Monday, October 5, 1998
Vol. 34, No. 40
Remarks at a Democratic National Committee
dinner in San Jose, California
William J Clinton
September 25, 1998
Thank you. Thank you,
John. I sort of hate to speak after that.
[Laughter] He made a better case than I could have made for
myself.
I thank you. And I want to thank Mayor Susan Hammer for her
friendship and her leadership of this great city.
I'm delighted to be back here again, or in the new Tech, and I do
hope that because of this event tonight you'll receive even wider
publicity, and you'll have throngs of children coming here,
learning
all the things that they need to see about their own future.
[Applause] Thank you very much.
I want to thank all of
you for being here tonight. Some of you
are probably in danger of overexposure.There are several people
here who were with Hillary last night in Seattle. [Laughter] And
you've already heard the better of the two speeches, I can tell
you
that. [Laughter]
We've been working-I was
in Chicago today, and she was in Portland
and Seattle last night, and we're going to, as you know, spend the
night with our daughter tonight. And then I'm going on to San
Diego
tomorrow and then to Texas and then back to Washington. But I
can't
thank you enough, all of you, for the kind things that you said,
as I
was going around before the dinner, about my family and what we're
dealing with. And I just want to thank you on a very personal
basis.
Even Presidents have to be people from time to time, and you made
me
feel like one tonight, and I thank you very much.
I also want to thank you
for giving me a way to work with this
community. When I came out here with Al Gore and we were working
in
1992, I felt that it was imperative that we establish a strong
relationship with the people and the companies of this area for
what
we could do together to rebuild the American economy, and then to
build an American future that is worthy of our people. And you
mentioned a few of those issues, but it's just the last list of
issues. We've worked on a lot of things over the last 6 years,
things that I never would have known very much about, and that
most
Presidents probably wouldn't, had it not been for your input and
your
consistent involvement, and even, sometimes, your stimulating
argument. And I thank you for that.
I don't know that that
was the greatest endorsement my Vice
President could ever get, what John said. [Laughter] But it's not
all
bad. I do want to say something about him. I thank you for working
with him. As you all know, one of the reasons I asked him to
become
my Vice Presidential partner is that he had a background in
technology issues far superior to mine and a consuming interest in
it. And all of you have fed it and broadened it, and I'm very
grateful to you.
I think that when the
historians write about this administration,
they may differ on whether our economic or social policies were
right
or wrong, but one thing is absolutely beyond question, and that is
that the Vice President has had more influence on more important
issues in more areas than any person in the history of this
country
that ever held that job. And he's made it possible for us to do a
lot of the things that we've done, and I'm very grateful to him.
Now, if I could just run
over-you mentioned a couple of things.
We have worked out the so-called H-lB visa issue. It vill be
coming
to my desk soon. And it was done in a way that's really good for
everybody in America, because in addition to permitting more sisas
of
high-skilled people to come into our country and strengthen us, it
also provides a lot more funds to train our own people, to upgrade
their skills. So it's a good, good bill. It has the best of both
worlds.
The securities reform
legislation is now in conference and they're
arguing only over some legislative intent language that those of
you
who are working the issue are very familiar with. But I think
we'll
be successful there. I think we've reached a broad agreement on
encryption policy and now you just have to make sure you work with
us
on the implementation of it so that the rules don't contradict the
policy, but instead reinforce them. And I think we can do that.
There's legislation to
implement the world intellectual property
agreements to which we are a part, and there's some problems
there,
but I think that on balance it does a lot of good. And I hope
you'll
help us get it right and get it through. The bill which keeps the
Internet from being interrupted for a period of time by various
kinds
of local taxes is making its way through the Senate, and there are
some extraneous issues that are having an impact on it, but those
of
you who are working it understand that, and I remain committed to
it.
And I think we can be successful there. And I think it's very,
very
important.
One other thing I'd like
to just say to you is a lot of you are
very concerned, as you should be for your own markets, with the
situation in Asia. And I am -working very, very hard to help those
countries regroup, to restore growth, and to limit the reach of
the
contagion. I believe we're doing about all we can do at this time,
but we need some support, and I'll say more about that in a
minute.
Now, I mention these
issues partly to make a specific point to
Silicon Valley, but partly to make a more general point. Today I
was
at Moffett Air Force Base, and we had an open arrival. And
typically, when we do this, a couple hundred people will show up
that
are associated some way or another with the base facility. There
were about 600 people there today, and they were all different
kinds
of people talking about very specific things about their lives,
things that had changed-- the schools their kids were in, the
family
and medical leave law, or other things that we had all been
involved
in together.
I entered public life
because I thought it would give me an
opportunity to work vith people to help them make the most of
their
lives. I believe that Washington would serve America better if we
worried more about the people that lived outside Washington than
where people stood on the totem pole inside Washington. And I
think
you believe that, too. And that's what I ask you to think about
tonight.
I'll be very brief. I
want to mention to you what I think are the
central questions facing the country in this election season which
is
unfolding rapidly now, and then what I think are some of the
central
questions facing this country over the next 20 years, because I
ask
you to begin thinking about it. We were talking about it at one of
the tables tonight. And this community has got to continue to be
involved in America to help us raise our imaginations and raise
our
visions toward these long-term issues as well.
I tell all my fellow
Democrats that, contrary to what you might
think, the great enemy of our cause in this election is not
adversity, it is, instead, complacency. Because oftentimes, when
people are doing well and things are doing well and they have a
high
level of comfort and confidence, particularly if they come through
a
very wrenching time-and our country came through a pretty
wrenching
time in the late eighties and early nineties, indeed throughout
the
decade of the eighties-the tendency is to say, "We'd like to
relax a
little bit. We're tired. Things are good for us now. We just want
to not think about this." In this case, "this" is
politics right
now.
You live in a world that
never permits that, because it's changing
so fast. One thing I'd like to ask you to do is to think about how
you can communicate that sense of urgency to the rest of your
fellow
Americans. And that's what I hope to do here tonight-because even
though people may not understand it in the way you do, if you're
struggling to develop a new product, a new service, keep up with
some
new discovery, the truth is that everyone else's life is more
dynamic
than most people realize as well.
And while I am profoundly
grateful that we have the lowest
unemployment rate in 28 years and the lowest crime rate in 25
years
and the smallest percentage of people on welfare in 29 years, and
next week the first balanced budget and surplus in 29 years, and
the
highest homeownership in history, and we just learned yesterday the
lowest AfricanAmerican poverty rate ever recorded, the biggest
increase in wages in 20 years-I'm grateful for allthat. The truth
is that this is a dynamic world. And so the right thing to do is
not
to rest on that but to build on it, to ask ourselves, "Okay,
what
else needs to be done?"
Now, in this election season, I think there are the following
major issues that, to me, are very important. We had a big vote on
one in the House today. There are some who say, "Well, we're
going
to have a surplus for the first time in 29 years and it's just a
few
weeks from the election, so let's have a tax cut." And even
though
I'm not a candidate anymore and won't be running for anything
anymore, I understand the appeal of that, but I think it's dead
wrong. For one thing, I'd just like to see the red ink turn to
black
and dry before we start spending again. [Laughter] I've been
working
for this for 6 years. I'd just like to see it dry, you know?
[Laughter]
And in a more serious
way, in this world financial situation we
have been a pillar of stability and strength and responsibility,
and
we need to communicate that to pe ople. And I know it's popular to
offer a tax cut right here before an election, but in this case it
would be wrong.
And there's another
reason it's wrong. It's wrong because we
finally have, I believe, a bipartisan consensus for making
modifications in the Social Security system that will enable us to
preserve it when the baby boomers retire-and at present rates, at
least, there will only be hvo people working for every one person
drawing. And I can just tell you the baby boomers are-and a lot of
you are too young to be one-[laughter]but, basically, the baby
boom
generation is everybody between the ages of 52 and 34. And when
that
group-only the present group in school is bigger than the baby
boom
generation. And when that group retires, unless we act now in a
modest, measured, disciplined way-and if we don't do anything
until
the time comes to face it, and with every year it will become a
more
severe decision because you'll be closer in time to it-we'll have
the
decision of either cutting benefits for seniors so much that we'll
erode the safety net, which today accounts for 48 percent of the
people on Social Security being lifted out of poverty-that is,
they
would be in poverty were it not for Social Security.
Or, in the alternative,
we'll decide we can't bear that, and we'll
raise taxes dramatically to maintain the old system, in which case
we
will undermine the standard of living of our children and
grandchildren, which would be equally wrong. And that's not
necessary. But in order to avoid it, we have to make an
election-year decision and tell the American people the truth that
we
ought to do something for the next 30 years and not for the next
30
days, and save Social Security before we entertain a tax cut out
of
this surplus. I think it is very important.
The second issue, if we
want to continue to lead the world
economy, we at least have to pay our way. For 8 months now, I've
been trying to get the Congress to approve our contribution to the
International Monetary Fund. Now, it's not perfect. And the IMF is
having to make adjustments, too, to recognize the new realities of
the global economy. But it is the most important instrument for
helping countries, first of all, reform as they should, and then
if
they do, get back on their feet; and, secondly, for helping us
limit
the contagion that is now gripping so many Asian economies from
bleeding over into Latin America, for example, our fastest growing
market as a country, and into countries that have done a good job
in
managing their own economies. I think it is absolutely imperative.
And it's pretty hard to
make an issue this, normally, esoteric, an
issue in an election year. But I'm telling you, if ve don't
exercise
our responsibility to try to stabilize the global economy, as Alan
Greenspan said the other day, we cannot forever be an island of
prosperity in a sea of dislocation. We have got to do this, and I
feel very strongly about it.
The third thing that I
think is very important is that the
education agenda be continually pushed forward. Eight months ago I
put before the Congress an education program based on the best
research about what is working in our schools. Among other things
in
the balanced budget, not spending the surplus, it would provide
funds
for another 100,000 teachers to be hired to take average class
size
down to 18 in the early grades. It would provide a tax incentive
program to rebuild, remodel, or build 5,000 schools at a time when
it's a big problem. It has the funds to continue our part of
hooking
up all the classrooms to the Internet by the year 2000. It has
funds
for another, over a several year period, 3,000 charter schools-and
thank you, Reed Hastings, for all the work you've done here in
California. California is leading the way, thank you very much.
And a lot of other things
that are very, very important, including
paying the college expenses of 35,000 young people who can then
pay
their college expenses off by going into inner-city areas and
other
areas of teacher shortage and teaching for a few years to pay
their
expenses off. It contains the best examples of the most reform-
oriented, big-city school system in the country, which I visited
again today, I think for the sixth time, in Chicago, where they
have
ended social promotion. And underperforming students in what used
to
be thought of as the worst big-- city school system in the
country-I
went to a school district today where 100 percent of the kids live
in
Cabrini-Green, one of the most economically challenged housing
projects in America. They have doubled their reading scores and
tripled their math scores in 4 years.
And there is no social
promotion, but they don't just throw the
kids out. Every child that doesn't perform has to go to summer
school. And they have after-school tutoring programs, so that now
the summer school program in Chicago is the sixth biggest school
district in America-the summer school. Over 40,000 children get 3
square meals a day there. But learning is beginning to occur
because
they have standards and accountability-but support. They don't
treat
children who don't perform as failures; they treat them as people
who
need more support and more help. And I think that's important.
So we need to save Social
Security,. We need to fund the IMF. We
need to pass the education program. Two other things I want to
mention. I have worked very hard for the last 6 years, along with
the Vice President, to persuade the American people that we can
improve the environment and grow the economy. And compared to 6
years ago, the air is cleaner; the water is cleaner; the food is
safer; lots of toxic waste dumps have been cleaned up. But there
are
still people who just don't believe it. And we're having a huge
environmental fight up there, and protecting these environmental
initiatives is very important.
Finally, I strongly
believe that Congress ought to pass a uniform
Patients' Bill of Rights for the country. And there may even be
some
disagreement about that in this audience, but I'd just like to
tell
you what my experience is here. There are 160 million Americans in
managed care plans. Forty-- three big managed care companies are
supporting this legislation. Why? Because they provide these
protections, and they know that they're being punished in the
marketplace for doing what they believe is right.
Now, a lot of you are
employers, and you're concerned about
controlling costs, but let me just tell you some of the things
that
are actually happening in America today. In big cities, if
somebody
walks outside a hotel and gets hit by a car, depending on what the
coverage of the plan is, they might drive past three hospitals to
get
to an emergency room covered by the plan, instead of going to the
nearest emergency room. There are places where, even if your
doctor
recommends you see a specialist and says, "I'm sorry. I can't
do
this," they still can't get to see a specialist until they go
through
three or four layers of approval.
Many times all these
horror stories you hear about people being
denied care are not quite accurate. Actually, almost always, or
more
than half the time, the managed care company does approve the
procedure, but the delays are so great that it's too late to do
the
right thing.
Another big problem for
small businesses is when the employer
changes providers, very often immediately all the employees are
affected by it. Now, that sounds reasonable. Except if you're
pregnant, and you're 6 months pregnant, you shouldn't have to give
up
your obstetrician for months 7, 8, and 9. If you're in the middle
of
a chemotherapy treatment, you shouldn't have to give it up in the
middle of the treatment. That's what this bill does. And it also
protects the privacy of medical records, which I think is very, very
important.
So I think this Patients'
Bill of Rights is the right thing to do
for the country, and I hope it will pass. Those are the big
issues,
to me, that we ought to be fighting for.
Now, in the election, the
voters vill have a clear choice. Do
they want this kind of progress, or do they want partisanship? Do
they want this to focus on people, or do they want this to focus
on
politics? And you can help us.
Now, if you look at the
long run-let me just mention something
very briefly, just a few things that I wish you'd begin to think
about. How are we going to change Social Security and Medicare so
that we legitimately care for the elderly without bankrupting
their
children and grandchildren? What are we going to do? We'll be
making those decisions-I hope and pray-in the first 6 months of
next
year. How are we going to do this? The Medicare Commission will
complete its report, and we will complete our year-long work on
Social Security in December.
The second question: What
else do we need to do in education, to
really provide world-class education, K through 12, in America?
Everybody knows we've got the best system of higher education in
the
world, how are we going to give every child, without regard to
their
circumstances in life, that opportunity?
Third question: How can
we convince people that the problem of
climate change is real and the biggest long-term environmental
challenge, closely related-especially in California-to the problem
of
ocean degradation, which is fast becoming a global problem? And
how
can you here, who know it to be true, convince people that there
is
no longer an iron link between old-fashioned, industrial-era
energy
usage and economic growth? Because, make no mistake about it,
that,
in the end, is what is holding back our advances in the
environment.
Most people who are in decisionmaking capacities honestly believe
you
can't grow an economy unless you use energy in the way we've been
using it for the last 50 years, and unless you use more of the
same
kind. You can help; you can make a huge difference there.
Fourthly, what are we going to do over the
long run-and it has to
be done fairly soon-to modify the world financial system and the
world trading system so it works for ordinary people and it limits
these huge boom/bust cycles without interrupting the free flow of
capital? I am very worried that in country after country after
country, ifyou have year after year after year of falling living
standards, that people will fall out of love with free markets and
free governments.
It's only been the last 3
or 4 or 5 years that, for the first time
in all human history, more people are living under governments
that
they chose themselves than dictatorships of one kind or another.
This is a precious gift, this gift of freedom, but we have to
prove
that it will work for ordinary people. And the United States has
to
take the lead in that. And all of you have a huge stake in it-a
huge
stake in it.
Everything you want to do
with the Internet rests on the premise
that people will get freer and freer and freer, and that it is a
very
good thing. And you know I believe that. So we have got to deal
with that.
And finally, I just ask
you to help meI got the last report of the
President's Initiative on Race last week, and I've got this on my
mind, too. If you think about what I do in foreign policy as your
representative-- we're worried about Kosovo today. What is Kosovo?
It's an ethnic conflict between Serbs and Albanian Muslims. What
is
going on in the Middle East? It's an ethnic and religious
conflict.
I'm going to do a lot of work on that next week. What is the
conflict that we're celebrating-I hope the final end of-- in
Northern
Ireland? It's a religious conflict.
You may have been reading-a few years ago we had this horrible war
in Rwanda, where over three-quarters of a million people were
killed
in a tribal conflict. And now in the Congo there are five
different
countries intervening in their conflict there and part of it is
the
settling of old scores among tribal conflicts.
Now, here in Silicon
Valley, you see people from all over the
world, from all different racial and ethnic groups and religious
and
cultural backgrounds, finding a way to work together to make
common
cause. And over the long run it may be our ability to prove that
we
can preserve and advance the American system and give deeper
meaning
to the Constitution of the United States as we grow more diverse,
than anything else that will permit us to be a powerful force for
good in the 21st century.
And so I say to you, I
hope you'll keep working on that, and I
hope you'll keep lifting that up, because I see deep in the heart
of
people all over the world this almost compulsive drive to define
themselves in negative terms, in the fact that their life has
meaning
because they are not the "other," whatever the
"other" is. And just
the way you do things here is a constant, daily rebuke to that.
And
that's what America has to do. We have to prove that we are
bringing
out the best in each other if we hope to be a positive force in
bringing out the best in people throughout the world.
Finally, let me just say
that I believe that the best days of this
country are still ahead of us. And I believe that we have been
given
a precious gift, but an enormous responsibility. The real question
before is, now that we have all this prosperity, now that we have
all
this confidence, now that we have this dominant position in the
world, what are we going to make of this moment? Are we going to
relax? Are we going to feed on each other? Are we going to care
for
each other and build a better tomorrow? I think I know what your
answer is, and I want you to help me make that America's answer.
Thank you, and God bless
you.
NOTE: The President spoke
at 9:55 p.m. at the Tech Museum of
Innovation. In his remarks, he referred to dinner host John Doerr;
Mayor Susan Hammer of San Jose; and Reed Hastings, chief executive
officer, Technology Network. This item was not received in time
for
publication in the appropriate issue