Copyright Royalty Tribunal

NOTICES
 
COPYRIGHT ROYALTY TRIBUNAL
 
[CRT Docket No. 88-1-86JD; Req. No. 8-10046]
 
Final Determination of the Distribution of the 1986 Jukebox Royalty Fund
 
Monday, September 19, 1988
 
*36262 AGENCY: Copyright Royalty Tribunal.

 ACTION: Notice of final determination.

 SUMMARY: The Tribunal announces the adoption of its final determination in the proceeding concerning the distribution to certain copyright owners and performing rights societies of jukebox royalty fees deposited for 1986 performances.

 FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:Robert Cassler, General Counsel, Copyright Royalty Tribunal, 1111 20th Street NW., Suite 450, Washington, DC 20036, (202) 653-5175.

 SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

 Authority

  17 U.S.C. 116(c)(3) authorizes the Copyright Royalty Tribunal (Tribunal) to distribute annually royalty fees paid by jukebox operators. First, the Tribunal is to assess the claims of, and make appropriate awards to, "every copyright owner not affiliated with a performing rights society." 17 U.S.C. 116(c)(4)(A). Second, the remainder is to be distributed to "the performing rights societies * * * as they shall by agreement stipulate among themselves, or if they fail to agree, the pro rata share to which such performing rights societies provide entitlement." 17 U.S.C. 116(c)(4)(B).

 The Claimants and the Controversy

  In this proceeding, the Tribunal takes up the distribution of the royalty fees *36363 deposited by jukebox operators for the calendar year 1986.

 Five parties filed claims in the 1986 proceeding: the American Society of Composers, Authors, and Publishers (ASCAP), Broadcast Music, Inc. (BMI), SESAC, Inc. (SESAC), Association de Compositores y Editores de Musica Latinoamericana (ACEMLA), and Italian Book Corporation (IBC).

 ASCAP, BMI, and SESAC (hereinafter A/B/S) reached an agreement for the division of the jukebox royalties among themselves, and decided to prosecute their claims jointly. Justification of Claim, filed November 2, 1987. On November 13, 1987, IBC reported to the Tribunal that it had reached a voluntary agreement with A/B/S and was therefore withdrawing its claim to the 1986 fund.

 Consequently, the controversy in the 1986 proceeding was between A/B/S and ACEMLA. In the statements of justification of claim, A/B/S jointly claimed "all but the most negligible" amount of the fund, and ACEMLA claimed 8% of the fund. Id.; Justification Statement of ACEMLA, filed November 16, 1987. In its final pleading in this proceeding, A/B/S claimed that ACEMLA was entitled to no more than 0.02122% of the fund, and that A/B/S was entitled to the rest, 99.97878%. A/B/S Reply Findings, par. 22. In its final pleading in this proceeding, ACEMLA claimed 2% of the fund. ACEMLA Reply Findings, p. 3.

 Background and Chronology

  On December 4, 1987, the Tribunal published a notice declaring that a controversy existed concerning the distribution of the 1986 jukebox royalty fund, effective December 7, 1987. 52 FR 46113. In a separate order, the Tribunal ordered a partial distribution of 99% of the 1986 jukebox royalty fund upon the condition that in the event the Tribunal determined that ACEMLA's entitlement exceeded 1%, A/B/S would reimburse ACEMLA the excess amount plus interest. Order, dated November 30, 1987.

 By Order, dated December 14, 1987, the Tribunal determined that the best disposition of the 1986 proceeding would be a bifurcated proceeding in which the question of the status of ACEMLA under section 116 of the Copyright Act, whether "copyright owner" or "performing rights society," would be decided first, and then the entitlement of all the parties would be decided second.

 On February 17, 1988, ACEMLA filed its written direct case on the issue of whether it was a performing rights society in 1986. On March 1, 1988, the Tribunal heard ACEMLA's direct case.

 On March 9, 1988, A/B/S filed its written rebuttal case. Because A/B/S's rebuttal case consisted solely of incorporation by reference of previous heard testimony, no hearing of A/B/S's rebuttal case was needed. By Order, dated March 14, 1988, the Tribunal dispensed with the rebuttal hearing.

 Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law on the question of ACEMLA's status were filed March 29, 1988, and Reply Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law were filed April 5, 1988.

 On April 8, 1988, the Tribunal met and determined that ACEMLA was a copyright owner, not a performing rights society, in 1986. Accordingly, the Tribunal ordered ACEMLA to produce on May 4, 1988 its written direct case on entitlement, and further ordered that the three performing rights societies, having resolved their differences, were not required to enter their proofs. 53 FR 12177 (April 13, 1988).

 On May 4, 1988, ACEMLA filed its written direct case on entitlement. ACEMLA's case was heard by the Tribunal May 18, 1988.

 A/B/S filed its written rebuttal case on entitlement May 25, 1988. Hearing were held June 2 and 3, 1988. Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law were filed by the parties June 17, 1988. Reply Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law were filed June 24, 1988.

 Findings of Fact

 Status of ACEMLA

  Previous Findings. The Tribunal took evidence regarding the status, organization and practices of ACEMLA in the 1982/1983 consolidated proceeding, the 1984 proceeding and the 1985 proceeding. All of the facts of these proceedings are hereby incorporated by reference into the 1986 jukebox distribution proceeding final determination. 50 FR 47577; 51 FR 43455; 52 FR 46324.

 Current Findings--1986 Proceeding. During 1986, ACEMLA stated it received royalty payments from the Tribunal as a copyright owner, and from radio station WNWK. ACMELA Direct p. 2.

 ACEMLA stated it made partial distributions of these royalties to "various composers, publishers, and others" in 1987, for 1986. ACEMLA Direct, p. 2; Tr. 21. ACEMLA stated it made advance payments against future royalty collections to SPACEM, a Puerto Rican organization. ACEMLA, p. 3.

 ACEMLA stated it has continued to prosecute for copyright infringement, and to monitor the play of music by New York City area radio and television stations. ACEMLA, p. 3.

 Conclusions of Law

 ACEMLA Was Not a Performing Rights Society in 1986

  The Copyright Royalty Tribunal has a procedural, not a regulatory, obligation to ascertain whether the jukebox claimants are copyright owners or performing rights societies. [FN1] ASCAP, BMI and SESAC have been defined by Congress as perorming rights

   FN1 The distinction between regulatory and procedural is important. As stated in earlier determinations, the Tribunal does not set standards for organizations to become performing rights societies; it does not raise or lower entry bars to becoming a performing rights society; nor does the Tribunal's opinion regarding performing rights society status have any legal effect upon the music industry. All that the Tribunal does, procedurally, is to make a finding whether a claimant is a copyright owner or a performing rights society so that it can structure the jukebox distribution proceeding according to Congress' mandate. Such a finding has no effect on the claimants' ultimate royalty award because the Tribunal makes every effort to ascertain the proper percentage award regardless of who is required to go forward with the evidence.

 societies, so no further inquiry is required. 17 U.S.C. 116(e)(3). Consequently, the only status question in this proceeding applies to ACEMLA.

  ACEMLA was found in the 1982/1983 consolidated proceeding, and in the 1984 and 1985 proceedings not to be a performing rights society. 50 FR 47577 (November 19, 1985), aff'd ACEMLA v. Copyright Royalty Tribunal, 809 F. 2d 926 (D.C. Cir. 1987); 51 FR 43455 (December 2, 1986), aff'd, ACEMLA v. Copyright Royalty Tribunal, 835 F. 2d 446 (2d. Cir. 1987); 52 FR 46324 (December 4, 1987), aff'd, ACEMLA and Italian Book Corporation v. Copyright Royalty Tribunal,-- F. 2d--(2d. Cir. 1988).

 However, previous findings by the Tribunal that ACEMLA was not a performing rights society in those years do not collaterally estop ACEMLA from relitigating its status, because it is possible that in all calendar year, ACEMLA may become a performing rights society.

 However, the Tribunal, as is evident from the above discussion, has accumplated a considerable record regarding ACEMLA's status in which the Tribunal has found and the Court of Appeals has affirmed that ACEMLA is not a performing rights society. Therefore, the only questions in this proceeding are: did ACEMLA relitigate any earlier findings so as to convince the Tribunal that the preponderance of the evidence now favors a different conclusion, or, did any circumstances change in 1986 so that the Tribunal can conclude that ACEMLA became a performing rights society in 1986

 *36364 ACEMLA did not relitigate any earlier findings of fact, so that the only question is whether ACEMLA took any new steps in 1986 to become a performing rights society.

 The definition of a performing rights society in the Copyright Act is: "an association or corporation that licenses the public performance of nondramatic musical work on behalf of the copyright owners, such as the American Society of Composers, Authors and Publishers, Broadcast Music, Inc., and SESAC, Inc." 17 U.S.C. 116(e)(3).

 In applying this definition to ACEMLA the Tribunal has broken the definition down into three parts: (1) "An association or corporation"; (2) "that licenses the public performance of nondramatic musical works on behalf of the copyright owners;" (3) such as the American Society of Composers, Authors and Publishers, Broadcast Music, Inc., and SESAC, Inc." The Tribunal has previously concluded that ACEMLA needs to meet all three parts of the definition to be considered a performing rights society. Not meeting any one of these three parts would be fatal to ACEMLA's claim to being a performing rights society.

 In each of the past three proceedings, we have stated that ACEMLA did not meet the first part of the definition, "an association or corporation." ACEMLA is but the assumed name of LAMCO, a music publishing company. It has no independent structure of its own. We have consistently required that ACEMLA must be at least independent enough of copyright owners to have its own organizational papers and structure. This holding was affirmed twice by the Court of Appeals.

 In 1986, ACEMLA took no structural steps to cure this deficiency noted by the Tribunal. Hence, ACEMLA does not meet the first part of the definition of a performing rights society, and no further weighing of ACEMLA's other proffered evidence is necessary and our analysis ends here.

 Our decision not to weigh ACEMLA's other evidence comports with the judicial rule of construction that states that a decision-maker only considers that which is necessary to resolve the issue at hand. To the extent the Tribunal considered all the evidence in previous proceedings it was to give guidance to ACEMLA so that it could glean the standards by which the Tribunal would consider the other aspects of ACEMLA's operation at such time when ACEMLA was properly structured.

 Should it be the case in future proceedings that ACEMLA becomes an association or corporation, we state now that the current quality of its evidentiary submissions must be improved. Its oral and written cases have in the past consisted of the vaguest and most general statements, unsupported whatsoever by documentary proof. All attempts during the hearing by the Tribunal or A/B/S to elicit the most fundamental and relevant facts regarding these vague statements were consistently rebuffed by the witness. In our Findings of Fact listed above, each finding has been prefaced "ACMELA stated", because we cannot believe with confidence ACEMLA's vague assertions. In future proceedings we shall require clear and specific written testimony, supported by documentation upon the filing of the written case.

 Effect of the Tribunal's First Conclusion

  The Tribunal has concluded that ACEMLA was a copyright owner in 1986. The next step is to consider the value of the music ACEMLA represents. After Tribunal consideration of ACEMLA is rendered, the Tribunal's task is complete because the three performing rights societies are in agreement.

 Findings of Fact

 ACEMLA's Proofs of Entitlement

  Incorporation by Reference. ACEMLA incorporated by reference the record evidence supporting its awards in the 1982/1983, the 1984, the 1985 jukebox distribution proceedings, and the 1985 cable distribution proceeding. A recitation of that evidence is not repeated herein. ACEMLA Direct, p.2.

 Monitoring of public performance of ACEMLA's works. ACEMLA undertook a limited monitoring of four New York City area radio stations in 1986 to determine which titles in its repertory were being broadcast. Radio station WADO was monitored on 11 days, WJIT on 22 days, WKSQ on 11 days and WKDM on 15 days. In total, 139 different ACEMLA-controlled songs were played a total of 227 times during this limited monitoring. ACEMLA Direct, p. 3; Ex. 2 (revised).

 ACEMLA's manner of monitoring was the same as it was for 1985. It was not conducted on any scientific basis. The recordings were not made continuously, and so do not show the frequency of performance of ACEMLA-claimed songs in relation to other songs. The four New York area stations do not constitute a representative sample of all 207 Spanish-language radio stations. Tr. 21; 1985 Tr. 343-344; 1985 ACEMLA Ex. 5.

 Hit Songs Charts. ACEMLA submitted 25 "Top Latin Album" hit parade charts pubished in Billboard Magazine in 1986, and they indicated that 61 different recordings of ACEMLA-controlled songs could be found on 28 different long-playing albums listed in the "Top Latin Albums" charts. ACEMLA Direct Case, p. 3; ACEMLA Ex. 1, pp. 1-2; ACEMLA's Response of May 20, 1988. ACEMLA's witness L. Raul Bernard (Bernard) was unable to state how many--if any--of these 61 songs were pressed as 45 rpm singles. Tr. 7.

 44 ACEMLA-controlled songs appeared on song charts in a bi-weekly magazine Guia Radial Del Show based upon information furnished by a Puerto Rican record store. ACEMLA Ex. 3. 11 of the 44 songs were also played by New York Spanish-language radio stations, as revealed by ACEMLA's limited monitoring. ACEMLA's Response of May 20, 1988.

 The hit songs charts from New York Spanish-language newspapers, Noticias El Mundo and Vocero, which were submitted in previous proceedings were not submitted this year. ACEMLA Direct.

 ACEMLA was advised in the 1985 jukebox final determination to file evidence in this proceeding to explain more of its operation--which of its songs have been recorded on 45 rpm records, how many were released, how they have been distributed, and where. 51 FR 46330-46331. ACEMLA did not provide that information in this proceeding, and when asked why, Bernard stated, "It is not our operation to distribute or really to find out where these 45's are distributed. We know they are, as a matter of fact, within the business, within the trade, and all we can give you is what we have given you so far." Tr. 15.

 A/B/S Radio Survey, and Dispute of Title Ownership. As in prior years, A/B/S performed a radio survey of ACEMLA-controlled works. A/B/S Reb. Test. of Adler; Reb. Test. of Ahrold. In this proceeding, A/B/S performed a survey of the songs listed by ACEMLA in the 1982-1985 proceedings, and the songs listed for the first time in the 1986 proceeding. Tr. 57-59, 119. These works totalled 580 songs. Of these, 120 songs were claimed by A/B/S to belong to the combined catalogues of A/B/S. Reb. Test. of Adler, p. 1; Reb. Test. of Ahrold, p. 1, corrected in A/B/S Proposed Findings, p. 17, fn. 9.

 According to ASCAP's methodology, if ACEMLA had been an ASCAP member in 1986, it would have earned for all 580 songs, 3,174 radio credits out of a total of 14,959,388 radio credits earned by all ASCAP members, yielding a percentage of 0.02122%. Reb. Test. of Adler, pp. 4-5. Excluding the 120 contested songs, the percentage is *36365 0.01217%. Id. Both percentage figures--0.021222% and 0.01217% represent a decline from comparable percentage figures from 1985 of 0.3277%, and 0.01791%, respectively. Id.

 According to BMI's methodology, if ACEMLA has been a BMI member in 1986, it would have earned for all 580 songs 0.005209% of BMI's distribution for all similar U.S. radio performances. Reb. Test. of Ahrold, p. 5; Tr. 59-60. Excluding the 120 contested songs, the percentage is 0.00211%. Id. Both percentage figures--0.005209% and 0.00211%--represent an increase from comparable percentage figures from 1985 of 0.00453% and 0.001383%. 1985 Reb. Test. of Ahrold, p. 5; 1985 A/B/S Proposed Findings, par. 110, fn. 36.

 Conclusions of Law

 ACEMLA has shown entitlement to 0.07% of the 1986 jukebox fund

  The Tribunal holds yearly distribution proceedings in jukebox and in cable which, because they primarily involve the same claimants, build year by year on the earlier records. Hence, the only questions for the Tribunal to decide this year is whether either ACEMLA or A/B/S chose to relitigate previouly found facts or conclusions, or whether either ACEMLA or A/B/S has shown changed circumstances for 1986.

 This hearing was marked by an absence of relitigation of previous facts or conclusions, so that the only question is whether the value of ACEMLA's catalogue has changed in 1986.

 In 1984, the Tribunal awarded ACEMLA 0.06% of the fund. In 1985, ACEMLA and IBC were joint claimants and together they were awarded 0.12% of the fund. The Tribunal would not indicate how much of the 0.12% of the fund was attributable to either ACEMLA or IBC, because of our policy favoring settlement--a determination of ACEMLA's subshare of the joint claim of ACEMLA/IBC would be an impermissible substitution of the Tribunal's judgment for whatever settlement ACEMLA and IBC reached.

 Therefore, the question of changed circumstances from 1985 is a particularly difficult problem, because it has no starting point, i.e., ACEMLA's 1985 award. However, it does have a starting range. ACEMLA was awarded 0.06% in 1984, and we generally noted that perhaps in 1985 ACEMLA's works were getting greater circulation. Therefore, we can say that the starting range is in the area slightly greater than 0.06%.

 Proceeding from that range, we can detect no change in circumstances for ACEMLA in 1986. First, regarding ACEMLA's proofs, we note that the Court of Appeals latest description of it--"scanty at best"--is truer this year than last. The only portion of ACEMLA's case which we can credit is the monitoring of New York City area radio stations. The monitoring, which was not scientific and which cannot be used to project to the universe of radio play, nonetheless shows consistent play of ACEMLA works on those stations, and shows the same level of play from 1985 to 1986.

 Regarding the hit songs charts, ACEMLA dropped the New York City song charts from its showing. The Puerto Rican song chart has validity only to the extent it was corroborated by the monitoring of the New York City area radio stations. Otherwise, the criticisms offered in the last proceeding by A/B/S-- that Puerto Rico has no licensed jukeboxes, and that the song charts may be influenced by the desire of a music store to sell records are sound.

 The Billboard Magazine album charts cannot be given any credit because we do not know whether any of those songs were made into 45 rpm singles. LP's are not the form in which music is played on jukeboxes. We started last year that we were concerned about A/B/S' testimony that generally Latin songs are not pressed into 45's, and we required ACEMLA to explain the distribution of the music it represents or we would credit A/B/S' testimony. ACEMLA has not been forthcoming on this issue, and we therefore cannot conclude that the Billboard Magazine album charts are probative of ACEMLA's case.

 Consequently, ACEMLA's showing this year rests on its monitoring. We can conclude that the frequently played titles on these radio stations are generally singles. Then the songs which ACEMLA monitored were singles capable of being played on jukeboxes. We can also conclude that the level of radio play was about the same, and therefore, it's likely that the level of jukebox play was the same and ACEMLA's award this year should be in the same range as in previous years.

 Nothing in A/B/S' rebuttal case deters us from the same conclusion. ASCAP's and BMI's radio surveys continue to provide valuable information for the Tribunal. However, we note that in shedding any light on whether there has been changed circumstances, the surveys seem to be contradictory. While ASCAP's surveys, inclusive or exclusive of the contested songs, show a decline in air play of ACEMLA's songs, BMI's surveys, inclusive or exclusive of the contested songs, show an increase in air play of ACEMLA's songs. [FN2]

   FN2 The Tribunal stated last year that it was not the proper forum to resolve disputes over copyright ownership, which position has just recently been affirmed by the Court of Appeals, NBC v. Copyright Royalty Tribunal, ---- F. 2d. ---- (D.C. Cir. 1988), and it urged the jukebox claimants to settle this matter. We continue to urge them to resolve who owns the contested songs, but for this proceeding, we conclude that the Tribunal can reach a proper allocation without determining the ownership of the songs in question.

 Accordingly, the Tribunal awards 0.07% of the 1986 jukebox royalty fund to ACEMLA as the assumed name of Latin American Music Co., Inc. The remainder of the fund is awarded to ASCAP, BMI and SESAC, Inc., collectively.

 Mario F. Aguero,

 Chairman.

  Dated: September 14, 1988.

 [FR Doc. 88-21282 Filed 9-16-88; 8:45 am]


Please refer to the IP Mall Copyright Royalty Tribunal homepage for details on this valuable resource.