Supreme Court of New Hampshire.
William J. GOSSELIN et al.
v.
Fortika B. ARCHIBALD.
No. 80-465.
Nov. 20, 1981.
Headnotes
**304 *1017
Murphy & Foley, P. A., Plymouth (Edwin W. Kelly, Plymouth, by brief and
Walter L. Murphy, Plymouth, orally), for plaintiffs.
Nighswander, Lord, Martin
& KillKelley, Laconia (David J. KillKelley, Laconia, on brief and orally),
for defendant.
KING, Chief Justice.
The questions to be
decided in this case are whether the trial court erred in awarding the plaintiffs
compensatory damages in a breach of contract action and in enforcing and
extending a covenant not to compete. We
affirm in part, reverse in part, and remand.
The defendant, Fortika B. Archibald, owned real estate known as
the Deep River Motor Inn in Plymouth, New Hampshire. The defendant negotiated with Richard and Carol Hogan for the
purchase of the property, but, because the Hogans could not obtain financing,
the sale was never consummated. The
plaintiffs, William J. Gosselin and Betty E. Gosselin, had a tentative
agreement with the Hogans to join efforts in managing the Deep River Motor Inn
and another property, the Staffordshire Inn, which the Hogans owned. When the negotiations between the defendant
and the Hogans failed, the defendant offered the property to the
plaintiffs. The plaintiffs accepted and
the defendant revised the documents prepared for the sale to the Hogans to name
the plaintiffs as the purchasers.
On November 30, 1977, the
defendant and the plaintiffs signed a purchase and sale agreement for the
property. In this document, the
defendant agreed that:
"At the time of the closing, seller shall execute an
agreement in form satisfactory to both parties wherein seller will covenant and
agree that for a period of five (5) years after the date of closing she will
not, anywhere within a radius of fifteen (15) air miles of the Deep River *1018
Motor Inn, compete with the Buyers in the motel, restaurant or resort business
either as owner of a competing business, or otherwise."
The defendant also agreed:
"(T)o convey to Buyer all rights and exclusive use of the
trade name 'Deep River Motor Inn' and 'Deep River,' with the exception that the
Seller may use the name 'Deep River' for her
exclusive use in her real estate business, and Seller agrees to deliver to
Buyer at the time of closing such documents as may be necessary to enable
Buyers to register said trade name in the office of the New Hampshire Secretary
of State."
Additionally, the purchase
and sale agreement contained a provision stating that the seller would
"rent space currently occupied by seller's real estate business ..., such
tenancy to be at will, and sixty days' written notice by either party to the
other shall be required to terminate such tenancy."
The plaintiffs took
possession of the premises on or about December 16, 1977, and the defendant
continued to occupy the space provided for her real estate business. At the closing on December 28, 1977, the
defendant executed a warranty deed for the Deep River Motor Inn to the
plaintiffs. On this date the defendant
also delivered to the plaintiffs an option agreement for the purchase of
approximately twenty-nine acres of unimproved land, payment to be made over a
three-year period. The agreement gave
the plaintiffs the right to exercise the option in writing between August 1,
1978, and August 15, 1978. In a letter
dated August 14, 1978, the plaintiffs exercised their option to purchase this
property. **305 The chief of
police of Campton delivered the letter to the defendant's husband on the
evening of August 15, 1978. Although
several closings were arranged, the defendant has never executed a deed for the
property to the plaintiffs.
In accordance with the purchase and sale agreement for the Deep
River property, the defendant delivered a dissolution form, relinquishing her
rights to the trade name Deep River Motor Inn.
The dissolution was not effective, however, because the name was
registered to John M. Ranney and Marjorie N. Ranney. Since that time, the plaintiffs have obtained a release from the
Ranneys and the trade name is now registered in the plaintiffs' names.
The plaintiffs allege that
the defendant did not deliver 144 of the 716 sheets included in the inventory
of Deep River Motor Inn, and that the defendant failed to make repairs that she
promised. The *1019 defendant
admits that she has not complied with these two obligations.
In February 1978, the
defendant approached the plaintiffs with a plan under which they could lease
another motel for sale in Plymouth, New Hampshire, originally known as Tobeys,
now known as The Candlelite Traveler (Candlelite). The Candlelite is located
about one-and-one-half miles from the Deep River Motor Inn. The defendant had a broker's listing for
this motel, and she was interested in the property. Having made an agreement not to compete with the plaintiffs,
however, she hoped to include the plaintiffs in the transaction. The plaintiffs
offered to lease the Candlelite for ten years with an option to buy, but the
defendant wanted a lease for only three years.
Consequently, negotiations between the parties ended.
On March 13, 1978, Dr.
John Archibald, the defendant's husband, signed a purchase and sale agreement to buy the
Candlelite. At approximately the same
time, the defendant and her husband went to see the plaintiffs and informed
them of the pending sale. After this
visit, relations between the parties deteriorated. Subsequently, the defendant abandoned the space she rented at the
Deep River Motor Inn, having given the plaintiffs one week's notice. The defendant asserts that she was bothered
by the plaintiffs' "traipsing" through her offices, but she did not
complain at that time to the plaintiffs or indicate that as her reason for
terminating the tenancy.
On April 25, 1978, Dr.
Archibald bought the Candlelite, and by June 1978, the defendant had moved her
real estate business to the Candlelite, still using the name Deep River Realty.
There is evidence in the
record that the defendant participated in some aspects of the management of the
Candlelite. Additionally, the defendant
admits that her husband had no experience in motel or restaurant management
prior to acquiring the Candlelite. Dr.
Archibald had a busy medical practice and devoted little time to the operation
of the Candlelite.
The plaintiffs brought an
action against the defendant in Grafton County Superior Court asking for
equitable and monetary relief for breaches of the parties' contracts. The Master's (Mayland H. Morse, Esq.)
decree, approved by the Trial Court (Johnson, J.), awarded the plaintiffs
$25,000 in compensatory damages and enjoined the defendant from participating
in the management of the Candlelite and from
operating her real estate business on the premises of the Candlelite.
(1)
The master determined that the defendant's failure to *1020 transfer a
valid dissolution of the trade name Deep River Motor Inn on the date of the
plaintiffs' purchase did not warrant an award of damages or the granting of
equitable relief. We agree. The plaintiffs did not suffer damages
because, from the time they took possession of the property until the time the
trade name was registered in their names, the plaintiffs had full use of the
name Deep River Motor Inn. Therefore,
without an award of damages, the plaintiffs are in the same position they would
have been in if the defendant had fully performed on the purchase date. See Emery v. Caledonia Sand and Gravel Co.,
117 N.H. 441, 447, 374 A.2d 929, 933 **306 (1977) (quoting C. McCormick,
Law of Damages s 137, at 560-61 (1935)).
(2)(3) The master ordered the defendant to convey to
the plaintiffs the twenty-nine acres of unimproved land described in the option
agreement. "We have held that a
decree for specific relief is not a matter of right but rests in the sound
discretion of the court according to the circumstances of the case." Johnson v. Korsak, Inc., 120 N.H. 412, 415,
415 A.2d 1141, 1143 (1980); Carle's Motorcycle Shop, Inc. v. Johnson, 113 N.H.
77, 79, 301 A.2d 335, 336 (1973) (citations omitted). An equitable remedy should be imposed in situations involving
real estate, absent evidence that the remedy is impossible or inequitable.
Johnson v. Korsak, Inc., 120 N.H. at 415, 415 A.2d at 1143. The master, therefore, did not abuse his
discretion in ordering the defendant to convey the twenty-nine acres to the
plaintiffs under the option agreement.
See Belrose v. Baker, 121 N.H. 48, 51, 426 A.2d 454, 456 (1981).
(4)(5) The master ordered that the plaintiffs' option
agreement payments for the purchase of twenty-nine acres of unimproved land be
extended over a ten-year period. The master
did not explain why he ordered a ten-year payment period instead of the
three-year period provided in the option instrument itself. We cannot agree with the master's
order. Absent an ambiguity and evidence
of the parties' intent to integrate a new term into the agreement, we must
effectuate the parties' intent at the time the contract was made. See Erin Food Servs., Inc. v. 688 Props.,
119 N.H. 232, 235, 401 A.2d 201, 203 (1979); Thiem v. Thomas, 119 N.H. 598,
603, 406 A.2d 115, 118 (1979). Because the option instrument is the only
evidence of the parties' intent in this case, the option agreement must be
enforced as it is written, and the plaintiffs must adhere to the three-year
payment period.
The master further ordered
that the defendant be enjoined from operating her real estate business under
the name Deep River Realty on the premises of the Candlelite. Reading the provisions of *1021 the
purchase and sale agreement together, he concluded that the parties intended
that the defendant not be allowed to use the name Deep River at the site of a
competingmotel. We agree.
(6)(7)
The defendant concedes that she agreed to use the trade name only for her real
estate business. The purchase and sale
agreement, when read in its totality, indicates that the defendant violated the
parties' contract by operating a real estate business at the Candlelite. See 93 Clearing House, Inc. v. Khoury, 120
N.H. 346, 350-51, 415 A.2d 671, 675 (1980); Bellak v. Franconia College, 118
N.H. 313, 316, 386 A.2d 1266, 1268 (1978).
A contract must be interpreted in a way best assimilating the parties'
intent. See MacLeod v. Chalet Susse
Int'l, Inc., 119 N.H. 238, 243, 401 A.2d 205, 208- 09 (1979) (quoting Rogers v.
Cardinal Realty, Inc., 115 N.H. 285, 286, 339 A.2d 23, 25 (1975)) (citations
omitted); Erin Food Servs., Inc. v. 688 Props., 119 N.H. at 235, 401 A.2d at 203. By using the name Deep River Realty on the
premises of the Candlelite, the defendant created a substantial likelihood that
the public would be confused between the real estate business and the Deep
River Motor Inn and between the Candlelite and the Deep River Motor Inn. See generally, Fisher Stoves, Inc. v. All
Nighter Stove Works, 626 F.2d 193, 194 (1st Cir. 1980). Although they agreed to allow the defendant
to use the name Deep River Realty, the plaintiffs did not contemplate a use
that would create confusion in the minds of the public as to the distinction
between their motel and the Candlelite.
Having found that the
defendant had "violated the spirit and intent of a binding contractual
provision not to compete," the master enjoined the defendant from participating in the management
or operation of the Candlelite and from being present at the Candlelite as long
as its ownership remained in her husband or other members of her family.
(8)
The defendant concedes the existence of an agreement not to compete. The terms of the agreement, as set forth in
the purchase and sale contract, are reasonable **307 and
enforceable. See Dunfey Realty Co. v.
Enwright, 101 N.H. 195, 197-98, 138 A.2d 80, 83 (1957). The defendant argues, however, that she has
not breached the agreement not to compete.
We disagree. The weight and
credibility of the evidence is a matter for the trier of fact. 93 Clearing House, Inc. v. Khoury, 120 N.H.
at 350, 415 A.2d at 674. There is
sufficient evidence in the record to support the master's finding that the
defendant participated in some aspects of the management of the Candlelite. See
Hynes v. Whitehouse, 120 N.H. 417, 421, 415 A.2d 876, 878 (1980).
*1022 The agreement
not to compete states that the defendant shall not "compete with the Buyers ... either as owner ... or
otherwise." (Emphasis added.) This
court interpreted similar language in Moore v. Dover Veterinary Hospital, Inc.,
116 N.H. 680, 367 A.2d 1044 (1976). In
Moore, the defendant had agreed not to compete as a dentist either
"directly or indirectly." Id.
at 683, 367 A.2d at 1047. This court
held that, although the agreement did not expressly prohibit the defendant from
practicing dentistry under a corporate name, his attempt to do so violated the
covenant not to compete. Id. at 686, 367 A.2d at 1049. The defendant's actions in this case
likewise violated the agreement not to compete even though the defendant is not
the owner of the competing business.
(9)(10) The master ordered that the parties'
five-year covenant not to compete be extended by twenty-three (23) months which
represented the amount of the time between the defendant's breach of the
covenant on March 13, 1978, and the master's order on February 15, 1980. We cannot agree with the master's extension
of the time limitation of covenant not to compete. Absent ambiguity as to the duration of the agreement or evidence
of the parties' intent to extend the agreement, a court cannot change the
express terms of a covenant. See Erin Food Servs., Inc. v. 688 Props., 119 N.H.
at 235, 401 A.2d at 204; Thiem v. Thomas, 119 N.H. at 603, 406 A.2d at
118. Furthermore, covenants not to
compete are generally narrowly construed and cannot be extended past the "
'fair and natural import of the language used.' " Moore v. Dover
Veterinary Hospital, Inc., 116 N.H. at 686, 367 A.2d at 1048 (quoting Bowers v.
Whittle, 63 N.H. 147, 148 (1884)). The
master had the power to award compensatory damages resulting from the defendant's
twenty-three (23) month breach of the covenant not to compete, but he chose
instead to reform the agreement not to compete by extending the original
five-year limitation. Although we order that the extension of the covenant be
vacated, we remand to the master for a redetermination of the damages, if any,
for the period of the breach.
(11)
The master awarded $25,000 in compensatory damages to the plaintiffs. Because injunctive relief was ordered as a
permanent remedy for the breach of the covenant not to compete, and the
extension of the covenant was ordered to remedy the partial breach of the
covenant not to compete from March 1978 to February 1980, the monetary award must
represent the following breaches: the failure by the defendant to deliver 144
sheets; the failure by the defendant to perform certain repairs; and the
failure by the defendant to give adequate notice of her termination of the *1023
tenancy. Even viewing the award in the
light most favorable to the prevailing party, 93 Clearing House, Inc. v.
Khoury, 120 N.H. at 350, 415 A.2d at 674, on the record before us we find that
$25,000 is excessive unless the injunction enforcing the covenant not to
compete is removed and award of $25,000 thereby includes damages for the
permanent breach of the covenant not to compete.
Additionally, any award of
damages to the plaintiffs must be reduced by the amounts the plaintiffs owe the
defendant. The defendant proved with
sufficient specificity that the plaintiffs owe money on certain utility and
fuel bills. See Progressive Survey, Inc. v. Pearson, 120 N.H. 58, 60, 410 A.2d
1123, 1125 (1980); Grant v. Town of Newton, 117 N.H. 159, 162, 370 A.2d 285,
287 (1977). If the defendant has
sustained damages as a result of the plaintiffs' failure to pay these bills,
the award to the plaintiffs should reflect those damages.
**308 We remand to
the trial court and order, in the alternative, either that the damages be
reduced to reflect only those breaches not remedied by injunctive relief or
that the damages be allowed to stand, but the injunction enforcing the covenant
not to compete be removed. Under either
alternative, the damages awarded to the plaintiffs may include an amount proved
to represent the breach of the covenant not to compete up to this date. Also, under either alternative, the award of
damages to the plaintiffs must be reduced by the amount of damages proved by
the defendant.
Affirmed in part; reversed
in part; remanded.
BATCHELDER, J., did not
sit; the others concurred.
N.H., 1981.
437 A.2d 302, 121 N.H. 1016
END OF DOCUMENT