Supreme Court of New Hampshire.
BANCROFT & RICH
v.
UNION EMBOSSING CO.
Dec. 31, 1903.
Headnotes
*98 Assumpsit to
recover $200 and interest thereon for each of nine "automatic lateral carving machines" manufactured and
sold by the defendants in accordance with a written contract executed May 6,
1899, the material provisions of which are set forth in the opinion. May 27,
1901, the plaintiffs were notified that the defendants would not be further
bound by the contract, and about the middle of the following July the patterns
mentioned in the contract were returned to the plaintiffs, who did not assent
to the rescission of the agreement. Subsequent to the notification, the
defendants manufactured nine machines, four of which were sold before the patterns
were returned, and five of which were disposed of after that date. The case was
tried at the May term, 1903, of the superior court, before Pike, J. The
plaintiffs contended that the defendants
were liable under the contract for all machines manufactured and sold by them.
The defendants contended that the right of rescission was properly exercised by
them on May 27, 1901, and that they were not liable for any machines manufactured
after that date. It was ruled that there was such a failure of consideration as
entitled the defendants to rescind by putting the plaintiffs in the situation
they occupied before the execution of the contract, that the right was
exercised within a reasonable time, that the rescission was not complete until
the patterns were returned, and that the plaintiffs were entitled to recover
the stipulated price for the four machines sold by the defendants prior to the
completion of the rescission. The court found a verdict for the plaintiffs in
the sum of $892.33, being the price for four machines, and interest thereon,
and to this finding both parties excepted.
Eastman & Hollis, for
plaintiffs.
Arthur W. Morgan and
Bradford & Hood, for defendants.
BINGHAM, J.
The questions in this case
arise upon exceptions taken by the parties to the findings and rulings made in
the superior court. At the time the contract in question was executed, the
plaintiffs had not procured a patent upon their embossing machine; but the
parties believed that its principal feature was novel,
and that the plaintiffs would obtain a patent which would control the
manufacture and sale of the machine. The plaintiffs, however, were not successful
in obtaining such a patent, although patents were granted to them upon some
minor parts. The defendants operated under the contract for a period of over
two years, and down to May 27, 1901, when they notified the plaintiffs that
they would not be further bound by it. After this notification the defendants
manufactured and sold nine of the machines, four of which were sold before the
middle of July, 1901, when the patterns mentioned in the contract were returned
to the plaintiffs. This suit is brought upon the contract to recover the sum of
$200 for each of the nine machines so manufactured and sold. The superior court
ruled that there was such a failure of consideration as entitled the defendants
to rescind the contract; that a rescission was made within a reasonable time,
but was not completed until the middle of July, 1901, when the patterns were
returned; and that the plaintiffs could recover the price named in the contract
for each of the four machines sold prior to the return of the patterns, but not
for those sold after that time.
The plaintiffs claim that
the fact that the parties believed the principal feature of the machine was
patentable, when it was not, did not constitute a failure of consideration
entitling the defendants to rescind the contract; that the consideration for
the defendants' undertaking is to be found in the contract itself; that the
belief of the parties as to the novelty and patentability
of the principal feature of the machine is immaterial; and that the material
question is what the parties understood, as gathered from the terms of the
written contract. We are inclined *99 to accede to this view of the
case. This is not a proceeding to reform the contract, but to enforce its provisions
as therein expressed. If the contract as drawn does not express the
understanding of the parties at the time it was made, it can be reformed upon
proper proceedings instituted for that purpose; but, until reformed, their
understanding is to be ascertained from the written contract, viewed in the
light of the circumstances under which it was executed; and a finding as to the
belief of the parties, based upon evidence gathered from extraneous sources, is
immaterial. Horne v. Hutchins, 72 N.H. 214, 55 Atl. 364.
It is apparent from the
contract that the plaintiffs did not agree they would be successful in
obtaining patents, fundamental or otherwise, upon the machine, or that the
defendants should be excused from complying with its terms in case a fundamental
patent was not obtained. What the plaintiffs undertook to do is there set forth
in plain and unambiguous terms. After stating that they were ready and willing
to give the defendants "the exclusive right, so far as it is in their
power, to manufacture and sell the said machines," they agree (1) that the
defendants shall have "full and exclusive license under any letters patent
which may be granted to them *** for inventions and improvements contained in
or relating to said embossing machine, for the full term for which any such letters patent are or may be granted, including
any renewal, reissue, or extension thereof," whether obtained from the
government of the United States or any foreign country; (2) "that they
will not during the existence of this contract make, vend, or use any embossing
machines" of the type named; (3) that they will give to the defendants
"all patterns and drawings which they have relating to such machines, and
will furnish such drawings as may be necessary for the manufacture of the
machines, and will give them the benefit of their advice and co-operation in
the manufacture of the said machines so long as this contract shall remain in
force"; (4) that they will transfer to the defendants "all orders
which they now have or may hereafter have for embossing machines of the type
*** described," except two orders specifically named; (5) "that they
will not during the existence of this contract in any way sell or assign any letters
patent of the United States or any foreign country relating to said machine or
any improvement thereon, or grant any rights thereunder"; and (6) that
"this contract shall last for the full term for which any letters patent
upon the applications of the [plaintiffs] *** are or may be granted, including
any renewal, reissue, or extension thereof, and if no such patent shall be
granted upon said machine, then this contract shall last for the term of twenty
years from the date hereof." These undertakings of the plaintiffs
constituted the consideration for those of the defendants; and it is found that
the plaintiffs "did what in the agreement was covenanted and agreed,"
and that "in consequence *** the
defendants were relieved from competition with the plaintiffs." The
contract was not a mere license to the defendants to manufacture and sell
machines of this type, provided the plaintiffs were successful in obtaining an
exclusive right by letters patent upon the principal feature of the machine,
and an agreement to waive the enforcement of such right against the defendants;
but was a sale of the plaintiffs' good will in the business of manufacturing
and selling machines of this type, together with any patent rights which they
might procure upon the machine from the government of the United States or any
foreign country, and an agreement not to make, vend, or use the machine during
the existence of the contract. Wood v. Company, 165 N.Y. 545, 59 N.E. 357;
Brett v. Ebel, 29 App.Div. 256, 51 N.Y.Supp. 573.
But the defendants say
that, if such was the nature of the contract, it was in general restraint of
trade and void, for the reason that it was unlimited as to territory, although
limited as to time. An agreement in restraint of a man's right to exercise his
trade or calling, according to the early common law of England, was void as
against public policy. In those days a man could not lawfully exercise a trade
to which he had not been duly apprenticed, and one so admitted was obliged by
statute to follow and exercise his trade under a penalty. Poll. Cont. 313.
Hence, to enforce such an agreement was to deny the covenantor the right to
earn his living, and to require him to violate an express provision of law.
When the courts first began to recognize as valid any restraint upon trade, such restraints were
confined within very narrow limits. The limitations which were allowed were
such as were clearly necessary to protect the covenantee in the ordinary
exercise of his trade or calling, having reference to the state of society and
the conditions under which business was then carried on. In the application of
this principle of reasonable necessity, a classification of agreements in
restraint of trade came to be recognized, to wit: (1) Where the restraint was
unlimited both as to time and space; (2) where it was limited as to time, but
unlimited as to space; (3) where it was limited as to space, but unlimited as
to time; and (4) where it was limited as to both time and space. If the
agreement fell within the first or second class, it was held to be void; but if
within the third or fourth, it was valid. In this jurisdiction three cases have
arisen, two of which came within the second class, and one within the fourth
class, and in all of them the contracts were upheld: Webster v. Buss, 61 N.H.
40, 60 Am.Rep. 317; Eastern Express Co. v. Meserve, 60 N.H. 198; Perkins v.
Clay, 54 N.H. 518. Whether the contracts were considered reasonable, having
reference to the *100 nature of the business and the circumstances of
each case, is not stated. No decision has been found in our Reports in which
the restraint was of the nature now under consideration.
Within the past few years
the above classification, as a hard and fast rule of decision, has been
questioned; and the House of Lords and many of the courts of this country, after an extensive review of the
cases, have refused to be bound by it. Nordenfelt v. Company [1894] A.C. 535;
Rousillon v. Rousillon, L.R. 14 Ch.Div. 351; Anchor Electric Co. v. Hawkes, 171
Mass. 101, 50 N.E. 509, 41 L.R.A. 189, 68 Am.St.Rep. 403; Watertown, etc., Co.
v. Pool, 51 Hun, 157, 163, 4 N.Y.Supp. 861; U.S. Cordage Co. v. Company, 90
Hun, 429, 434, 35 N.Y.Supp. 978; Ru Ton v. Everitt, 35 App.Div. 412, 54
N.Y.Supp. 896; Diamond Match Co. v. Roeber, 106 N.Y. 473, 13 N.E. 419, 60
Am.Rep. 464; Wood v. Company, 165 N.Y. 545, 59 N.E. 357; National Enameling Co.
v. Haberman (C.C.) 120 Fed. 415; 24 Am. & Eng.Enc.Law, 842-862. The
conclusion reached in these decisions is that the validity of the agreement
depends upon the reasonableness of the restraint as applied to the particular
circumstances of each case, and that the contract is necessarily unreasonable
and void if it is not limited as to space. It has even been denied that the
alleged rule as to limits of space ever existed in England, as a positive rule
of law, in any class of cases. Rousillon v. Rousillon, L.R. 14 Ch.Div. 366. If,
as is quite probable, this classification was the result of the application of
the principle of reasonable necessity in a series of cases, at a time when
trade and intercourse were necessarily confined to a given locality or to
comparatively narrow limits, and the classification as applied to those
conditions met the rule of reasonableness, there would seem to be no reason for
its continued recognition and application, as a hard and fast rule, to cases arising under the enlarged and materially
changed conditions in which trade and commerce are now carried on, but rather
that there should be a recurrence to and application of the principle itself.
In Wood v. Company, supra,
Gray, J., in speaking of the doctrine which avoids a contract for being one in
restraint of trade, says: "It had its origin at a time when the field of
human enterprise was limited, and when each man's industrial activity was more
or less necessary to the material well-being and welfare of the community and
of the state. *** The conditions which made so rigid a doctrine reasonable no
longer exist. In the present practically unlimited field of human enterprise,
there is no good reason for restricting the freedom to contract, or for fearing
injury to the public from contracts which prevent a person from carrying on a
particular business. Interference would only be justifiable when it was
demonstrable that in some way the public interests were endangered. But
contracts between parties, which have for their object the removal of a rival
and competitor in a business, are not to be regarded as contracts in restraint
of trade. They do not close the field of competition, except as to the
particular party to be affected. To say at the present day that such a contract
as was made in this case was affected by a public interest, and was a matter of
public concern, would be, in my opinion, unreasonable."
In Diamond Match Co. v.
Roeber, supra, Andrews, J., says: "When the restraint is general, but at the same time is
coextensive only with the interest to be protected and with the benefit meant
to be conferred, there seems to be no good reason why, as between the parties,
the contract is not as reasonable as when the interest is partial, and there is
a corresponding partial restraint. And is there any real public interest which
necessarily condemns the one, and not the other? It is an encouragement to
industry and to enterprise, in building up a trade, that a man shall be allowed
to sell the good will of the business and the fruits of his industry upon the
best terms he can obtain. If his business extends over a contingent, does
public policy forbid his accompanying the sale with a stipulation for restraint
coextensive with the business which he sells? If such a contract is permitted,
is the seller any more likely to become a burden on the public than a man who,
having built up a local trade only, sells it, binding himself not to carry it
on in the locality? Are the opportunities for employment and for the exercise
of useful talents so shut up and hemmed in that the public is likely to lose a
useful member of society in the one case and not in the other? Indeed, what
public policy requires is often a vague and difficult inquiry. It is clear that
public policy and the interests of society favor the utmost freedom of
contract, within the law, and require that business transactions should not be
trammeled by unnecessary restrictions. If *** there is one thing more than any
other which public policy requires, it is that men of full age and competent understanding shall have the utmost liberty of
contracting, and that contracts, when entered into freely and voluntarily,
shall be held good and shall be enforced by courts of justice. It has sometimes
been suggested that the doctrine that contracts in general restraint of trade
are void is founded in part upon the policy of preventing monopolies, which are
opposed to the liberty of the subject, and the granting of which by the king,
under claim of royal prerogative, led to conflicts memorable in English
history. But covenants of the character of the one now in question operate
simply to prevent the covenantor from engaging in the business which he sells,
so as to protect the purchaser in the enjoyment of what he has purchased. To
the extent that the contract *101 prevents the vendor from carrying on
the particular trade, it deprives the community of any benefit it might derive
from his entering into competition. But the business is open to all others, and
there is little danger that the public will suffer harm from lack of persons to
engage in a profitable industry. Such contracts do not create monopolies. They
confer no special or exclusive privilege. If contracts in general restraint of
trade, where the trade is general, are void as tending to monopolies, contracts
in partial restraint, where the trade is local, are subject to the same
objection, because they deprive the local community of the services of the
covenantor in the particular trade or calling, and prevent his becoming a
competitor with the covenantee. We are not aware of any rule of law which makes
the motive of the covenantee the test of
the validity of such a contract. On the contrary, we suppose a party may
legally purchase the trade and business of another for the very purpose of
preventing competition; and the validity of the contract, if supported by a
consideration, will depend upon its reasonableness as between the parties.
Combination between producers to limit production and to enhance prices are or
may be unlawful, but they stand on a different footing."
It seems to us that,
inasmuch as public policy requires that a man should be free to sell in the
most advantageous way what he has obtained by his skill or other means, the
same public policy should permit him to enter into restrictive covenants in aid
of the thing sold, provided the restriction, in the judgment of the court, is
not unreasonable, having regard to the subject-matter of the contract. And it
seems to be generally held that the question whether the restriction is
reasonable, as applied in this class of cases, is one of law, and not of fact.
Anchor Electric Co. v. Hawkes, supra; Cohen v. Company, 166 N.Y. 292, 59 N.E.
906; Linn v. Sigsbee, 67 Ill. 75; Haynes v. Doman [[1899] 2 Ch.Div. 24; Poll.
Cont. 316; 24 Am. & Eng.Enc.Law, 858. In the application of this principle,
the question is whether the restraint affords more than a fair and reasonable
protection to the party in whose favor it is imposed. If it does not, the
contract should be upheld. It will be noticed that the contract in this case
does not restrain the plaintiffs from manufacturing and selling embossing
machines of every description, as was the case in Berlin v. Perry, 71 Wis. 495, 38 N.W. 82, 5
Am.St.Rep. 236, cited by the defendants, but simply those involving the
specific feature which the defendants were to manufacture and sell under the
contract; and considering the nature of the business, the admitted limited
number of customers, and their location throughout the various states of this
country, we do not think the restriction can be held to exceed what is
necessary for the protection of the purchaser, or that it violates any
principle of public policy.
The defendants also
contend that the contract comes within the provisions of Act Cong. July 2,
1890, c. 647, 26 Stat. 209 [U.S.Comp.St. 1901, p. 3200], preventing restraints
upon trade and commerce among the several states and foreign nations, and is
therefore void. But we fail to see how the contract comes within this statute.
It does not place or contemplate any direct restraint upon the right of the
defendants to make sales of the manufactured article in any of the United
States or any foreign country. Under it, the defendants were at liberty to
carry on their trade in all of the states of the Union or any foreign country.
This contention was raised in Brett v. Ebel, supra, where the restraint was of
a similar nature, and it was held that the contract was not in contravention of
the act or within its spirit; that if the "act were to be construed
literally and technically, so as to embrace such a contract, *** it would involve
consequences most harmful to the commercial community--consequences which ***
were not contemplated by the lawmakers." See, also, United States v. Association, 166 U.S.
290, 17 Sup.Ct. 540, 41 L.Ed. 1007; United States v. Company, 85 Fed. 271, 29
C.C.A. 141, 46 L.R.A. 122. The Supreme Court of the United States, in
considering this statute, has said: "When it is seen that the agreement
entered into does not directly relate to and act upon and embrace interstate
commerce, and that it was executed for another and entirely different purpose,
and that it was calculated to attain it, the agreement would be upheld, if its
effect upon that commerce were only indirect and incidental." Addyston,
etc., Co. v. United States, 175 U.S. 221, 244, 20 Sup.Ct. 96, 108, 44 L.Ed.
136, 148; Anderson v. United States, 171 U.S. 604, 19 Sup.Ct. 50, 43 L.Ed. 300.
We are therefore of the
opinion that this contention of the defendants cannot be maintained, and that
the plaintiffs are entitled to recover the contract price and interest on the
five machines sold after the middle of July, 1901, in addition to what has
already been allowed them.
Plaintiffs' exception
sustained; defendants' exception overruled. All concurred.
N.H. 1903.
57 A. 97, 64 L.R.A. 298, 72 N.H. 402
END OF DOCUMENT