NOTICES
COPYRIGHT ROYALTY TRIBUNAL
(Docket No. 92-3-DART)
Digital Audio Recording Technology Act; Implementation
Monday, November 22, 1993
*61681 AGENCY: Copyright Royalty Tribunal.
ACTION: Notice.
SUMMARY: On November 3, 1993, The American Society of Composers, Authors and Publishers, Broadcast Music, Inc., and SESAC, Inc., ("Performing Rights Organizations"), filed a petition to reopen for reconsideration the rulemaking proceeding which resulted in the Notice Adopting Final Regulations to implement the Audio Home Recording Act of 1992 (AHRA), issued by the Copyright Royalty Tribunal ("Tribunal") on October 18, 1993. 58 FR 53822. The Tribunal invites comments from the interested parties.
DATES: Comments are due by December 1, 1993.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:
Cindy Daub, Chairman, Copyright Royalty Tribunal, 1825 Connecticut Avenue NW., suite 918, Washington, DC 20009. (1993).
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: The Audio Home Recording Act of 1992 (AHRA), 17 U.S.C. 1001-1010 (Supp. IV 1992), became effective on October 28, 1992.
AHRA authorizes the Tribunal to prescribe the "form and manner" for filing claims. Id. The Tribunal, in an Advance Notice of Rule Making, invited comments concerning the filing of claims to royalties. 57 FR 54542 (1992). Thereafter, on January 29, 1993, the Tribunal, issued Interim Regulations, with a request for public comment. 58 FR 6441 (1993). The Interim Regulations also directed the parties to file a report, on or before June 1, 1993, commenting on the issue of whether performing rights societies need separate, specific, and written authorization to represent members and affiliates. 58 FR 6441, 6444 (1992). Having considered all the facts and comments before the Tribunal, final regulations were published October 18, 1993. 58 FR 53822.
In filing the petition to reopen for reconsideration of the final regulations on November 3, 1993, the Performing Rights Organizations objected to the provision in the Tribunal's final regulations requiring the performing rights societies to obtain separate, specific, and written authorizations, signed by their respective members and affiliates or their representatives in order to file claims on behalf of those members and affiliates under the Act. 58 FR at 53826; 37 CFR 311.2.
The Performing Rights Organizations contend that:
I. The Tribunal's final regulations as promulgated will disenfranchise many writers and publishers who are otherwise qualified to receive royalties under the Act; that due to the Tribunal October 18, 1993 publishing date of its regulation, and the filing of claims to 1993 royalties by February 28, 1994, the Tribunal's determination has left the performing rights organizations with little time to obtain the required authorizations for claims to 1993 royalties should the final regulation stand as adopted; and that the rights of claimants who want to file on their own behalf, or have others file for them, will not be impaired by adoption of a permanent rebuttable inference of an agency relationship between the performing rights societies and their respective members and affiliates. Moreover, because the Tribunal has adopted their proposal that lists of all individuals represented by joint claimants must be made available upon request to the other parties and the Tribunal, there can be no possibility of confusion about which organization is representing a particular writer or publisher in a given proceeding.
II. The Tribunal erred in concluding that the holding in National Broadcasting Company, Inc. v. Copyright Royalty Tribunal, 848 F.2d 1289 (D.C. Cir. 1988), precludes adoption of the rebuttable inference of agency for performing rights organization. They argue that the court in NBC v. CRT, held that the Tribunal's decision to award royalties to Worldvision, the syndicator, instead of NBC, the program owner, did not constitute a final adjudication of the rights of the parties under the syndication agreement. Similarly, they are not seeking a final judgment or interpretation of their membership and affiliation agreements. They are merely seeking a rebuttable inference for valid procedural, administrative and policy reasons. The rule that they are seeking will not be a binding judgment on any party in a DART distribution proceeding.
III. Even if the Tribunal rejects the concept of a permanent rebuttable inference, that the Tribunal's final ruling adopting a requirement that performing rights societies must obtain separate, specific and written authorizations signed by their respective members and affiliates should not be applied to the 1993 distribution proceeding because of the short turn around time before 1993 royalty claims have to be filed.
They further contend that the prejudice that will otherwise result to their members and affiliates is compounded by the fact that they have entered into a settlement with all joint claimant groups and all but one of the individual claimants (James Cannings) to the Musical Works Fund that links the distribution of 1992 DART royalties, for which they have the rebuttable inference of agency, to the outcome of the 1993 proceeding, for which they would not have the rebuttable inference if the Tribunal's final regulations stand.
Dated: November 16, 1993.
Cindy Daub,
Chairman.
(FR Doc. 93-28557 Filed 11-19-93; 8:45 am)
Please refer to the IP Mall Copyright Royalty Tribunal homepage for details on this valuable resource.