Supreme Court of New Hampshire.
SPRINGFIELD
v.
DRAKE.
December, 1876.
*1 When the
assignee of a right to canvass for and sell a patented machine, as agent, is
not disturbed in exercising the right, the assignor, in an action for the
purchase-money, is not required to prove his principal's title.
Such an assignment conveys
no interest in the monopoly conferred by the patent, and may be verbal.
A ratification of an act
done by one assuming to be an agent, relates back, and is equivalent to a prior
authority.
It is fraud, if, in making
an assignment, the assignor, on a material point, knowingly states what is
false, or what he does not know to be true, and what was not equally well known
to the assignee, who is misled thereby to his injury.
ASSUMPSIT, upon a
promissory note.
The consideration of the note was a verbal assignment by the
plaintiff to the defendant, of his right to sell a patented knitting machine in
three towns in Carroll county, under his written appointment as agent of the
Bickford Novelty Manufacturing Company.
The defendant claimed that
the note was obtained by fraud, and that no right passed to the defendant by
the assignment. The patentee of the machine was one Dana Bickford. The letters
patent, and the plaintiff's written appointment by said company as its agent,
were given in evidence. Said appointment authorized him to canvass for and sell
the machine in Carroll county, the company agreeing to furnish said machine at
their wholesale prices, and allow the retail profits as pay to the plaintiff
for his services. Said verbal assignment was made and the note was dated
February 1, 1869, and the defendant had the plaintiff order for him a bill of
machines, which were furnished by the company on the third, and paid for on the
fourth, of the same month.
It did not appear that the
defendant was disturbed in the exercise or use of his rights as conveyed. The
charge of the court, and other material facts, sufficiently appear in the
opinion.
Headnotes
B. C. Carter, for
the plaintiff.
Quarles, for the
defendant.
BINGHAM, J.
*2 It does not
appear that Bickford had conveyed his title to the company at the time of the
plaintiff's appointment; and the defendant claims that, his principal having no
apparent title, the agent's conveyance would not be a sufficient consideration
for the note. The defendant obtained the patented machine for sale under his
assignment, and he was never disturbed in the full use of all the rights he
supposed he acquired under it, and for which he gave his note.
The general doctrine upon
this subject appears to be, that when the vendee has not been disturbed in the
exercise and use of his rights as conveyed, he is not in a situation to call
upon the vendor, in an action for the purchase-money, to establish his title to
the thing sold. Buss v. Putney, 38 N. H. 47; Bartlett v. Holbrook,
1 Gray 114; Stevens v. Head, 9 Vt. 174. If it is material to his defence
that the vendor's want of title appear, the burden is upon him to prove it.
The defendant excepted to
the charge of the court, that the plaintiff could convey to the defendant, by
verbal assignment, the rights he had under his appointment.
A patent is personal
property--Holden v. Curtis, 2 N. H. 63--and, if it were not for the law of congress, could be
conveyed by parol. Buss v. Putney, before cited. The plaintiff conveyed
to the defendant, by the verbal assignment, the authority and license he had of
the company to canvass and sell the machine in three towns in Carroll county,
and to have the machine furnished him at wholesale prices, retaining the retail
profits as pay for his services. This was not a conveyance of any interest in
the monopoly conferred by the letters patent. It was a mere assignment of the
plaintiff's license to canvass and sell for the owner in those towns, and not
required to be in writing. Gayler v. Wilder, 10 How. 477.
The defendant's objection,
that the plaintiff had not authority to make the assignment, is not well taken.
The appointment provides that the plaintiff may do the work, or cause others to
do it, which is sufficient to authorize the making of the assignment. If there
had been no prior authority, there was a subsequent ratification. A
ratification is equivalent to prior authority. Despatch Line v. Bellamy,
12 N. H. 232; Davis v. School District, 44 N. H. 407.
Upon the question of
fraud, the court charged the jury that the plaintiff must have stated what was
false, and known to be so, or not known to be true, on a point material to the
contract,in relation to a matter not equally within the knowledge of the
defendant, and by which the defendant was actually misled to his injury.
*3 We think this a correct statement of the law. Hoitt
v. Holcomb, 23 N. H. 535, 552; Gage v. Gage, 29 N. H. 543.
Judgment on the
verdict.
N.H. 1876.
58 N.H. 19
END OF DOCUMENT