Copyright Royalty Tribunal

NOTICES
 
COPYRIGHT ROYALTY TRIBUNAL
 
[Docket No. CRT 89-2-87CD]
 
1887 Cable Royalty Distribution Proceeding
 
Friday, March 30, 1990
 
AGENCY: Copyright Royalty Tribunal.

 ACTION: Notice of final determination of music controversy.

 SUMMARY: The Copyright Royalty Tribunal announces the adoption of a final determination in the proceeding concerning the distribution to Music claimants of royalty fees paid by cable systems for secondary transmissions during 1987.

 FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Robert Cassler, General Counsel, Copyright Royalty Tribunal, 1111 20th Street, NW., Suite 450, Washington, DC 20036 (202- 653-5175).

 SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: Section 111(d)(3) of the Copyright Act, as amended August 27, 1986, authorizes the Copyright Royalty Tribunal to distribute annually royalty fees paid by cable systems to those copyright owners whose works were the subject of secondary transmissions by cable systems.

 In this proceeding, the Tribunal takes up the distribution of the royalty fees deposited by cable operators for the calendar year 1987. In an earlier determination, published in the Federal Register on February 16, 1990, the Tribunal described that all Phase I controversies had been settled, and that there remained only two Phase II controversies to be decided. 55 FR 5647. One was in the Devotional Claimants category. The final determination of that controversy was published February 16, 1990. Id. The second controversy was in the Music category. The Music controversy is the subject of this final determination.

 Background and Chronology

  A general background of the 1987 cable royalty distribution proceeding was described in the Devotional Claimants final determination. Id. Concerning the Music controversy, two parties, the American Society of Composers, Authors and Publishers (ASCAP), and Broadcast Music, Inc. (BMI), advanced conflicting claims, all other Music claimants having settled their differences. ASCAP claimed 67-72% of the category. BMI claimed not less than 50%.

 On September 22, 1989, the Music claimants filed their direct cases. The Tribunal held a pre-hearing conference on November 1, 1989 to rule on discovery requests. Hearing of the Music claimants' direct cases took place on December 14, 15, 18, and 19, 1989.

 Rebuttal cases were filed January 10, 1990. Hearing of the rebuttal cases took place on January 18, and 19, 1990, after which the record was closed.

 Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law were filed by the Music Claimants on February 9, 1990. Reply Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law were filed February 16, 1990.

 Controversy Two: The Music Claimants

 Findings of Fact

  The Claimants. ASCAP and BMI are performing rights societies who represent thousands of composers and publishers to collect fees for the public performance of copyrighted published nondramatic musical works. Each year since 1978, ASCAP and BMI have collected cable royalties from the Tribunal. ASCAP and BMI have been in agreement concerning the distribution of cable royalties in each year, except for 1978. In 1978, the Tribunal based its determination of the Music controversy on five categories of evidence: (a) Total license fee revenues of the performing rights societies; (b) performing rights societies share of 1978 local television license rates; (c) performing rights societies share of 1978 television and radio performance credits; (d) performing rights societies share of 1978 jukebox royalty fees; (e) performing rights societies share in 1978 public broadcasting proceeding of the Tribunal and voluntary licenses with educational institutions. 45 FR 63041. In the 1978 proceeding, the Tribunal give a relative award to ASCAP and BMI of 55.67% and 44.33%, respectively (not including SESAC's award). Id.

 ASCAP's claim. To demonstrate its entitlement to 1987 royalties, ASCAP performed four different studies. each one intended to ascertain the actual performances of music on cable retransmissions in 1987. ASCAP believed that these studies would provide more relevant information than the five factors depended upon in the 1978 proceeding. Test. of Gloria Messinger, pp. 3-4.

 The 53-station study--according to data complied by Cable Data Corporation (also called Larson data), 608 broadcast stations were carried as distant signals by cable systems in the first half of 1987, and 629 were carried as distant signals in the second half of 1987. Test. of Peter Boyle, p. 10, fn. 10. ASCAP chose to study the musical performance on the top 64 broadcast stations, those stations which generated cable royalty fees of $100,000 or more in 1987. Id., p. 10.

 Of the top 64 stations, nine could not be studied because they were Canadian stations, and two could not be studied because they did not appear in ASCAP's local television survey of performances in 1987. Id., p. 11, fn. 13.

 Consequently, ASCAP performed a study of 53 of the 64 top distantly-carried broadcast stations in 1987. These stations accounted for 90.68% of all fees generated, 67.78% of all instances of carriage, and 73.28% of all subscribers. Id., p. 11, fn. 14.

 ASCAP identified the music actually performed on those 53 television stations, as shown by ASCAP's survey of local television performances in 1987. Id., p. 20. Apart from these proceedings, ASCAP, in the normal course of its business, surveys programs in order to make distributions to its members. It bases its distribution on a system of abstract credits which give different weights to different types of musical performances. Tr. 593, 595; Test of Peter Boyle, p. 5; ASCAP Ex. 3. In the regular conduct of its survey, ASCAP sampled these stations' programming for 5,400 *11989 hours in 1987. Tr. 593-594. ASCAP determined the credits generated by musical performances on these stations, and then determined which of these performances were of compositions in the ASCAP repertory. Test. of Peter Boyle, p. 12.

 The 53-station study results were then weighted by the Larson data for fees generated, instances of carriage and subscriber reach. ASCAP asserted that when weighted for fees generated, ASCAP music accounted for 67.7% of all performances on the 53 stations. When weighted for instances of carriage, ASCAP music accounted for 67.5%, and when weighted for number of subscribers reached, ASCAP music accounted for 67.0% of performances. Test. of Peter Boyle, pp. 13-14.

 Census of WTBS performances--According to the Larson data, WTBS accounted for 37.59% of all fees generated in 1987. Id., p. 14. ASCAP undertook to take a census of all musical works on WTBS during 1987. Id. ASCAP used "TV Guide" listings to identify each program broadcast on WTBS in 1987. ASCAP then identified the music performed on those programs, relying primarily on cue sheets. Id., pp. 14-16. When ASCAP had no cue sheets, ASCAP referred to tape recording made of the programs on one or more occasions in 1987 as part of the ASCAP survey. Id. ASCAP analyzed approximately 8,700 hours of programming in the WTBS census. Tr. 653-654. ASCAP asserted that its music accounted for 71.9% of the total credits for performances of copyrighted music on WTBS in 1987. ASCAP Ex. 10.

 WTBS performances weighted by Nielsen data--Each year, the Motion Picture Association of America (MPAA) commissions the A.C. Nielsen Company to perform a special study of cable house hold viewing of distant broadcast stations. Test. of Peter Boyle, p. 20. ASCAP identified each of the programs carried on WTBS which were included in the Nielsen data and for which ASCAP had music use information. Id. P. 21. NSCAP then weighed the credits generated by the music in each program by the total number of viewers for each program, according to the Nielsen viewing data, controlling for the differeing lengths of programs. Id. ASCAP asserted that its share of performances on WTBS when weighted by the Nielson viewing data, was 67%. Id.

 WTBS programs weighted by Nielsen data for all surveyed stations--ASCAP applied the music use information it had on WTBS programs which were also carried by other broadcast stations in the Nielson study, and applied the Nielsen data for these programs for all of the approximately 120 distant signals. Id., p. 22. ASCAP asserted that the result yielded an ASCAP share of 67%. Id.

 Quality--ASCAP works or members have won 126 Oscars for the years 1934-1987; 62 Tony Awards (1949-1987); 18 Grammys for Song of the Year since 1958; 70 prime time Emmys since 1954. ASCAP Ex. 1. 19 of 20 non-silent films recently selected for the National Film Registry contained exclusively or predominantly ASCAP music. Test. of Gloria Messinger, pp. 6-7.

 BMI's criticism of ASCAP's studies--All four of ASCAP's studies have as an essential component ASCAP's local television distribution survey. Tr. 668. BMI lodged several criticisms of ASCAP's distribution survey. BMI Proposed Findings, pp. 43-63.

 BMI argued that ASCAP's distribution survey lacks relevance to the marketplace value of the music it represents. Id.; pp. 46-49. The distribution survey is designed for ASCAP's internal distribution to its members. Test. of Gloria Messinger, p. 5. Its design is based upon what ASCAP believes would achieve an equitable distribution to its members, and, competitively, would attract and/or retain the most members. Id., Tr. 1141. The choice of television stations to be surveyed is based upon "follow the dollar," the extent to which stations pay ASCAP royalty fees. Tr. 681-682. ASCAP assigns different values to different music, depending on whether it is feature, theme or background, giving the most weight to feature music. Tr. 1258.

 BMI perceived that this results in a favorable bias toward ASCAP works because of a great predominance of ASCAP feature music in older films. Id.

 ASCAP changes its weighting system from time to time. In mid-1987, ASCAP doubled the rate for theme music. Id. Recently, ASCAP changed its rules to triple the payment for gospel music performances in all media. BMI Ex. 3; Tr. 1141.

 Prior performances of music is given weight in ASCAP's distribution survey. Tr. 1265. Prior performances of BMI's background music was not kept by ASCAP before 1980. Tr. 1144.

 BMI criticized that ASCAP's distribution survey can not be verified. BMI Proposed Findings, pp. 43-46. Certain aspects of ASCAP's distribution survey are confidential, such as the depth of the sampling of local television stations, and the precise use of station weight multipliers, strata multipliers and feature multipliers. Reb. Test. of David Black, pp. 4-5. Certain aspects of ASCAP's survey depends upon subjective judgments made by ASCAP employees such as whether a work was performed with dancers, or was the principal focus of audience attention. Id., p. 3. Certain aspects of the survey are not based on cue sheets, but listening to or viewing tapes that BMI asserted were not provided to it. Id.

 BMI critized that some of its music was excluded by ASCAP. BMI Prop. Findings, pp. 49-52. ASCAP employees ignored music that they considered unrecognizable. Tr. 1269. BMI gave as an example the theme to CNN Headline News. BMI licenses the theme, but it was unrecognizable to ASCAP employees and excluded from the surveys. Id. BMI also asserted that it is almost impossible to identify background music by listening to audiotapes. Tr. 1270. Some of the cue sheets ASCAP provided BMI indicated that BMI background music was crossed off the page. Thus, it was never entered into ASCAP's computer software's weighting process to attain abstract credits. Tr. 1271; BMI Ex. B-19R.

 BMI asserted that some music claimed by ASCAP belonged to the BMI repertory. BMI submitted in evidence cue sheets for 14 programs which ASCAP claimed, but which contain certain works licensed by BMI. BMI Ex. B-18R. ASCAP claims full credit for the film, "Moulin Rouge," although the "Song from Moulin Rouge" is licensed by BMI. Tr. 1271. ASCAP claimed the works of Bernard Hermann for the time he was an ASCAP member, but BMI pays the royalties to his estate. Tr. 774 (representation of counsel).

 BMI argued that ASCAP's studies give too much weight to WTBS. BMI Prop. Findings, pp. 54-56. WTBS' program mix is unusual in that it carries about twice the amount of film programming than the other stations on average, measured by quarter hours of air time. BMI Ex. B-14. TBS purchased the MGM film library in 1986, which contains many older films which have primarily ASCAP music. Tr. 1273. In the 53-station study conducted by ASCAP, no attempt was made to weight the 550-plus stations that were not studied. Therefore, WTBS' impact rises from 37.59% of all distant signal stations (in terms of fees generated measured by Larson data) to 41.45% of the 53 studied stations. ASCAP Exs. 5,7.

 ASCAP's responses to BMI's criticisms--ASCAP asserted that its distribution survey does represent the marketplace value of music. ASCAP Prop. Findings, para. 39-40; ASCAP Reply Prop. Findings, para. 18-20. Both ASCAP and BMI assign different values to different types of performances. Tr. 569-571; ASCAP Ex. 24x. While the *11990 actual weights ASCAP and BMI assign to feature, background and theme music differ, neither organization uses duration alone for crediting works. Tr. 570, 572, 648. Music publishers assign different values when they negotiate the synchronization license. Tr. 700- 701. The Tribunal has established different values in setting the public broadcasting compulsory license fees. 37 CFR 304.4(a).

 The ASCAP distribution survey is "blind" in that it tallies the performances of all music without regard to music ownership, and only after the calculations are made is the music divided among ASCAP and non-ASCAP repertories. Tr. 586. Dr. Boyle of ASCAP testified that he had conducted a further examination of his studies which indicated that BMI is not adversely affected regardless of how features, background and theme music is weighted because ASCAP's share of each of the performance types is within 3 percent of ASCAP average share of 67% of the music on the 53 stations, weighted by the Larson data. Tr. 652-653.

 ASCAP denied that its studies have excluded a significant amount of BMI music. ASCAP Reply Prop. Findings, para. 20-21. ASCAP did not credit the "CNN Headline News" theme, because the composer directly licensed it to CNN. Tr. 787-788; ASCAP Ex. 38RX. ASCAP acknowledged that "lined-through" music may have been involved in the 53-station survey, but it calculated that the difference it would make would be limited to 1.6%. ASCAP Ex. 41RX. Concerning ASCAP claiming credit for BMI's works, ASCAP got BMI's witness to concede that there may be works subject to dispute between ASCAP and BMI, but ASCAP offered no exhibits to show that was the case. Tr. 1294-1295. In the case of Bernard Hermann, although BMI is paying royalties, ASCAP disputed BMI's right to license his music. Tr. 773-776 (representation of counsel).

 BMI's Claim--To demonstrate its entitlement to 1987 royalties, BMI submitted evidence in accordance with the five categories of evidence relied upon by the Tribunal in the 1978 proceeding, the purpose of which was to show improvement by BMI in these categories as measured against the 1978 award.

 (A) Total license fee revenues--In the 1978 proceeding, the Tribunal found that total license revenues for BMI were $70,548,000 and for ASCAP were $114,117,000. 45 FR 63041. This represented a ratio of 38.2% for BMI and 61.8% for ASCAP.

 For 1987, BMI's revenues were $189,049,000 and ASCAP's revenues were $277,233,000. This represents a ratio of 40.5% for BMI and 59.5% for ASCAP. BMI Ex. B-1 (revised).

 (b) share of local televison license rates--In the 1978 proceeding, the Tribual found that BMI's local television contract provided for payment based on 58% of the fees paid to ASCAP. This represented a 36.7% share of total local television revenues for BMI and 63.3% for ASCAP. 45 FR 63041. BMI argued in that proceeding that its local television rate had been negotiated in 1972 and did not reflect what BMI considered were significant changes between 1972 and 1978. Id.

 BMI has been getting 68% of ASCAP's interim fees for 1987, but by a 1985 agreement, BMI is to get 70% of ASCAP's fees for 1987 when ASCAP's rate is finalized. Tr. 897, 1116. Using the 68% figure, this would represent a 40.5% share for BMI and a 59.5% share for ASCAP. Uisng the 70% figure, this would represent 41.2% share for BMI and 58% share for ASCAP.

 ASCAP asserted that the additional 2% payments to BMI do not represent a marketplace decision to value BMI music more, but it was offered by local television broadcasters in exchange for, among other things, a dismissal of an antitrust suit and agreeing to ask the Department of Justice to establish a mechamism for court determination of reasonable license fees similar to the mechanism established for ASCAP. Reb. Test. of Gloria Messinger, p. 9; ASCAP Ex. 18X.

 (c)(1) share of television performance credits--BMI undertook to construct a study that would replicate the music that was performed on secondary transmissions during 1987. Test. of Alan Smith, p. 4. First, BMI chose to study the music that was performed during the FCC's seven day "Composite Week," chosen for this study to be: Sunday, April 19, 1987, Monday, October 26, 1987, Tuesday, March 17, 1987, Wednesday, July 8, 1987, Thursday, September 24, 1987, Friday, August 21, 1987, Saturday, December 19, 1987. Id., p. 5.

 Next, BMI chose to study the five stations which generated the most fees in 1987: WTBS, WGN, WWOR, WPIX and WSBX. Together, they accounted for 80% of the royalties paid by Form 3 cable systems. Id. BMI analyzed "TV Guide" data to identify the programs that appeared on each of the five stations during the seven-day Composite Week. BMI then used the cue sheets which it receives from program producers and others to determine the amount of time encompassed by the music contained in those programs. Id., pp. 7-8. BMI's findings were broken down into aggregate timings of BMI music versus aggregate timings of music represented by other societies or public domain music. Id.

 To replicate the marketplace more accurately, BMI weighted the five stations in the study according to the fees that they generated, using Larson data Id. p. 9. To account for the 20% of the market which was not measured, BMI averaged the raw timings data of four of the five stations, WGN, WWOR, WPIX and WSBK.

 This average became the basis of a hypothetical sixth station called WRST which was assigned a weight equal to the weight of the unmeasured stations, and then added to the five station study to approximate 100% of the market. Id., p. 6. BMI excluded from the measurement of hypothetical station WRST the timings data for WTBS, because BMI found that WTBS had a percentage of programming time for movies twice that of the average station. Id., pp. 6-7.

 BMI also used Nielsen data to determine the percentage of time on each of the five stations that were devoted to film programming and to syndicated television series programming. Id., pp. 10-11. Because syndicated series programming accounted for a significantly greater amount of time than film programming, syndicated series programming was accorded a greater value by BMI. Id.

 The results of BMI's study was 47.2% for BMI and 52.8% for all other music. Id., p. 12. BMI estimated that 5% of all other music either was represented by SESAC or was in the public domain. Accordingly, when eliminating SESAC and public domain music, BMI calculated that its share vis-a-vis ASCAP was 49.7%.

 BMI made further adjustments to the study based on its belief that the syndicated exclusivity surcharge only applies to syndicated series programming. Id. pp. 13-15. However, the surcharge applies to both film and syndicated series programming. Reb. Test. of Alan Smith, pp. 8-9.

 ASCAP's criticisms of BMI's study--In the 1978 study performed by BMI, BMI based its calculations on occurrences of music. No weight was given to the length of time of each performance. Test. of Alan Smith, p. 5. In the 1987 study, BMI weighted its calculations based on the length of time. Id. However, all performances, regardless of whether they were feature, background or theme, were valued the *11991 same. Tr. 996, 1275. BMI normally makes distinctions among different types or performances in making its distributions. ASCAP Ex. 24X.

 BMI's study was smaller in scope than was ASCAP's--BMI sampled a maximum of 840 hours of programming versus ASCAP sample of 5400 hours in the 53-station survey and 8700 in the WTBS census. Tr. 1024-1025, 593-594, 653-654.

 When BMI did not know the particular episode of a syndicated series, it created an "average cue sheet" for that series, selecting the first 13 cue sheets in its files. These cue sheets were filed alphabetically or chronologically. Tr. 996, 1025-1026; ASCAP Ex. 21x. ASCAP argued that this meant that the cue sheets were not selected at random. ASCAP Prop. Findings, par. 78.

 ASCAP analysis of WTBS programming showed only 3% of the music in the "other" category (SESAC or public domain music). A reduction of BMI's estimated 5% "other" to 3% "other" would improve ASCAP's percentage share. Reb. Test. of Peter Boyle, p. 13.

 ASCAP asserted that BMI's study excluded a substantial amount of music. Id., pp. 2-8. For the "Tom and Jerry" program on WTBS and WPIX, BMI tallied only cue sheets for "Tom and Jerry" cartoons, but left out other parts of the program such as "Three Stooges" and "Little Rascals" live-action films and cartoons other than "Tom and Jerry". Id., p. 3. Similar exclusions occurred in the calculation of the "Bozo" program on WGN. Id. p. 5.

 ASCAP also claimed that BMI credited to itself much of the music on the cartoons "GI Joe" and "Transformers," which was written by a PRS member, Johnny Douglas, and published by an ASCAP publisher-member, Wildstar Music, Inc. Id., p. 6.

 Further, ASCAP noted that BMI excluded from its calculations those programs for which it did not have the cue sheets, the most significant of which was the "Night Tracks" program on WTBS. Id., p. 7. ASCAP's study of the tapes of "Night Tracks" indicated that ASCAP's share of the "Night Tracks" music was 68% and BMI's share was 32%. Id., p. 8.

 ASCAP calculated that if the omitted and/or mistallied music were corrected, and the share of SESAC or public domain music were reduced to 3%, BMI's study would then yield a result of 58% for ASCAP, 42% for BMI. Tr. 1245.

 ASCAP also argued that BMI made a methodological error when it weighted the percentage of music duration of film and series programs on the five stations by the percentage of time occupied by film and series programs on those stations. Reb. Test. of Peter Boyle, p. 8. Such a method would be correct, ASCAP argued, only if the average music duration per hour were the same for both film and series programs. Otherwise, inaccuracies would occur. Id., pp. 9-10.

 Finally, ASCAP argued that BMI's use of the Nielsen data for ascertaining duration only was inadequate and should have included the amount of viewing, as well, to measure popularity. Id., pp. 10. ASCAP applied the Nielsen average audience per quarter hour to BMI's study. ASCAP Ex. 35R. Adding the adjustments to BMI's weighting methodology, and the Nielsen's viewing audience per quarter hour data to the adjustments ASCAP already made for excluded music, ASCAP derived a new result of ASCAP 65%, BMI 35%. Id., ASCAP Prop. Findings., par. 18.

 BMI's responses to ASCAP's criticisms--BMI's economist, Dr. David Black, testified that choosing the first 13 cue sheets alphabetically or chronologically would be an adequate means to make a random sample. Tr. 1091.

 BMI asserted that while BMI's distribution system has different levels of compensation for different types of music, such distinctions are based on competitive considerations that are not relevant to music users. Tr. 1267.

 BMI obtained from WTBS the cue sheets for the "Night Tracks" programs that actually aired on the Friday, Saturday and Sunday of the Composite Week. BMI Ex. XR-3. Rather than the 68/32 split favoring ASCAP, the cue sheets showed a 42.6% share for BMI a 57.4% share for ASCAP. Tr. 1229 (representation of counsel). ASCAP responded by stating that if BMI's cue sheets calculations are used for "Night Tracks," instead of ASCAP's it would make only a 1% difference in ASCAP's "modifications" to BMI's study. ASCAP Prop. Findings, para. 7, Appendix A.

 BMI asserted that ASCAP's weighting of BMI's study for viewing popularity using the Nielsen data was performed incorrectly. Instead of using total viewing hours, ASCAP used viewing hours per quarter hours. Such an approach, BMI noted, discounted syndicated series programming and favored film programming. BMI argued that this type of weighting was performed not only in ASCAP's modification of BMI's study, but in ASCAP's own WTBS studies, as well. BMI Proposed Findings, pp. 68-69.

 (c)(2) share of radio credits--In 1987, BMI's local radio blanket license rate was 1.39% of gross revenues. ASCAP's rate was 1.56%. This represents a ratio of BMI-47.1%, ASCAP-52.9%. BMI Ex. B-21R. ASCAP testified that its share of performances on WFMT-FM in 1987, which was one of the most heavily carried distant commercial radio stations, was approximately 86%. Tr. 923; Reb. Test. of Peter Boyle, pp. 14-15.

 (d) share of jukebox royalty fees--By voluntary agreement, ASCAP and BMI shared equally in the distribution of the 1978 jukebox royalty fund. 45 FR 63041. The 1978 voluntary agreement was made expressly on a non-prejudicial basis. 45 FR 63043. In all subsequent years, ASCAP, BMI and SESAC have reached voluntary jukebox distribution agreements which by their terms are confidential. Test. of Marvin Berenson, p. 11.

 (e) share of public broadcasting fees--The terms of BMI's voluntary licensing agreement with PBS for 1987 are confidential, so no comparison with PBS' agreement to pay ASCAP $2.66 million could be established. Tr. 878; ASCAP-Public Broadcasting Agreement, dated October 28, 1982. The rates established by the Tribunal for noncommercial radio stations not affiliated with either National Public Radio or any college or university are equal for BMI and ASCAP. BMI Ex. B-5. The Tribunal's determination establishing these rates stated they were not to be used as precedent in any other Tribunal proceeding. 47 FR 57925.

 Share of other related markets--BMI introduced evidence concerning its share of markets that were not considered in the 1978 proceeding. For network television, ABC, NBC and CBS provide for BMI a rate 85% of ASCAP's network revenues. BMI Ex. B-22R. This represents a ratio of 46% for BMI and 54% for ASCAP. Tr. 1371.

 For cable networks, BMI negotiated with Home Box Office (HBO) a rate of 12 cents per subscriber. Id. ASCAP and HBO were unable to reach a voluntary agreement. HBO commenced a proceeding for determining a reasonable fee. BMI Ex. 24R. Currently, HBO is paying ASCAP 15 cents per subscriber for 1987 on an interim basis, subject to retroactive adjustment when a final order is issued. Id., pp. 11-12, 24. This represents a ratio of 44.4% for BMI and 55.6% for ASCAP.

 For 1987, BMI negotiated with Country Music Television (CMT) a rate of 1% of CMT's net revenues. Tr. 1373. Commencing in 1989, CMT will pay ASCAP 0.7% of CMT's gross revenues on an interim basis, subject to adjustment when a final order is issued. BMI Ex. B-24R, p. 24.

 *11992 For 1987, BMI received 55% of the combined ASCAP and BMI license fees paid by Nashville Network. Tr. 1373.

 For domestic films released in 1987, BMI licensed 41.6% and ASCAP licensed 47.7% of the rights to the film scores. ASCAP Ex. 22X. When the "other" category is eliminated, BMI's ratio to ASCAP is BMI, 46.6%, ASCAP, 53.4%. Id.

 Quality--BMI introduced evidence of the numerous awards received by BMI affiliates, including 32 Oscars (1960-1987), 88 Grammy Awards (1959-1987), including 16 Songs of the Year, and 22 Pulitzer Prizes (1947-1987). BMI Ex. B-28R.

 Of the 142 record albums which recieved Gold Certifications from the recording Industry Association of America in 1987, BMI's analysis showed that BMI licensed 43.67% of the rights to 1508 songs on those albums. BMI Ex. XR-6. ASCAP's analysis showed ASCAP licensed 56.9% of the rights to those songs, and on a durational basis, ASCAP-represented music occupied 58.4% of the time on those albums. Reb. Test. of Gloria Messinger, p. 12.

 ASCAP has shown entitlement to 58% of the Music category of the 1987 cable royalty fund. BMI has shown entitlement to 42% of the Music category of the 1987 cable royalty fund.

 In 1978, the claimants to the Music category litigated their differences before the Tribunal, and the Tribunal made an allocation of 54% for ASCAP, 43% for BMI and 3% for SESAC. In terms of ASCAP and BMI only, that meant an allocation of 55.67% for ASCAP and 44.33% for BMI.

 Since the 1978 proceeding, the Music claimants have settled their differences each year so that the 1987 proceeding is the first time the Tribunal has considered the Music category since 1978.

 The task for the Tribunal has been to ascertain as best it can the actual performances of music in the cable distant signal marketplace in 1987. We have considered that all the evidence which the parties presented, whether statistical studies, or proofs concerning analagous markets, were submitted for that purpose. We have not considered it the task of the Tribunal to make a judgment about the relative strengths of ASCAP and BMI in general, and the decision of this agency is not to be taken as such. But we have considered such general evidence to the extent that it shed light on what occurred in the cable distant signal marketplace in 1987.

 BMI argued that the Tribunal, having established the evidentiary criteria for its Music category decision in 1978, should only consider "changed circumstances." ASCAP argued that the Tribunal should consider not only changed circumstances, but, also, better evidence.

 We agree with ASCAP that both better evidence and changed circumstances are to be considered by the Tribunal. This is especially so when it is realized that in the 1978 proceeding the Tribunal was first exploring what kinds of evidence would be appropriate to consider. The Tribunal, when it described the five types of evidence upon which it based the 1978 decision, did not intend to foreclose new approaches to the claimants. On the contrary, we appreciate the claimants' efforts to improve the bases for Tribunal decision-making.

 ASCAP offered four studies, all of which were designed by ASCAP to be more relevant than the study of local television credits ASCAP performed for the 1978 proceeding. We agree that the studies in their design were more relevant, but the accumulation of defects in their execution were such that the Tribunal could not place much reliance on their results.

 First, ASCAP's studies were unverifiable because key elements were confidential. Second, other elements depended on subjective judgments made by ASCAP employees. Third, BMI raised valid objections to the exclusion of "lined-out" music on cue sheets which ASCAP acknowledged would result in a 1.6% difference in its 53-station survey, and also to other BMI musich which was excluded for which ASCAP did not offer a response. Fourth, each study overvalued the impact of WTBS, giving ASCAP an advantage in the results. Three of the four studies were based on WTBS programming, and we considered them less relevant than the 53-station study which did include a broader consideration of the distant signal market. But even in the 53-station study, no compensation was included for the 500-plus stations that were not studied. Fifth, ASCAP's use of Nielsen viewing per quarter hour rather than overall Nielsen viewing was criticized by BMI for undervaluing syndicated series, and ASCAP did not show why that was a valid method.

 While each one of these flaws might not by itself have lessened the Tribunal's confidence in ASCAP's sproffered results, the sum of these flaws has. The Tribunal cannot conclude with confidence whether these studies resulted in 67% for ASCAP or some other less favorable percentage. We note that ASCAP's study of "Night Tracks," gave ASCAP a 68% advantage, but that BMI's study of the cue sheets of "Night Tracks" from the Composite Week gave ASCAP only a 57.4% share. If such disparites are typical, based on the preponderance of the evidence, we tend to have more confidence in BMI's results than in ASCAP's. The extent to which we do give ASCAP's studies weight is that it can be concluded that more ASCAP music was played than BMI music, and that WTBS' preponderance of film programming did weigh to ASCAP's advantage. More will be said about the contributions of ASCAP's studies to the Tribunal final decision below.

 Looking at BMI's study, its design appears to be appropriate for what it intended to prove, but it also had flaws. We especially agree with ASCAP that the flaws concerning excluded music, such as music on the "Tom and Jerry Show," "Bozo" and "Night Tracks", and an overestimate of "other" music, were serious, and we accept ASCAP's corrections. Using ASCAP's modifications (except for "Night Tracks" where we have accepted BMI's calculation of the cue sheets from the Composite Week), the result of BMI's study is 57% ASCAP, 43% BMI.

 We did not consider BMI's use of the first 13 cue sheets, either alphabetically or chronologically, to be a flaw in the study. Dr. Black's testimony that that would be a reasonable method was accepted. We also did not accept ASCAP's other criticisms of BMI's study using the Nielsen data. Again, as stated earlier, ASCAP did not show how using viewing data per quarter hour, rather than total viewing data, was appropriate.

 Concerning whether BMI's use of duration only or ASCAP's weighting of the music according to its own internal valuation of feature, background and theme music, was a better measure of marketplace value, on conclusion was reached. Dr. Boyle's testimony for ASCAP indicated that, according to ASCAP's studies, no appreciable changes between the two parties relative standing occurs regardless of the mix of types of music. Assuming that to be the case, the Tribunal did not need to reach a conclusion. We are concerned however that both methods, duration only or internal valuations, might, for different reasons, fail to approximate marketplace value and we would be interested in further exploring the issue should future controversies occur.

 Summing up our conclusions concerning the studies of the actual performances of music in the cable distant signal marketplace, we have credited BMI's study at 57% ASCAP, 43% BMI, and we have accepted ASCAP's studies not for any particular percentages, but for the conclusion that *11993 ASCAP's music is in the majority and that WTBS' programming favors ASCAP.

 Turning now to a consideration of analogous marketplaces, ASCAP offered no proof concerning other markets, believing that they lacked any relevance. BMI, on the other hand, offered much evidence and urged the Tribunal to note the growing trend toward "convergence" between the two performing rights societies.

 It is a truism that other marketplaces are not the marketplace under consideration in this proceeding, but we disagree with ASCAP that they lack any relevance. There is no distant signal marketplace because it has been replaced by the compulsory license. A look at other marketplaces might help the Tribunal approximate the "shadow" market of cable retransmissions.

 In the 1978 proceeding, the Tribunal considered total license revenues, total local television revenues, and percentages indicating share of radio, jukebox and public broadcasting revenues.

 In 1987, total revenues were ASCAP 59.5%, BMI 40.5%. Total local television revenues were ASCAP 58.8%, BMI 41.2% (using BMI's 70% parity achieved in the latest agreement). In radio, the ratio was ASCAP 52.9%, BMI 47.1%. For jukebox and public broadcasting, no statistics were available to provide a reliable basis for the Tribunal to consider, prior agreements having been reached on the condition that they would not have precedential affect on other proceedings.

 Added to these considerations were ratios submitted for network television, ASCAP 54% BMI 46%, Home Box Office, ASCAP 55.6%, BMI 44.4% (subject to change when a final rate decision is rendered), licensing of new U.S. films in 1987, ASCAP 53.4% BMI 46.6% licensing of Gold Certification song hits of 1987--ASCAP 56+%, BMI 43+% (ASCAP's and BMI's studies differed slightly).

 BMI also submitted ratios for the licensing of Country Music Television but they were not comparable because BMI's rate was based on net revenues and ASCAP's rate was based on gross revenues. The ratio for the Nashville Network was not considered relevant because BMI did not show that country music was significant on cable distant signals. Evidence concerning all music, not just a subcategory of music, such as the overall radio licensing and the Gold Certification song hits, was considered more relevant.

 The Tribunal gave the most weight in this decision to BMI's study, as adjusted (57/43 ratio), local television revenues (58.8/41.2 ratio) and total license revenues (59.5/40.5 ratio). Accordingly, we concluded that a 58/42 percentage split had been established between ASCAP and BMI. Given secondary weight were the proofs establishing the ratios for radio, network television, HBO, new U.S. films in 1987, and hit songs of 1987. They tended to support BMI's contention that a convergence between the performing rights societies had been taking place from 1978 to 1987. However, in counterweight to that perception was ASCAP's evidence showing the importance of WTBS' position in the distant signal marketplace and WTBS' use of older films which contain a predominance of ASCAP music. WTBS' dominance in cable retransmissions has grown since 1978 to the point where it accounts for over a third of all fees generated. Therefore, despite whatever trends to the contrary that may have occurred in other markets, the Tribunal concludes that an upward adjustment for ASCAP from 55.67% to 58% is justified.

 We also observe that, in the 1978 proceeding, the Tribunal accepted BMI's argument that its 1972 agreement of 58% parity (36%/64%) with ASCAP was six years out-of-date and convergence was taking place. The Tribunal accepted this contention, although it did not determine the rate or extent to which such convergence was occurring. Now that the Tribunal has additional evidence, including the 1985 agreement in which BMI achieved a 70% parity (41.2%/58.8%), the Tribunal's judgment of a 44.33% share for BMI in 1978 may have included a greater acceptance of BMI's argument than has turned out, with more facts in evidence, to have been warranted. We have accepted the figure of 70% parity for BMI rather than 68%, as was urged by ASCAP, because, without knowing what negotiating points were obtained or conceded, the fact remains that BMI will get 70% of ASCAP's revenues when the final payments for 1987 are made.

 In addition, to the limited extent that the Tribunal considered jukebox and public broadcasting fees in 1978, they did not enter into our consideration in this determination, and the dropping of such consideration also provides counterweight to the trend toward convergence argued for by BMI. Concerning quality, no differences between the performing rights societies could be perceived.

 Accordingly, the Tribunal has determined that ASCAP has shown entitlement to 58% and BMI has shown entitlement to 42% of the Music category.

 Allocations

  Pursuant to the Phase I settlement, the Tribunal has adopted the following allocation to categories of claimants in Phase I of the 1987 cable copyright royalty fees available for distribution:

 After subtracting the stipulated award to Noncommercial Radio of 0.18% of the entire fund,

 
---------------------------------------------------------------
            Category Basic 3.75 Syndex
---------------------------------------------------------------
Program Suppliers .................. 67.10 72.00 95.50
Sports ............................. 16.35 17.50 0
Noncommercial Television ............ 5.20 0 0
Commercial Television ............... 5.00 5.00 0
Music ............................... 4.50 4.50 4.50
Devotional Claimants ................ 1.10 0.75 0
Canadian Claimants .................. 0.75 0.25 0
Commercial Radio ....................... 0 0 0
---------------------------------------------------------------
 

 The allocations adopted by the Tribunal under Phase II for the individual claimants are as follows:

 Devotional Claimants

  Settling Devotional Claimants, 99.2% of Basic and 100% of 3.75%

 Christian Television Corp., 0.8% of Basic and 0% of 3.75%

 Music

  
                                                                      Percent
American Society of Composers, Authors and Publishers (ASCAP) .............. 58
Broadcast Music, Inc. (BMI) ................................................ 42
 

 Dated: March 27, 1990.

 J.C. Argetsinger,

 Chairman.

 [FR Doc. 90-7358 Filed 3-29-90; 8:45 am]


Please refer to the IP Mall Copyright Royalty Tribunal homepage for details on this valuable resource.