketplace value of the programs being measured.
Changed circumstances. It is the Tribunal's view that MPAA's claim and *7137 Multimedia's claim have not changed from 1984 to 1985 to any significant degree to justify a change in their awards.
In 1985, MPAA represented 94 producers and/or syndicators of 5,954 different programs, garnering 2,451,567,190 cable household viewing hours. In 1984, MPAA represented 86 producers and/or syndicators of 5,796 different programs, which garnered approximately 2,381,600,000 cable household viewing hours. The improvement in household viewing hours is about 3%.
Multimedia's cable household viewing hours improved less than 0.2%. Multimedia's programs occupied more broadcast time during 1985 than in 1984, averaging on all broadcast stations 1318.8 hours per week, as against 1237 hours per week in 1984, an improvement of 6.6%. This was due mainly to the first full year of "Sally Jessy Raphael." However, the impact of that program was diminished by the termination of other weekly series such as "Braun and Company", and "Pop! Goes The Country," and by the sharp reduction in the number of country music and entertainment specials. Those specials declined from 25 in 1984 to 7 in 1985. "Donahue" remained strong in 1985, improving in its household viewing hours, 8.8%, and its popularity in the broadcast market was sustained. Our overall view, therefore, is that whatever slight improvements there were in the collective claim of MPAA were matched by the slight improvements in Multimedia's claim, so as to keep their relative positions equal.
Turning to Multimedia's arguments that it deserves an increase from 0.825% to 1.1%, we see nothing in what it presented to justify its request. Multimedia noted some improvements in some of the indicia of broadcast marketplace value for its properties, but these were slight and difficult to equate to cable marketplace values. In any event, they were certainly not of the nature to justify a 33% improvement in its award. For example, Multimedia requested credit for the improvements for Donahue in its daytime broadcast ratings and daytime share, and it requested credit for a 7% increase in total households reached by the "Young People's Special." These marginal improvements were given credit only to the extent that they served to offset the improvements in MPAA's claim, but nothing more.
Multimedia's claim for improved popularity for its country music and entertainment specials is not valid. The number of country music and entertainment specials declined over 70%, from 25 to 7, and its Nielsen cable household viewing hours, declined over 80%. That those remaining specials averaged higher total audiences and average audiences than the 25 from 1984 only serves to stem somewhat the loss to Multimedia's claim resulting from the decline in the specials, but in no way justifies an increase.
As noted earlier, the credit that the Tribunal could have given to Multimedia's "Sally Jessy Raphael" was mitigated by the loss of "Braun & Company," the ending of "Pop! Goes the Country," and the decline in country music and entertainment specials. Finally, Multimedia argued that it should be given a higher award due to the undermeasuring by Nielsen of its specials. The credit for the undermeasurement has already been built into Multimedia's award. Multimedia's success is showing an undermeasurement only served, as we said earlier, to avoid a lowering in the award. Considering that specials have become a smaller and smaller portion of Multimedia's claim over the years, the impact of the undermeasurement is not sufficient to justify a raise in the award.
Finally, MPAA states that because it has entered into a settlement with NAB, and because NAB has already received from the Tribunal through partial distribution its royalties based on last year's percentage, the Tribunal should state that the percentage awards to MPAA and Multimedia apply only after subtracting from the total the amount distributed by the Tribunal to NAB. We do not agree with MPAA. We have stated that Multimedia deserves the same award, 0.825%, as it received last year. In order to achieve this, the 0.825% must be from the entire Program Suppliers allocation, and not from the Program Suppliers allocation minus the NAB distribution. Otherwise, Multimedia will be sharing the cost of a settlement it did not enter.
Controversy Two: ASCAP, BMI, SESAC and ACEMLA
Findings of Fact
The claimants: ASCAP, BMI and SESAC (hereinafter A/B/S) are three performing rights societies which license the public performance of nondramatic musical works on behalf of copyright owners. 17 U.S.C. 116(e)(3).
ACEMLA is the assumed name of Latin American Music Co., a music publisher, which has sub-publishing agreements with several Latin American entities, and which has some agreements with individual composers, to represent their interests in the United States. ACEMLA is independent of ASCAP, BMI or SESAC. 52 FR 46324.
A/B/S' claim: A/B/S claims 100% of the Phase II allocation for the Music category. A/B/S Proposed Findings, par. 2. A/B/S bases its claim on the testimony by its witnesses that collectively ASCAP, BMI and SESAC license all but an incalculably small percentage of music performed in the United States in all media, including radio, television, concerts, and commercial businesses. 1984 Test. of Alan H. Smith, p. 2; 1984 Tr. 37-38, 42-43; 1982/1983 Test. of Gloria Messinger, p. 2.
For 1978, the total license revenues for ASCAP, BMI and SESAC for all public performances were approximately $190 million. 45 FR 63041. For 1982 and for 1983, the total license revenues for ASCAP, BMI and SESAC were approximately $350 million, each year. 1982/83 Test. of Gloria Messinger, p. 3.
ACEMLA stipulated that its claim is only for the portion of the cable fund attributable to Spanish-language music, conceding all other portions of the music category to A/B/S. ACEMLA Proposed Findings, pp. 1-2; Tr. 18-19. Accordingly, A/B/S attempted to define by various mathematical indices the part of the music category that is attributable to Spanish-language music.
According to the 1985 edition of Broadcast Yearbook, there were 33 American and Mexican television stations which characterized themselves as Spanish-language stations, and which were receivable over-the-air in the United States. A/B/S Ex. 1. Data compiled by Cable Data Corporation (CDC) indicated that 17 Spanish-language stations were carried as distant signals in 1985; 11 of which were American and 6 of which were Mexican. Test. of Peter Boyle, p. 2.
A/B/S and ACEMLA stipulated to an analysis of CDC's data which concluded that Spanish-language stations in 1985 accounted for 0.96% of all instances of carriage, 1.26% of the number of cable subscribers, and 1.21% of the cable royalty fees generated. Stipulation, dated October 30, 1987, Joint Table 1.
A/B/S contended that the CDC data must be further narrowed to account for the fact that not all programming on Spanish-language station is in Spanish. Using figures prepared for and introduced in the 1984 proceeding, A/B/S discounted the CDC data for the English language and other language programming on the subject stations and arrived at a conclusion that Spanish-language programming on Spanish language stations accounted for 0.69% of the instances of carriage, 0.97% of the *7138 number of subscribers, and 0.92% of the cable royalty fees generated. 1984 Test. of Peter Boyle, pp. 8-9; A/B/S Ex. 4; A/B/S Table 2 (revised).
In regard to Spanish-language music, Peter Boyle for A/B/S testified that ASCAP, BMI, and SESAC license all Spanish-language television stations because as a general matter all television stations in the United States hold licenses from ASCAP, BMI, SESAC so that they can perform music. Tr. 107. A/B/S did not introduce proof that they license the Spanish language stations specifically. Id.
A/B/S also incorporated by reference its list of foreign performing rights societies which they represent in the United States from such countries as Argentina, Bolivia, Brazil, Chile, Colombia, Mexico, Paraguay, Peru, Philippines, Spain, Uruguay, Venezuela, and from the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico. A/B/S Evidentiary Statement, Dec. 4, 1984. To supplement their earlier showing, Peter Boyle of ASCAP contacted the performing rights society in Venezuela, Spain and Mexico, and the advice he received was that the music in the television programming produced in those countries were entirely within their repertoires and is licensed in the United States through ASCAP, BMI and SESAC. Test. of Peter Boyle, p. 7; Tr. 88-89, 108.
A/B/S incorporated by reference various specific showings of the individual Spanish-language songs which are in the combined repertoires of ASCAP, BMI and SESAC which were introduced in previous jukebox distribution proceedings: Lists of popular Spanish-language songs in combined ASCAP, BMI, and SESAC repertoires, Joint Statement of A/B/S, dated March 14, 1984 (1982 list); Joint Evidentiary Statement of A/B/S, dated December 4, 1984 (1983 list); List of most-performed Spanish-language works in the combined ASCAP, BMI and SESAC repertoires for 1982 and 1983, Response of A/B/S, dated August 9, 1985; List of Popular and most-performed Spanish-language songs in combined ASCAP, BMI and SESAC repertoires which first appeared in 1984, Settling Parties' Ex. 4, 1984 Jukebox Distribution Proceeding; BMI printout of copyrighted musical compositions which first entered the BMI repertory in the first six months of 1984, Settling Parties' Ex. 7, 1984 Juke. Dist. Proc.; Partial list of Spanish-language titles first appearing in the ASCAP, BMI and SESAC repertoires in 1985, Settling Parties' Ex. 4 (corrected copy), 1985 Juke. Dist. Proc.; Partial list of works in the Settling Parties' repertoires recorded by performing artists specified by the Copyright Royalty Tribunal and contained in recordings released in 1984 or 1985, or performed on radio in 1985, Settling Parties' Ex. 23B, 1985 Juke. Dist. Proc.
ACEMLA's claim: ACEMLA testified that it taped a number of programs during 1985 which included musical compositions claimed by ACEMLA and which were broadcast by Spanish-language television stations WXTV and WNJU. WXTV and WNJU broadcast to the New York television market. Test. of Raul Bernard, par. 4.
ACEMLA stated it monitored and recorded 29 of its songs on WNJU, Channel 47, Newark, N.J. on three programs of "Asi Canta Ecuador," one program of "Despedida de Ano," one program of "Estudio Alegre," one program of "Show de la 12 (doce) Puerto Rico," and one program of "Show Espectacular." ACEMLA Ex. 1. According to CDC, WNJU was carried by 9 Form 3 cable systems during the first half of 1985 and by 10 Form 3 cable systems during the second half of 1985 on a distant signal basis. Stipulation, Jt. Ex. 1A. These systems reached an average of 193,216 subscribers and paid a total of $201,447 in royalty fees for 1985. Stipulation, Jt. Ex. 1B and 1C.
ACEMLA stated that it taped 21 of its songs on WXTV, Channel 41, Paterson, N.J. on two programs of "Noche De Gala," two programs of "Embajadores de la Musica Colombia (Colombiana)," three programs of "Siempre en Domingo," and one program of "Sabado Espectacular," ACEMLA Ex. 1. According to CDC, WXTV was carried by three Form 3 cable systems during 1985 on a distant signal basis. Stipulation, Jt. Ex. 1A. These systems reached an average of 49,553 subscribers and paid $47,779 in royalty fees for 1985. Stipulation, Jt. Exs. 1B and 1C.
ACEMLA further asserted that WXTV was owned by Spanish International Communications Corporation, whose principals also owned the Spanish International Network (SIN), and that WXTV was SIN's flagship stations during 1985. Accordingly, ACEMLA stated that the 21 songs it found were broadcast on WXTV would also have been performed over SIN's affiliated stations. Test. of Raul Bernard, par. 4. However, ACEMLA had no confirmation from SIN that these programs were actually carried by the SIN affiliated stations. Tr. 15. Those SIN affiliates which were carried on a distant signal basis in 1985 by Form 3 systems were: KMEX, Los Angeles, CA., KWEX, San Antonio, Texas, WLTV, Miami, FL., KCSO, Sacramento, CA., and KDTV, San Francisco, CA. Test. of Raul Bernard, par. 4; Stipulation, Jt. Ex. 1A. The cable systems carrying these stations reached an average of 578,000 subscribers, and paid $605,734 in royalty fees in 1985, according to CDC. Id., Jt. Exs. 1B, 1C.
In 1985, ACEMLA did not license any U.S. television broadcast station; ACEMLA did not license any radio stations except for a license reached in 1986 extended to WNWK, Newark, N.J. for $1500 a year, retroactive to 1985; ACEMLA received no income from any television broadcast station; and ACEMLA made no distribution of royalties to any publisher or composer. 52 FR 46325.
In support of its claim to 1.235% of the Music category, ACEMLA asserts that the royalties attributable to Spanish-language music is the average of the percentage of all cable subscribers receiving Spanish-language stations (1.26%) and the percentage of fees paid by cable operators (1.21%), and that ACEMLA believes it is entitled to all of it on the basis of its assertion that it alone has established that its songs have been included in secondary transmission by cable systems in 1985. ACEMLA Proposed Findings, pars. 1,2,6.
A/B/S Rebuttal of ACEMLA's Claim: A/B/S introduced evidence to show that (1) nine of the programs cited by ACEMLA in support of its claim did not air on the dates ACEMLA said they aired; and (2) eight of the songs which ACEMLA claims belong in the catalogues of A/B/S Rebuttal.
A/B/S introduced evidence that seven of the programs cited by ACEMLA were not listed in TV Guide as being scheduled for broadcast on the specific dates listed in ACEMLA Ex. 1, and that two other programs could not be traced to TV Guide because ACEMLA had not provided the specific dates of broadcast. Reb. Test. of Peter Boyle. According to Dr. Boyle, this evidence undermined ACEMLA's claim to 30 of the 50 performances of its songs.
Three of the nine programs questioned by Dr. Boyle were weekly episodes of "Asi Canta Ecuador." ACEMLA introduced invoices received by the producer of these programs from WNJU indicating that the programs had been broadcast on the dates listed in ACEMLA Ex. 1. These three programs included 19 of the 50 performances of songs claimed by ACEMLA. ACEMLA Ex. 4RX. The producer also told ACEMLA that TV Guide had either incorrectly listed or omitted entirely other programs he had produced. Id. A/B/S did not check "El Diario La Prensa," a Spanish-language newspaper *7139 published in New York City, to see if ACEMLA's programs were listed there, and ACEMLA argues that that publication would have been a more reliable guide than TV Guide. Tr. 432-3; ACEMLA Proposed Findings, par. 14.
ACEMLA claims in this proceeding for 40 songs performed a total of 50 times in 1985. A/B/S challenges ACEMLA's claim to eight of those songs performed 9 times: "Alegre Amanecer," "Cantares de Navidad," "La Piraqua," "Navidad Negra," "San Fernando," "El Barbarazo," "Patacon Pisao," "La Guacherna." A/B/S asserts that those eight songs are in the combined repertoires of ASCAP, BMI and SESAC, and that challenges to these same songs were raised in the 1984 and 1985 Jukebox Royalty Distributon Proceedings, which challenges were incorporated by reference into this proceeding. A/B/S Rebuttal, p. 4. In response, ACEMLA incorporated by reference the testimony it introduced in the 1984 and 1985 jukebox proceedings to support its right to claim for those eight songs. ACEMLA Proposed Findings, par. 9.
Conclusions of Law
ACEMLA has shown entitlement to a cash award of $1. ASCAP, BMI and SESAC have shown entitlement collectively to the rest of the allocation in the Music category
The Tribunal begins its analysis of the claimants in the Music category by first looking at the relative strengths of ACEMLA and of ASCAP, BMI and SESAC overall. ASCAP, BMI, and SESAC together collect hundreds of millions of dollars in license fees from all sources every year for the public performance of music. Every television station in the United States, including Spanish-language stations, holds a license from one, two or three of them so that music can be performed. On the other hand, ACEMLA is a fledgling entity with an independent repertoire of Spanish-language music for which it has attempted to obtain licenses, but as of 1985, had not yet succeeded in licensing any television station, receiving any licensing income, or making any royalty distribution. ACEMLA conceded at the start of this proceeding that it made no claim for music other than Spanish language music, and therefore the only question is ACEMLA's relative control of Spanish language music vis-a-vis ASCAP, BMI and SESAC.
Concerning only Spanish language music, it is again pertinent that only ASCAP, BMI and SESAC are the licensors of the Spanish-language television stations, and ACEMLA is not. Further, ASCAP, BMI and SESAC represent in the United States the performing rights societies of the Latin American countries, so that any music which is not represented by A/B/S pursuant to their own composers and publishers is represented pursuant to their agreements with Latin American societies. Additionally, each time the Tribunal has made requests of A/B/S for examples of current Spanish-language songs, and songs performed by current Spanish-language artists, they have complied satisfactorily.
Against these showings by A/B/S, ACEMLA has been able to garner a small percentage award in the jukebox proceedings by, among other things, actual jukebox surveys performed by A/B/S which found some ACEMLA-represented works on jukebox, and radio surveys performed by A/B/S which found some performances on radio, plus showings by ACEMLA of the production and distribution of some 45 rpm singles. These showings in the jukebox proceedings do not translate, in our consideration, to performances of ACEMLA's works in television programs. To obtain credit for television performances, it was incumbent upon ACEMLA to show sufficiently convincing evidence.
ACEMLA's actual claim is for 40 songs performed a total of 50 times on two television stations, WXTV and WNJU, and by virtue of the fact that WXTV is the flagship station of SIN, on five other television stations. Comparing these performances to the universe of all performances of music on television during 1985 and carried by cable systems on a distant signal basis--hundreds of thousands of hours of performances of songs, theme music and background music-- the 50 performances are insignificant. Applying the Tribunal's five criteria to ACEMLA's claim, we cannot see how the claim can deserve any more than the smallest possible award, $1.
We note that the parties introduced considerable evidence to approach the question of ACEMLA's award mathematically. The Tribunal wishes to make clear that it does not make its allocation based upon a time plus fee generation formula, because, as we have said in the past it is a mechanical formula which does not take into account properly the five criteria upon which the Tribunal bases its decisions: harm, benefit, marketplace value, time and quality. However, the Tribunal has consistently permitted fee generation analyses to be entered into the record, and considers it useful information.
Accordingly, we performed two different mathematical analyses based on two different starting points. In both analyses, the Tribunal worked from an assumption that ACEMLA had proved all 50 performances. The first analysis took as its starting point the total cable fees generated by the Form 3 cable systems carrying the ACEMLA performances. After making the appropriate discount for the percentage of the fees which is attributable to other program categories, and discounting for the sum of music that would have been carried by those systems aside from ACEMLA's claim, the Tribunal arrived at a mathematical result wholly consistent with its view that ACEMLA's claim is limited to $1. The second analysis took as its starting point the percentage of Spanish-language stations versus all television stations. Whether using ACEMLA's argued-for 1.235% or A/B/S' less than 1%, the second fee generation analysis was comparable to the first. These two fee generation analyses confirmed for us what the Tribunal already believed viewing the record as a whole, and that is that ACEMLA's claim is insignificant.
Because of the nature of ACEMLA's claim, it was unnecessary for the Tribunal to determine how many of the performances ACEMLA has proved. Whether ACEMLA proved all 50 performances, or just a few, the award would be the same, since giving ACEMLA maximum credit for its entire claim would not raise its value above the minimum. We will state that we believe that A/B/S did not successfully rebut ACEMLA's claim on the basis of the TV Guide listings. We credit ACEMLA's explanation that TV Guide sometimes misses programming of Spanish-language television stations. We also did not render a decision whether ACEMLA or A/B/S were the proper representatives of eight of the claimed songs, given the value of the claim.
The only remaining question for the Tribunal was whether to award ACEMLA $1 or give ACEMLA no award on the ground that the claim is de minimis. We are persuaded that ACEMLA has shown a prima facie case, that is, that it had some works performed in 1985 over television broadcast stations which works were retransmitted by cable systems to their subscribers. Given that our task is to make awards to copyright owners who meet the requirements set by Congress, we believe that a minimal award is warranted.
Lastly, the Tribunal does not agree with ACEMLA's springboard argument *7140 that by its showing a few performances of Spanish-language music, it should receive all of the music category attributable to Spanish-language music, on the ground that A/B/S hasn't shown any specific performances.
It is true that A/B/S could have put into the record examples of a specific performance of one of its works on Spanish-language television. Absent this, it became necessary for the Tribunal to draw from analogy from previous records that A/B/S licenses all stations, and have a virtual control of all music. However, A/B/S' showing on this needed improvement.
It was up to the Tribunal, for instance, to inquire of A/B/S whether A/B/S licenses all Spanish language stations, and the answer was that A/B/S must, because it licenses all stations. A/B/S did not, on its own enter this evidence as part of its direct case. A second example, ACEMLA objected to Dr. Boyle's testimony regarding his being advised by the Mexican, Venezuelan and Spanish performing rights societies that they still had agreements with A/B/S on the ground that it was hearsay. Although hearsay is admissible in administrative agencies, we were, like counsel for ACEMLA, concerned about the weight of this particular hearsay, and it was only after further inquiry of the witness were we assured that we could give the testimony weight.
Generally, we view A/B/S' case as lax in establishing the essential elements of its case. However, having said this, we also view ACEMLA's case as one composed mostly of unsupported statements. ACEMLA's objections to the hearsay of the other party's case would be better heard if its own case depended less on hearsay. For example, ACEMLA's assertion that the songs performed on WXTV were also carried by other SIN affiliated television stations had no support, and the Tribunal's questioning of the witness revealed that no documentary support existed. As a general observation, the Tribunal would like to see documentary support for the elements of claimants' cases at the beginning of the case when written direct cases are submitted, rather than through the process of discovery, cross examination exhibits, and eleventh-hour surrebuttal.
Therefore, in comparing the two cases, the Tribunal does not see its task as a mechanistically procedural one in which, as ACEMLA would wish, we would give to ACEMLA considerable royalties based upon a conclusion that only they showed specific performance. Rather, the Tribunal attempts to ascertain the reality of musical performances in 1985, and we are persuaded that ACEMLA's repertoire accounted for an insignificant amount of the musical performances in 1985.
Allocations
Pursuant to the Phase I settlement, the Tribunal has adopted the following allocation to categories of claimants in Phase I of the 1985 cable copyright royalty fees available for distribution.
After subtracting the stipulated award to National Public Radio to 0.18% of the entire fund.
------------------------------------------------------------------
Category Basic 3.75 Syndex
------------------------------------------------------------------
Program Suppliers ..................... 67.10 72.00 95.50
Sports ................................ 16.35 17.50 0
Public Broadcasting Service ............ 5.20 0 0
Commercial Television .................. 5.00 5.00 0
Music .................................. 4.50 4.50 4.50
Devotional Claimants ................... 1.10 0.75 0
Canadian Claimants ..................... 0.75 0.25 0
Commercial Radio .......................... 0 0 0
------------------------------------------------------------------
The allocation adopted by the Tribunal under Phase II for the individual claimants is as follows:
Program Suppliers:
Motion Picture Association of America, Inc .....99.175%
Multimedia Entertainment, Inc.....0.825%
Music:
Asociacion de Compositores y Editores de Musica Latinoamericana.....$1.00
ASCAP, BMI and SESAC, collectively--the remainder of the category.
Finally, the NBC-Worldivision controversy for the entitlement to the 1985 royalties attributable to "Little House on the Prairie" is held in abeyance until the outcome of the petition for review of the Tribunal's 1984 final determination filed with the United States Court of Appeal for the District of Columbia Circuit.
Mario F. Aguero,
Chairman.
Dated: March 1, 1988.
[FR Doc. 88-4707 Filed 3-3-88; 8:45 am]
Please refer to the IP Mall Copyright Royalty Tribunal homepage for details on this valuable resource.