Copyright Royalty Tribunal

NOTICES
 
COPYRIGHT ROYALTY TRIBUNAL
 
[Docket No. CRT 89-2-87CD]
 
1987 Cable Royalty Distribution Proceeding
 
Friday, February 16, 1990
 
AGENCY: Copyright Royalty Tribunal.

 ACTION: Notice of final determination of Devotional Claimants controversy.

 SUMMARY: The Copyright Royalty Tribunal announces the adoption of a final determination in the proceeding concerning the distribution to Devotional Claimants of royalty fees paid by cable systems for secondary transmissions during 1987. A final determination of the Music Claimants controversy will be issued at a later date.

 FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:Robert Cassler, General Counsel, Copyright Royalty Tribunal, 1111 20th Street, NW., Suite 450, Washington, DC 20036 (202- 653-5175).

 SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

 Authority

  Section 111(d)(3) of the Copyright Act, as amended August 27, 1986, authorizes the Copyright Royalty Tribunal to distribute annually royalty fees paid by cable systems to those copyright owners whose works were the subject of secondary transmissions by cable systems.

 This Proceeding

  In this proceeding, the Tribunal takes up the distribution of the royalty fees deposited by cable operators for the calendar year 1987. In accordance with past procedures, the Tribunal resolved that the 1987 distribution proceeding would be conducted in two phases. In Phase I, the Tribunal would determine the allocation of cable royalties among various program categories of claimants. The Phase I categories were: Program Suppliers, Sports, Noncommercial Television, U.S. Commercial Television, Music, Devotional Claimants, Canadian Claimants, Noncommercial Radio and Commercial Radio. In Phase II, the Tribunal would allocate cable royalties to individual claimants within a program category.

 For this 1987 proceeding, there were no controversies in Phase I. All Phase I parties settled based upon the allocations made by the Tribunal in the 1983 cable distribution proceeding (The 1984-1986 Phase I controversies were similarly settled on the basis of the 1983 allocations.)

 In Phase II, there were two controversies. Within the Devotional Claimants category, two parties advanced claims which, when combined, exceeded 100% of the category. One of the parties was the Settling Devotional Claimants (SDC) which includes The Christian Broadcasting Network, Inc. (CBN), Old Time Gospel Hour (OTGH), The Inspirational Network (TIN), Oral Roberts Evangelical Association (OREA), In Touch Ministries, Inc. (ITM), Multimedia Entertainment, Inc. (Multimedia) First Century Broadcasting, Inc. (First Century) and the National Association of Broadcasters (NAB). The other party was Christian Television Corporation (CTC). SDC claimed 100% of the Devotional Claimants category, except for a nominal award to CTC ranging from $100 to 0.4% of the category. CTC claimed 10% of the category.

 Within the Music category, two parties advanced claims which, when *5648 combined, exceeded 100% of the category. The two parties were: American Society of Composers, Authors and Publishers (ASCAP) and Broadcast Music, Inc. (BMI). ASCAP claimed 67-72% of the Music category. BMI claimed not less than 50% of the Music category.

 The Tribunal heard the two controversies on a staggered schedule, so that the record concerning the Devotional Claimants was developed earlier than for the Music Claimants. Consequently, the Tribunal has decided for the first time to issue its final determination of a cable royalty fund distribution in two parts. This determination concerns only the Devotional Claimants. It is intended to be a final decision of this controversy for purposes of Sections 809 and 810 of the Copyright Act. A final determination of the Music Claimants controversy will be issued at a later date.

 Background and Chronology

  Six hundred and seventy-five (675) individual or joint claims were filed with the Tribunal for the 1987 cable royalty fund. On February 1, 1989, the Tribunal published a notice directing all claimants to inform the Tribunal by March 23, 1989 whether any controversies existed concerning the distribution of the 1987 cable royalty fees. 54 FR 5119.

 Based upon the written comments which were submitted, the Tribunal announced on March 30, 1989 that controversies did exist in both Phase I and Phase II of the 1987 cable distribution proceeding, effective April 3, 1989. 54 FR 13101.

 On April 14, 1989, the Tribunal received notice that all Phase I controversies had been resolved, and that the parties had agreed to a Phase I allocation of cable royalties on the same basis as the allocations made for the 1983-1986 funds. Concerning Phase II, the Tribunal found that controversies existed in the Program Supplies, the Noncommercial Television, the Music and the Devotional Claimants categories.

 On April 24, 1989, the Tribunal adopted the agreed-upon Phase I allocations, and ordered an 80% distribution of the royalties in the Devotional Claimants category, and a 100% distribution of all other Phase I categories. 54 FR 16387.

 On September 14, 1989, the Tribunal was advised that OREA, ITM, and First Century had reached a settlement with CBN, OTGH and TIN, thereby reducing the controversies in the Devotional Claimants category to a single controversy between the Settling Devotional Claimants and CTC.

 On September 15, 1989, the Tribunal was informed that all controversies had been settled in the Program Suppliers and the Noncommercial Television category.

 Accordingly, the Tribunal revised its hearing schedule to hear two controversies. [FN1] On September 15, 1989, the Devotional Claimants direct cases took place on October 25 and 26, 1989. Rebuttal cases were filed November 17, 1989.

   FN1 A background and chronology of the Music controversy will be described in the separate determination concerning Music.

 On November 22, 1989, the Settling Devotional Claimants moved for an additional partial distribution of the funds in the Devotional Claimants category. On November 27, 1989, the Tribunal ordered an additional distribution of 5% of the funds in the category.

 On December 4 and 5, 1989, the Tribunal heard the rebuttal cases of the Devotional Claimants whereupon the record was closed. Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law were filed by the Devotional Claimants on December 20, 1989. Reply Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law were filed January 10, 1990.

 Controversy One: The Devotional Claimants

 Finding of Fact

  The claimants. The Settling Devotional Claimants (SDC) are a group of religious programmers who reached confidential agreements among themselves concerning the division of royalties from the Devotional Claimants category. SDC Ex. 1, p. 3; Tr. 18-19. They include:

 The Christian Broadcasting Network, Inc. (CBN), producer of "The 700 Club," "Superbook," "Flying House," and "Another Life." "The 700 Club" is a 90-minute daily magazine format program featuring Pat Robertson. It is videotaped each week day before a live studio audience, and features interviews with newsmakers. "Superbook" and "Flying House" are 102 half-hour animated programs for children featuring characters from the Bible. "Another Life" is a 30-minute continuing daily drama, or "soap opera." SDC Ex. 1, pp. 4-5; Tr. 19-20.

 The Old Time Gospel Hour (OTGH), producer of the "Old Time Gospel Hour," a weekly 60-minute Sunday service conducted by the Reverened Jerry Falwell at Thomas Road Baptist Church in Lynchburg, Virginia. SDC Ex. 1, p. 4; Tr. 21.

 The Inspirational Network (TIN), successor in interest to the producer of the "PTL Club," also known during 1987 as "The Jim and Tammy Show." The "PTL Club" is a daily one-hour program. SDC Ex. 1, p. 4; Tr. 20.

 Oral Roberts Evangelical Association (OREA), producer of "Richard Roberts Live," a daily 60-minute talk/variety show. OREA also produces a weekend 30- minute program called "Expect a Miracle" (formerly known as "Oral Roberts and You") which features Oral Roberts and musical presentations, and ministry-oriented productions. SDC Ex. 1, p. 5; Tr. 20.

 In Touch Ministries, Inc. (ITM), producer of "In Touch," a weekend program featuring the church service and speaking of Dr. Charles Stanley at the First Baptist Church of Atlanta. SDC Ex. 1, p. 4; Tr. 20.

 First Century Broadcasting, Inc. (First Century), producer of four daily religious talk shows entitled, "California Tonight," "New Mexico Tonight," "New York Tonight," and "Double Image." SDC Ex. 1, p. 5; Tr. 22.

 Multimedia Entertainment, Inc. (Multimedia), producer of "Gospel Singing Jubilee," a one-hour musical program hosted by Les Beasley and The Florida Boys. SDC Ex. 1, p. 5.

 The National Association of Broadcasters (NAB), representing the claims of broadcast stations that produce and syndicate devotional programming, such as local church services and Christian talk shows. SDC Ex. 1, pp. 3-4, n. 1; Tr. 23.

 The other party to this controversy is Christian Television Corporation (CTC). CTC owns and oeprates WCLF-TV, a Christian television station in Clearwater, Florida. CTC Ex. 1, p. 3. CTC is the producer and distributor of eleven programs. They are: "Joy Junction," a half-hour program of games, contests and Bible quizzes intended for children aged 8 to 12 which takes place in a small town called Joy Junction. CTC Ex. 2, p. 1. "Becky's Barn," a half-hour program designed to teach Bible principles to pre-school age children. Id. "Solo Act," a half-hour weekly program targeted to single audults. CTC Ex. 1, p. 10.; CTC Ex. 5. "Action Sixties," a one-hour Christian program for senior adults. It airs live each weekday at 10 a.m. and is repeated each evening at 6 p.m. CTC Ex. 1, p. 10; CTC Ex. 12. "Good Night Alive," a live one-hour late-night Christian talk/variety show. CTC Ex. 1, p. 11; CTC Ex. 5. "Celebrate with Jessy Dixon," a half-hour Black/Contemporary Gospel music program. *5649 CTC Ex. 5. "Word For the World," a half-hour program hosted by Dr. Ron Cottle offering Greek and Hebrew language interpretations of the Bible. Id. "The Miller Brothers," a fifteen minute program featuring fast-paced Gospel music. Id. "The Good Life," a one-hour talk/variety program hosted by Christian Television Network President Robert D'Andrea and Molly D'Andrea. It airs live daily at 12:30 p.m. and is repeated nationally in prime time at 9 p.m. Id. CTC Ex. 12. "The Downings," a half-hour Southern/Contemporary Gospel music program with interviews. CTC Ex. 5. "This is Your Day," a half-hour weekly Bible teaching on praise and worship hosted by Molly D'Andrea. Id.

 SDC's Claim. The Special Nielsen Study--To demonstrate its entitlement, SDC submitted a portion of the 1987 Special Nielsen Study conducted by the A.C. Nielsen Company. The study measures the hours of distant signal nonnetwork programming which are viewed by cable households. SDC Ex. 1, p. 6. The study is based on data derived from Nielsen Station Index survey conducted during six rating cycles in 1987. Tr. 52, 271-273.

 For the 1987 study, the sample of U.S. commercial television stations consisted of all stations which were retransmitted as full-time distant signals by Form 3 cable systems with an average of 80,000 subscribers per accounting period. 119 television broadcast stations qualified for inclusion in the sample. Id.; Tr. 74-75. SDC asserted that the 119 stations accounted for 97 percent of the distant signal viewing in 1987. Tr. 46.

 The number of viewing hours for each of the claimants were as follows:

 
----------------------------------------------
          Program Viewing hours
----------------------------------------------
700 Club ........................... 2,366,118
Old Time Gospel Hour ............... 1,387,718
PTL Club ............................. 566,029
Expect a Miracle ..................... 197,670
Richard Roberts ...................... 110,124
In Touch Ministry ..................... 45,928
                              ----------------
Total .............................. 4,673,587
----------------------------------------------
 

 SDC Ex. 2.

 First Century, Multimedia, NAB, and CTC garnered no viewing hours in the Nielsen study. SDC Ex. 2; Tr. 26-27.

 On the basis that the Settling Devotional Claimants had 4,673,587 cable household viewing hours in 1987 and CTC had none, SDC argued that CTC should be awarded at most a nominal award from the Tribunal. SDC Ex. 1, pp. 7-9

 Abandonment--SDC also argued that CTC should receive no award because it has abandoned its copyrights in its eleven programs. SDC Ex. R-15. CTC transmits its signal unscrambled to satellite carriers. Tr. 175-178. CTC is not aware until viewers, station owners or cable operators write to inform them which television stations are transmitting, and which cable systems are retransmitting its programs. Id. CTC transmits its programs by satellite to get the widest possible use of its programs as one method of raising funds. Tr. 177. CTC does not inform potential users that they need license agreements. Tr. 178.

 CTC alleges all its programs were copyrighted; SDC did not allege CTC's programs lacked the notice of copyright. CTC Ex. 5; SDC Ex. R-15. CTC submitted two letters, one granting a Kentucky station permission in 1987 to rebroadcast CTC's programs, the other granting an Iowa station permission in 1988 to rebroadcast CTC's programs. Ex. Rx-5, RX-5A. As a practice, most religious broadcasters do not scramble their signals. TR. 438.

 CTC's claim. Instances of carriage--Based on the Cable Data Corporation survey of November 9, 1989, CTC's programs were carried on 13 broadcast stations in the first half of 1987 and were transmitted by 35 distant cable systems. In the second half of 1987 CTC's programs were carried on 14 broadcast stations which were retransmitted by 33 distant cable systems. SDC Ex. RX-1.

 According to the Cable Data Corporation survey of October 26, 1989, CBN, OTGH and TIN, together, were carried by 3,051 distant cable systems in the first half of 1987, and 3,148 distant cable systems in the second half of 1987. Id.

 Consequently, in terms of instances of carriage, CTC's relative percentage compared to CBN, OTGH, and TIN, Was 1.13% for the first half of 1987, and 1.04% for the second half of 1987.

 Subscriber reach--Based on the same Cable Data Corporation survey, the 35 cable systems which retransmitted CTC's programs on a distant signal basis in the first half of 1987 served 414,887 subscribers. The 33 cable systems which retransmitted CTC's programs on a distant signal basis in the second half of 1987 served 444,857 subscribers. Id.

 In the first half 1987, the 3,051 cable systems which retransmitted either CBN, OTGH and/or TIN served 58,390,355 subscribers. In the second half of 1987, the 3,148 cable systems which retransmitted either CBN, OTGH, and/or TIN served 62,388,774. Id.

 Consequently, in terms of the potential reach to cable subscribers, CTC's relative percentage compared to CBN, OTGH and TIN, was 0.71% for the first half of 1987, and 0.71% for the second half of 1987.

 Time plus fee generation formula--CTC performed a time plus fee generation analysis based on data supplied by Cable Data Corporation. The method is to take the royalties paid by cable systems for the retransmission of the broadcast stations on which CTC's programs were performed and to multiply that by the percentage of time that CTC's programs occupied the broadcast schedule. CTC Ex. 6. It is based on the assumption that each distant signal carried by a cable operator has equal value. Tr. 117-119, 141-144.

 None of CTC's programs were on stations paid for by cable systems at the 3.75% rate. Tr. 120. Of the cable royalties paid for at the basic rate, CTC's formula yielded a result of $15,311.43 generated by CTC's programs' time on the air. CTC Ex. RX-1.

 In rebuttal, SDC presented a similar time plus fee generation analysis of CBN, OTGH and TIN. These three claimants were said to have generated $1,153.058.28 in basic royalties, and $320,308.62 in 3.75% royalties. SDC Exs. R-4, p. 2, R-5, R-9.

 However, WWOR dropped "The 700 Club" from its proramming after September 18, 1987. Thus "The 700 Club" was carried by WWOR for 43.5% of the second half of 1987. Letter of December 6, 1989, filed by SDC. "The 700 Club" is claimed to have generated $217,606.90 in basic royalties and $125,923.90 in 3.75% royalties for the second half of 1987. SDC Exs. R-5, R-9. Reducing the fees generating to account for the dropping of "The 700 Club" would yield a result of $1,030,110.38 in basic royalties and $249,161.62 in 3.75% royalties for CBN, OTGH and TIN for all of 1987.

 CTC's percentage of fees generated compared to CBN, OTGH and TIN after accounting for WWOR's dropping of "The 700 Club" is 1.46% of basic royalties, 0% of 3.75% royalties.

 In proposed findings, SDC argued that CTC should be given no credit in the fee generation formula for the fees paid by the Lakeland, Florida cable system for retransmission of WCLF-TV. SDC Proposed Findings, paras. 49-52. In 1984, 1985 and part of 1986, the Lakeland cable system sent WCLF a bill to reimburse the system for the cable copyright royalties arising from the retransmission of WCLF-TV. Tr. 199. In 1987, the cable system again sent a bill, but WCLF did not pay because its agreement to pay was with a preceding owner of the Lakeland cable system. Id. In 1988, the cable system dropped WCLF *5650 for its failure to reimburse the cable system. Tr. 199-200. SDC argues that this indicates an unwillingness by the Lakeland system to pay the cable fees, and that the fees generated by that system's carriage of WCLF should be deducted from CTC. SDC Proposed Findings, para. 50. Deducting the Lakeland system would yield a total of $7,513.68 in fees generated by CTC's programs, or 0.72% of basic royalties of CTC, CBN, OTGH and TIN combined. Id., para. 51.

 Harm--CIC argued it has incurred harm in the cable distant signal marketplace. CTC Ex. 1, pp. 4, 7-9. CTC transmits its signal unscrambled on satellite carriers. Tr. 177, 362. Some cable systems retransmit CTC's signal without CTC's knowledge. CTC. Ex. 1, p. 8. When CTC is unaware that a cable system is retransmitting CTC's signal, it is not able to promote its programs to the cable subscribers through direct-mail appeals or other types of advertisement. Id. CTC has a direct mail return response rate of 10.5%, with an average donation per return of $10.37. Id.

 As a practice, religious broadcasters do not scramble their signals, although CBN scrambles its signals during some portions of the day. Tr. 438. In that respect, CTC is in no different position than other religious programmers. Tr. 169, 176.

 Benefit--CTC argued that it has a greater variety of programs that any of the other claimants. CTC argued that each of the eleven programs targets a different audience, and offer something diverse and unique. CTC Proposed Findings, paras. 29-48.

 Marketplace value--CTC argued that it has greater marketplace value than the other devotional programmers because in 1987 it did not have to pay any broadcasters to broadcast its programs, while the other devotional claimants' primary method to get broadcast stations to air their works is to pay them. CTC Ex. 1, pp. 5, 13; Tr. 55, 285. SDC stated that the policy of devotional programmers of buying airtime is based on their interest in keeping commercials off their programs. Tr. 292-293.

 CTC argued that indications of both benefits and marketplace value were the 2000 letters per month received by CTC from viewers of "Joy Junction." CTC Ex. 2, CTC Supp. Direct Ex. 1.

 Time--CTC argued that its programs had significant carriage during prime time. Eight of the eleven CTC programs aired a total of 17 times per week in prime time on 16 distant systems. CTC Ex. 1, p. 15; Tr. 206. 15 of the 17 instances were carriage of WCLF, CTC's flagship station. Tr. 207.

 Quality--CTC cited the high technical quality of its programs and that its "Joy Junction" is a winner of four national silver Angel awards for religious programming. CTC Exs. 2, 9, 10. SDC acknowledged that CTC produces quality programs. Tr. 257. CTC acknowledged that the other claimants in the Devotional category produce quality devotional programs. Tr. 218.

 Conclusions of Law

  SDC has shown entitlement to 99.2% of the basic fund and 100% of the 3.75% fund within the Devotional Claimants category. CTC has shown entitlement to 0.8% of the basic fund and 0% of the 3.75% fund within the Devotional Claimants category.

 The first question to be considered in this controversy is whether CTC abandoned its copyright in its eleven claimed programs. If that were so, then CTC could not be awarded any cable royalties, because the Tribunal may make awards only to copyright owners.

 The doctrine of abandonment is one that necessarily turns on the particular facts of a case. None of the cases cited by SDC were in the context of broadcasting or satellite transmission. However, courts have stated the general test.

 Abandonment of copyright must be manifested by some overt act indicative of intent to surrender rights in a copyrighted work and to allow the public to copy it; mere inaction is not sufficient manifestation of such intent. Rohauer v. Killiam Shows, Inc., 379 F. Supp. 723 (S.D.N.Y. 1974), rev'd on other grounds, 551 F. 2d 484 (2d Cir. 1974). The presence of a notice is strong evidence of an intent not to abandon. Bell v. Combined Registry Company, 397 F. Supp. 1241 (N.D. Ill. 1975), aff'd on other grounds, 536 F. 2d 164 (7th Cir. 1975). A proprietor who desires to preserve his legal monopoly must be vigilant in policing distributions of the work. Id.

 Abandonment, then, is based on intent. It does not operate automatically as forfeiture does when a copyright owner neglects to put notice on his work. It must be found that the creator intended to abandon his work. That intent must be demonstrated by an overt act. The overt act which SDC points to is the transmitting of an unscrambled signal without additional efforts to communicate that a license is needed, or efforts to see who is actually using the works.

 We do not see that SDC has met its burden. Transmitting unscrambled signals, apparently, is a common practice. The vigilance in policing one's works which SDC has cited as a requirement in the context of Bell v. Combined Registry Company and other cited cases dealt with whether the copyright owner put the copyright notice on his work, not whether the owner took additional steps. It has not been shown that CTC failed to put its notice of copyright on any of its works. CTC has shown that it does issue licenses. If CTC has been, in some people's view, lax, that does not amount to clear indications of CTC's intent to surrender its rights. The Tribunal concludes for purposes of this distribution that CTC is the copyright owner of its eleven claimed programs.

 This is the first time in which there has been a controversy within the Devotional Claimants category. As a result, the task has been to ascertain the best evidence on which to base an allocation of Devotional Claimants category without the benefit of prior Phase II proceedings. [FN2]

   FN2 Therefore, no consideration of changed circumstances was appropriate. Accordingly, the Tribunal did not consider testimony presented by CTC purporting to show declines in distant signal carriage of SDC's programs from 1986 to be relevant, and no findings of fact were made on this point.

 The Tribunal has traditionally looked to the special Nielsen study as its starting off point when it has considered controversies in Phase I and in the Program Suppliers category. Devotional producers and distributors are also program suppliers, and our conclusion continues to hold that the special Nielsen study in this record provided the most relevant evidence, because it included viewership.

  In this proceeding, the Nielsen data yields a result of 100% for the Settling Devotional Claimants, and 0% for CTC. Yet, the record clearly shows that CTC's programs had a certain level of distant signal carriage. One of the criticisms that has been consistently lodged against reliance on the Nielsen study is that it is not a complete census. It measures only the broadcast tations with the most distant signal retransmissions. The Tribunal has recognized the validity of this criticism, and while the Tribunal has not asked for a complete census, we have stated, "(T)he Tribunal will give credit, when shown, that a claimant's programs have not been measured at all, or have been significantly undermeasured." 1985 Cable Royalty Distribution Proceeding, 54 FR 7132, 7136 (1988).

 CTC's programs have not been measured at all. Accordingly, the Tribune must look to other indicia of entitlement to weigh the distant signal *5651 carriage which CTC has shown did occur in 1987.

 CTC has endeavored to distinguish its programs from the programs of SDC in all five of the Tribunal's criteria--harm, benefit, marketplace value, time and quality. For each of these distinctions, CTC has requested a 1% bonus which represents 5% of their 10% claim.

 However, the Tribunal can perceive no essential differences between CTC and the other devotional programmers. Concerning harm, the type of harm the Tribunal has given credit for in past proceedings is the harm to the exploitation of one's copyright, not difficulties of a general sort. CTC's distribution is similar to other devotional programmers' in that it charges nothing for the carriage of its programs and it seeks the widest dissemination possible. Therefore, it is not harmed by cable retransmission. It is helped. While CTC might be helped further by the cooperation of cable systems in notifying CTC of their programs being retransmitted, this lack of additional help is not harm as the Tribunal has employed the term.

 Concerning benefit, the Tribunal has recognized in Phase I that the devotional programmers add to the diversity that cable operators can offer their subscribers as compared to the other Phase I program types of movies, sports, news, etc. But further subdividing a particular category in Phase II to show more diversity can only be credited if there were a real marketplace response to this subdivision. But CTC's programs have barely penetrated the marketplace when one looks at the instances of retransmission. A mere assertion of diversity is not enough to obtain a credit.

 CTC attempts to show marketplace value based on its not having paid to have its programs aired on broadcast stations. Yet the explanation of the other claimants that they pay stations to keep their programs free of commercials has been accepted by the Tribunal in the past. CTC might have gotten some credit had stations paid for its programs, but otherwise, we do not consider that it has shown more marketplace value than the other programmers.

 Concerning time, the record shows CTC's prime time positioning is basically confined to its flagship station. Quality, as a factor, is true of the programming of all the claimants.

 Consequently, the Tribunal, having decided that there are no features of CTS's programs such as would distinguish them from SDC's programs, turns to the various mathematical indicia in the record. In terms of instances of carriage, CTC's percentage is 1.13% for the first half of 1987, and 1.04% for the second half of 1987, while CBN, OTGH AND TIN's percentages are 98.87% and 98.96%, respectively. In terms of subscriber reach, CTC's percentages are 0.71% for both halves of 1987, and CBN, OTGH and TIN's percentage is 99.29%.

 In terms of time plus fee generation formula, the applicable percentages are CTC--1.46% for basic royalties, 0% for 3.75% royalties; CBN, OTGH TIN--98.54% for basic royalties, 100% for 3.75% royalties.

 SDC argued that the time plus fee generation formula should not be adjusted for the dropping of CBN from WWOR'S schedule in September, 1987. SDC reasons that if a station is carried even one day into the second half of a year, the cable systems owes for the entire seniannual pay period. SDC's argument would be true if all of WWOR was dropped by the cable systems, but WWOR continued to be carried. Only CBN dropped, and another program was substituted for it. A time-based formula necessarily takes into account the actual time a program was on the air. In any event, the formula is being offered for its relevance to marketplace value, and to ignore the dropping of CBN would be to defeat the purpose for which the evidence was developed.

 SDC also argued that the carriage of CTC's programs by the Lakeland cable system should be eliminated from the fee generation formula, because Lakeland only wanted to retransmit the signal if it were reimbursed for it. Here, SDC's argument is more valid. Since the formula is being offered for its relevance to marketplace value, circumstances showing that the Lakeland system expected reimbursement undercuts the indiction of value in the formula. However, rather than eliminating Lakeland system's carriage of CTC's program entirely from the formula, the Tribunal believes a downward adjustment is more appropriate.

 What relevance the time plus fee generation formula has in Tribunal proceedings has been argued many times in the past. The Tribunal has clearly rejected it as a mechanistic formula because it distorts marketplace analysis. The formula assigns an equal value to all programming based on time, regardless of popularity and demand, so that a program scheduled at three in the morning is assigned equal value to a prime time program. And it is based on an assumption that the cable operator values all programming equally when, to the contrary, the Tribunal has received convincing evidence that cable operators have strongly different preferences. The Nielsen study, on the other hand, provides the necessary weighting of the programs--the actual viewing--which makes it the more relevant evidence.

 However, the Tribunal has just as consistently stated that time plus fee generation has some relevance and could enter the record as part of the mix of evidence indicating the proper allocation. In Phase II, its use has had more relevance because like programming is being compared and the potential for gross marketplace distoraton is less, although never acepted at full value. A time analysis was used in allocating royalties between broadcasters and the music claimants in the Commercial Radio category, 1979 Cable Royalty Distribution Determination (Remand), 49 FR 20048, 20051 (1984), and a time plus fee generaton formula entered into the consideration of ACEMLA's claim in the Music Category in the 1985 cable royalty distribution proceeding. 1985 Cable Royalty Distribution Proceeding, 54 FR 7132, 7139 (1988).

 There, the fee generation formula served to confirmed an assessment of the record which the Tribunal had reached on other grounds. Here, too, the formula complements the other findings as to instances of carriage and subscriber reach. Together, a picture is formed of the actual marketplace in 1987 which is supported equally by all the indicia.

 Taking into account all the indicia shown by the claimants--the Nielsen study, the instances of carriage, the subscriber reach and the time plus fee generation formula--the Tribunal has determined that CTC has shown an entitlement to 0.8% of the basic royalties, and SDC has shown entitlement to 99.2%. The record indicates that there was not a single instance of a cable system paying 3.75% rate royalties for retransmission of a station carrying CTC's program. Thus the Tribunal concludes that CTC has demonstrated no entitlement to any of the 3.75% royalties.

 In reaching this conclusion, the Tribunal took into consideration that the mathematical indicia of instances of carriage, subscriber reach and time plus fee generation formula only accounted for three of SDC's claimants--CBN, OTGH and TIN. Some adjustment was made for the fact that the other SDC claimants would have improved SDC's percentages had their figures been included.

 Allocation

  Within the Devotional Claimants category, the Tribunal has made the *5652 following allocation of the 1987 cable copyright royalty fund:

 
Basic:
SDC ........... 99.2%
CTC ............ 0.8%
3.75%:
SDC ............ 100%
CTC .............. 0%
 

 Commissioner Cindy S. Daub did not participate in the determination of this controversy.

 Dated: February 9, 1990.

 J.C. Argetsinger,

 Chairman.

 [FR Doc. 90-3622 Filed 2-15-90; 8:45 am]


Please refer to the IP Mall Copyright Royalty Tribunal homepage for details on this valuable resource.