NOTICES
COPYRIGHT ROYALTY TRIBUNAL
(CRT Docket No. 93-1-92DRD)
1992 Audio Home Recording Act Distribution Proceeding
Wednesday, November 17, 1993
*60610 AGENCY: Copyright Royalty Tribunal.
ACTION: Notice.
SUMMARY: On November 4, 1993, the American Society of Composers, Authors and Publishers, Broadcast Music Inc., Copyright Management, Inc., Gospel Music Coalition, The Harry Fox Agency, Inc., SESAC, Inc. and The Songwriters Guild of America ("Parties") filed a joint motion to consolidate the 1992 and 1993 Dart Distribution Proceedings in the Musical Works Fund. The Tribunal invites comments from interested parties.
DATES: Comments are due by November 23, 1993. Reply comments will not be accepted.
ADDRESSES: An original and five copies of the comments shall be addressed to Chairman, Copyright Royalty Tribunal, 1825 Connecticut Avenue, NW., suite 918, Washington, DC 20009.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:
Cindy Daub, Chairman, Copyright Royalty Tribunal, 1825 Connecticut Avenue, NW., suite 918, Washington, DC 20009, (202) 606-4400.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: On June 30, the parties in Joint Comments advised the Tribunal that they had reached agreement among themselves and with certain individual claimants within the Musical Works Fund who had filed claims in the Writers Subfund, the Publishers Fund, or both Subfunds for 1992. By that agreement, the parties advised the Tribunal that claims to 1992 Musical Works Fund royalties were "rolled over" into the 1993 Distribution Proceedings and claims of settling parties to shares of the respective Subfunds of the 1992 Musical Works Fund are to be settled based on the shares each receives of the respective 1993 Subfunds. In Supplementary Comments dated September 8, 1993, the parties advised the Tribunal that they had reached agreement with other individual claimants who filed claims within the Musical Work Fund and that no controversy existed as among these additional individual claimants. Further, Mr. James Cannings was the only claimant in the Musical Work Fund to file a Notice of Intent to Participate in the 1992 DART Distribution Proceedings and had not agreed to "roll over" his 1992 claims into the 1993 Distribution Proceeding.
The parties express that because of, the unique circumstances presented and in the interest of justice and efficient administration they request the Tribunal to consolidate the 1992 and 1993 DART Distribution Proceedings in the Musical Works Fund. The parties note the following several reasons why consolidation is the fairest and most prudent course:
1. The size of the 1992 DART royalty fund does not justify a proceeding, for the costs of a proceeding will leave nothing to distribute;
2. The first DART Distribution Proceeding will have precedential effect, and should not be held in these circumstances; precisely, that if the Tribunal were to conduct a special Distribution Proceeding at this time to determine Mr. Canning's 1992 entitlement, those claimants not appearing will be denied the opportunity to be heard on the important matters of the procedure and substance of Music Works Fund *60611 Distribution Proceedings. The parties further note that significant prejudice would be avoided if the Tribunal were to consolidate the 1992 and 1993 DART Distribution Proceedings.
3. Because of the pendency of H.R. 2840 and S. 1346, bills introduced to abolish by the Tribunal, to conduct a 1992 DART Distribution Proceeding at this time may truncate the proceeding and needlessly expend effort and resources. Additionally, the parties note that in view of this legislation, the Tribunal has already suspended conduct of the 1990 Cable Royalty Distribution Proceeding. Also, the Tribunal's procedural schedule calls for submission of written direct cases by December 1, 1993, and commencement of hearings on January 10, 1994. If parties acted on this schedule, and the legislation is enacted, the parties would have gone to the expense of preparing direct cases for nought.
4. Consolidation would improve the quality of any evidence to be adduced and enhance the prospects for settlement; and finally,
5. Consolidation of the 1992 and 1993 DART Distribution Proceedings will not prejudice Mr. Cannings since the parties do not seek to impose on Mr. Cannings the settlement for 1992 that all other parties in the Musical Works Fund have found acceptable. Mr. Cannings would have a full and fair opportunity to present his evidence of entitlement during one consolidated Distribution Proceeding. The parties assert that the only conceivable detriment Mr. Cannings may suffer from consolidation of the two proceedings is that he will have to wait slightly longer to receive the 1992 award.
Cindy Daub,
Chairman.
(FR Doc. 93-28422 Filed 11-16-93; 8:45 am)
Please refer to the IP Mall Copyright Royalty Tribunal homepage for details on this valuable resource.