Monday, December 18, 1995
ISSN: 0511-4187; Volume v31; Issue n50
Message to the Congress on the Federal
Republic of Yugoslavia (Serbia and
Montenegro). (Pres. Bill Clinton's foreign
policy)(Transcript)
Total number of pages for this article: 6 FULL TEXT
December 8, 1995
To the Congress of the
United States:
On May 30, 1992, in
Executive Order No. 12808, the President declared
a national emergency to deal with the threat to the national
security,
foreign policy, and economy of the United States arising from
actions
and policies of the Governments of Serbia and Montenegro, acting
under
the name of the Socialist Federal Republic of Yugoslavia or the
Federal
Republic of Yugoslavia, in their involvement in and support for
groups
attempting to seize territory in Croatia and the Republic of
Bosnia and
Herzegovina by force and violence utilizing, in part, the forces
of the
so-called Yugoslav National Army (57 FR 23299, June 2, 1992). I
expanded
the national emergency in Executive Order No. 12934 of October 25,
1994,
to address the actions and policies of the Bosnian Serb forces and
the
authorities in the territory of the Republic of Bosnia and
Herzegovina
that they control.
The present report is
submitted pursuant to 50 U.S.C. 1641(c) and
1703(c) and covers the period from May 30, 1995, to November 29,
1995.
It discusses Administration actions and expenses directly related
to the
exercise of powers and authorities conferred by the declaration of
a
national emergency in Executive Order No. 12808 and Executive
Order No.
12934 and to expanded sanctions against the Federal Republic of
Yugoslavia (Serbia and Montenegro) (the "FRY (S&M)")
and the Bosnian
Serbs contained in Executive Order No. 12810 of June 5, 1992 (57
FR
24347, June 9, 1992), Executive Order No. 12831 of January 15,
1993 (58
FR 5253, January 21, 1993), Executive Order No. 12846 of April 25,
1993
(58 FR 25771, April 27, 1993), and Executive Order No. 12934 of
October
25, 1994 (59 FR 54117, October 27, 1994).
1. Executive Order No.
12808 blocked all property and interests in
property of the Governments of Serbia and Montenegro, or held in
the
name of the former Government of the Socialist Federal Republic of
Yugoslavia or the Government of the Federal Republic of
Yugoslavia, then
or thereafter located in the United States or within the
possession or
control of United States persons, including their overseas
branches.
Subsequently, Executive
Order No. 12810 expanded U.S. actions to
implement in the United States the United Nations sanctions
against the
FRY (S&M) adopted in United Nations Security Council (UNSC)
Resolution
757 of May 30, 1992. In addition to reaffirming the blocking of
FRY
(S&M) Government property, this order prohibited transactions
with
respect to the FRY (S&M) involving imports, exports, dealing
in FRY
(S&M)-origin property, air and sea transportation, contract
performance,
funds transfers, activity promoting importation or exportation or
dealings in property, and official sports, scientific, technical,
or
other cultural representation of, or sponsorship by, the FRY
(S&M) in
the United States.
Executive Order No. 12810
exempted from trade restrictions (1)
transshipments through the FRY (S&M), and (2) activities
related to the
United Nations Protection Force (UNPROFOR), the Conference on
Yugoslavia, or the European Community Monitor Mission.
On January 15, 1993, President
Bush issued Executive Order No. 12831
to implement new sanctions contained in UNSC Resolution 787 of
November
16, 1992. The order revoked the exemption for transshipments
through the
FRY (S&M) contained in Executive Order No. 12810, prohibited
transactions within the United States or by a United States person
relating to FRY (S&M) vessels and vessels in which a majority
or
controlling interest is held by a person or entity in, or operating
from, the FRY (S&M), and stated that all such vessels shall be
considered as vessels of the FRY (S&M), regardless of the flag
under
which they sail.
On April 25, 1993, I
issued Executive Order No. 12846 to implement in
the United States the sanctions adopted in UNSC Resolution 820 of
April
17, 1993. That resolution called on the Bosnian Serbs to accept
the
Vance-Owen peace plan for the Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina
and, if
they failed to do so by April 26, 1993, called on member states to
take
additional measures to tighten the embargo against the FRY
(S&M) and
Serbian-controlled areas of the Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina
and
the United Nations Protected Areas in Croatia. Effective April 26,
1993,
the order blocked all property and interests in property of
commercial,
industrial, or public utility undertakings or entities organized
or
located in the FRY (S&M), including property and interests in
property
of entities (wherever organized or located) owned or controlled by
such
undertakings or entities, that are or thereafter come within the
possession or control of United States persons.
On October 25, 1994, in
view of UNSC Resolution 942 of September 23,
1994, I issued Executive Order No. 12934 in order to take
additional
steps with respect to the crisis in the former Yugoslavia (59 FR
54117,
October 27, 1994). Executive Order No. 12934 expands the scope of
the
national emergency declared in Executive Order No. 12808 to
address the
unusual and extraordinary threat to the national security, foreign
policy, and economy of the United States posed by the actions and
policies of the Bosnian Serb forces and the authorities in the
territory
in the Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina that they control,
including
their refusal to accept the proposed territorial settlement of the
conflict in the Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina.
The Executive order
blocks all property and interests in property that
are in the United States, that hereafter come within the United
States,
or that are or hereafter come within the possession or control of
United
States persons (including their overseas branches) of: (1) the
Bosnian
Serb military and paramilitary forces and the authorities in areas
of
the Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina under the control of those
forces; (2) any entity, including any commercial, industrial, or
public
utility undertaking, organized or located in those areas of the
Republic
of Bosnia and Herzegovina under the control of Bosnian Serb
forces; (3)
any entity, wherever organized or located, which is owned or
controlled
directly or indirectly by any person in, or resident in, those
areas of
the Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina under the control of
Bosnian Serb
forces; and (4) any person acting for or on behalf of any person
within
the scope of the above definitions.
The Executive order also
prohibits the provision or exportation of
services to those areas of the Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina
under
the control of Bosnian Serb forces, or to any person for the
purpose of
any business carried on in those areas, either from the United
States or
by a United States person. The order also prohibits the entry of
any
U.S.-flagged vessel, other than a U.S. naval vessel, into the
riverine
ports of those areas of the Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina
under the
control of Bosnian Serb forces. Finally, any transaction by any
United
States person that evades or avoids, or has the purpose of evading
or
avoiding, or attempts to violate any of the prohibitions set forth
in
the order is prohibited. Executive order No. 12934 became
effective at
11:59 p.m., e.d.t., on October 25, 1994.
2. The declaration of the
national emergency on May 30, 1992, was made
pursuant to the authority vested in the President by the
Constitution
and laws of the United States, including the International
Emergency
Economic Powers Act (50 U.S.C. 1701 et seq.), the National
Emergencies
Act (50 U.S.C. 1601 et seq.), and section 301 of title 3 of the
United
States Code. The emergency declaration was reported to the
Congress on
May 30, 1992, pursuant to section 204(b) of the International
Emergency
Economic Powers Act (50 U.S.C. 1703(b)) and the expansion of that
national emergency under the same authorities was reported to the
Congress on October 25, 1994. The additional sanctions set forth
in
related Executive orders were imposed pursuant to the authority
vested
in the President by the Constitution and laws of the United
States,
including the statutes cited above, section 1114 of the Federal
Aviation
Act (49 U.S.C. App. 1514), and section 5 of the United Nations
Participation Act (22 U.S.C. 287c).
3. Effective June 30,
1995, the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia (Serbia
and Montenegro) Sanctions Regulations, 31 C.F.R. Part 585 (the
"Regulations"), were amended to implement Executive
Order No. 12934 (60
FR 34144, June 30, 1995). The name of the Regulations was changed
to
reflect the expansion of the national emergency to the Bosnian
Serbs,
and now reads "Federal Republic of Yugoslavia (Serbia &
Montenegro) and
Bosnian Serb-Controlled Areas of the Republic of Bosnia and
Herzegovina
Sanctions Regulations." A copy of the amended Regulations is
attached.
Treasury's blocking
authority as applied to FRY (S&M) subsidiaries and
vessels in the United States has been challenged in court. In
Milena
Ship Management Company, Ltd. v. Newcomb, 804 F. Supp. 846, 855,
and 859
(E.D.L.A. 1992) aff'd, 995 F. 2d 620 (5th Cir. 1993), cert.
denied, 114
S. Ct. 877 (1994), involving five ships owned or controlled by FRY
(S&M)
entities blocked in various U.S. ports, the blocking authority as
applied to these vessels was upheld. In IPT Company, Inc. v.
United
States Department of the Treasury, No. 92 CIV 5542 (S.D.N.Y.
1994), the
district court also upheld the blocking authority as applied to
the
property of a Yugoslav subsidiary located in the United States,
and the
case was subsequently settled.
4. Over the past 6
months, the Departments of State and Treasury have
worked closely with European Union (the "EU") member
states and other
U.N. member nations to coordinate implementation of the U.N.
sanctions
against the FRY (S&M). This has included continued deployment
of
Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE)
sanctions
assistance missions (SAMs) to Albania, Bulgaria, Croatia, the
Former
Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia, Hungary, Romania, and Ukraine to
assist
in monitoring land and Danube River traffic; support for the
International Conference on the Former Yugoslavia (ICFY)
monitoring
missions along the Serbia-Montenegro-Bosnia border; bilateral
contacts
between the United States and other countries for the purpose of
tightening financial and trade restrictions on the FRY (S&M);
and
ongoing multilateral meetings by financial sanctions enforcement
authorities from various countries to coordinate enforcement
efforts and
to exchange technical information.
5. In accordance with licensing policy and
the Regulations, the Office
of Foreign Assets Control (FAC) has exercised its authority to
license
certain specific transactions with respect to the FRY (S&M),
which are
consistent with U.S. foreign policy and the Security Council
sanctions.
During the reporting period, FAC has issued 90 specific licenses
regarding transactions pertaining to the FRY (S&M) or assets
it owns or
controls, bringing the total specific licenses issued as of
October 13,
1995, to 1,020. Specific licenses have been issued: (1) for
payment to
U.S. or third country secured creditors, under certain narrowly
defined
circumstances, for preembargo import and export transactions; (2)
for
legal representation or advice to the Government of the FRY
(S&M) or FRY
(S&M)-located or controlled entities; (3) for the liquidation
or
protection of tangible assets of subsidiaries of FRY
(S&M)-located or
controlled firms located in the United States; (4) for limited
transactions related to FRY (S&M) diplomatic representation in
Washington and New York; (5) for patent, trademark, and copyright
protection in the FRY (S&M) not involving payment to the FRY
(S&M)
Government; (6) for certain communications, news media, and
travel-related transactions; (7) for the payment of crews' wages,
vessel
maintenance, and emergency supplies for FRY (S&M)-controlled
ships
blocked in the United States; (8) for the removal from the FRY
(S&M), or
protection within the FRY (S&M), of certain property owned and
controlled by U.S. entities; (9) to assist the United Nations in
its
relief operations and the activities of the UNPROFOR; and (10) for
payment from funds outside the United States where a third country
has
licensed the transaction in accordance with U.N. sanctions.
Pursuant to
U.S. regulations implementing UNSC Resolutions, specific licenses
have
also been issued to authorize exportation of food, medicine, and
supplies intended for humanitarian purposes in the FRY (S&M).
During the period, FAC
addressed the status of the unallocated debt of
the former Yugoslavia by authorizing nonblocked U.S. creditors
under the
New Financing Agreement for Yugoslavia (Blocked Debt) to exchange
a
portion of the Blocked Debt for new debt (bonds) issued by the
Republic
of Slovenia. The completion of this exchange will mark the
transfer to
Slovenia of sole liability for a portion of the face value of the
$4.2
billion unallocated debt of the FRY (S&M) for which Slovenia,
prior to
the authorized exchange, was jointly and severally liable. The
exchange
will relieve Slovenia of the joint and several liability for the
remaining unallocated FRY (S&M) debt and pave the way for its
entry into
international capital markets.
During the past 6 months, FAC has continued
to oversee the liquidation
of tangible assets of the 15 U.S. subsidiaries of entities
organized in
the FRY (S&M). Subsequent to the issuance of Executive Order
No. 12846,
all operating licenses issued for these U.S.-located Serbian or
Montenegrin subsidiaries or joint ventures were revoked, and the
net
proceeds of the liquidation of their assets placed in blocked
accounts.
In order to reduce the
drain on blocked assets caused by continuing to
rent commercial space, FAC arranged to have the blocked
personalty,
files, and records of the two Serbian banking institutions in New
York
moved to secure storage. The personalty is being liquidated, with
the
net proceeds placed in blocked accounts.
Following the sale of the M/V Kapetan Martinovic in January 1995,
five
Yugoslav-owned vessels remain blocked in the United States.
Approval of
the UNSC's Serbian Sanctions Committee was sought and obtained for
the
sale of the M/V Kapetan Martinovic (and the M/V Bor, which was
sold in
June 1994).
With the FAC-licensed
sales of the M/V Kapetan Martinovic and the M/V
Bor, those vessels were removed from the list of blocked FRY
(S&M)
entities and merchant vessels maintained by FAC. As of October 12,
1995,
five additional vessels have been removed from the list of blocked
FRY
(S&M) entities and merchant vessels maintained by FAC as a
result of
sales conditions that effectively extinguished any FRY (S&M)
interest:
the M/V Blue Star, M/V Budva, M/V Bulk Star, M/V Hanuman, and M/V
Sumadija. The new owners of several other formerly Yugoslav-owned
vessels, which have been sold in other countries, have petitioned
FAC to
remove those vessels from the list.
During the past 6 months,
U.S. financial institutions have continued
to block funds transfers in which there is a possible interest of
the
Government of the FRY (S&M) or an entity or undertaking
located in or
controlled from the FRY (S&M), and to stop prohibited
transfers to
persons in the FRY (S&M). The value of transfers blocked has
amounted to
$137.5 million since the issuance of Executive Order No. 12808,
including some $13.9 million during the past 6 months.
To ensure compliance with
the terms of the licenses that have been
issued under the program, stringent reporting requirements are
imposed.
More than 318 submissions have been reviewed by FAC since the last
report, and more than 130 compliance cases are currently open.
6. Since the issuance of
Executive Order No. 12810, FAC has worked
closely with the U.S. Customs Service to ensure both that
prohibited
imports and exports (including those in which the Government of
the FRY
(S&M) or Bosnian Serb authorities have an interest) are
identified and
interdicted, and that permitted imports and exports move to their
intended destination without undue delay. Violations and suspected
violations of the embargo are being investigated and appropriate
enforcement actions are being taken. Numerous investigations
carried
over from the prior reporting period are continuing. Since the
last
report, FAC has collected 10 civil penalties totaling more than
$27,000.
Of these, five were paid by U.S. financial institutions for
violative
funds transfers involving the. Government of the FRY (S&M),
persons in
the FRY (S&M), or entities located or organized in or
controlled from
the FRY (S&M). One U.S. company and one air carrier have also
paid
penalties related to unlicensed payments to the Government of the
FRY
(S&M) or other violations of the Regulations. Two companies
and one law
firm have also remitted penalties for their failure to follow the
conditions of FAC licenses.
7. The expenses incurred
by the Federal Government in the 6-month
period from May 30, 1995, through November 29, 1995, that are
directly
attributable to the declaration of a national emergency with
respect to
the FRY (S&M) and the Bosnian Serb forces and authorities are
estimated
at about $3.5 million, most of which represent wage and salary
costs for
Federal personnel. Personnel costs were largely centered in the
Department of the Treasury (particularly in FAC and its Chief
Counsel's
Office, and the U.S. Customs Service), the Department of State,
the
National Security Council, the U.S. Coast Guard, and the
Department of
Commerce.
8. The actions and
policies of the Government of the FRY (S&M), in its
involvement in and support for groups attempting to seize and hold
territory in the Republics of Croatia and Bosnia and Herzegovina
by
force and violence, and the actions and policies of the Bosnian
Serb
forces and the authorities in the areas of Bosnia and Herzegovina
under
their control, continue to pose an unusual and extraordinary
threat to
the national security, foreign policy, and economy of the United
States.
The United States remains committed to a multilateral resolution
of the
conflict through implementation of the United Nations Security
Council
resolutions.
I shall continue to exercise the powers at
my disposal to apply
economic sanctions against the FRY (S&M) and the Bosnian Serb
forces,
civil authorities, and entities, as long as these measures are
appropriate, and will continue to report periodically to the
Congress on
significant developments pursuant to 50 U.S.C. 1703(c).
William J. Clinton
The White House, December
8, 1995.
NOTE: This item was not
received in time for publication in the
appropriate issue.