VALUATION OF INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY

 

            IPSI - SUMMER 2000

 

 

 

Gordon V. Smith

AUS Consultants

Moorestown, New Jersey 08057

(856) 234-1199 – Telephone

(856) 273-9710 – Fax Machine

gsmith@ausinc.com

 

Friday and Saturday: 11:00 a.m. - 1:30 p.m.

 

 

Course Overview:

 

Intellectual property is an increasingly important asset in the modern economy.  Recent examples of infringement litigation resulting in multi-million dollar awards have only served to further emphasize this observation.  Today’s successful attorney, whether engaged solely in an intellectual property practice or a general business practice, must be able to assist in the identification, preservation and use of valuable knowledge and information assets.  One important skill the attorney needs to help meet these objectives is an ability to understand the basics of intellectual property valuation.

 

This course can be divided into three basic parts.  First, we will examine the fundamental concepts of accounting and valuation and how they apply to intellectual property assets.  Next, we will examine how damages are calculated in infringement cases and how to work with a valuation expert.  And finally, we will briefly explore how valuation of IP assets is used in the increasingly important areas of taxation, financing and bankruptcy.

 

PLEASE NOTE that there is an assignment to be completed BEFORE the first class session.

 

 

How You Will be Graded:

 

There are three components to the grade: a final examination, some valuation problems that will be assigned during the course, and class contribution.  I believe that pre-class preparation and in-class participation by each student is one of the best learning methods, therefore I have tried to design the course to encourage and reward such behavior.  Given the class size it is unlikely that each of you will have an opportunity to participate in every class, but this does not mean that you should not come prepared to contribute to each class discussion and be able to respond when called upon.  Your class contribution (positive or negative) may be used to increase or decrease your final grade by one-half grade.  Please remember, the amount of “air-time” is less important than the quality of any contribution.  You should be aware that the reading assignments are of various lengths and you will need to adjust your preparation time to reflect these differences.

 

 

Valuation Problems 25%

Class Contribution.. +/-

Examination       75%

    100%

 


INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY

VALUATION AND FINANCE

 

 

JUNE 2, 2000

 

PRE-CLASS ASSIGNMENT

 

            Peruse the Annual Report of Procter & Gamble Company.

 

TOPICS

Introduction

Overview of the Course

Why Valuations Are Necessary

Importance of IP Assets

Intangible Assets and Intellectual Property Defined

The Business Enterprise and the Assets that Comprise It

 

READING ASSIGNMENT

 

1-41       Valuation of Intellectual Property and Intangible Assets, Smith & Parr, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, 3rd Edition, 2000, pp. 15-54 (Intangibles and IP) (39)

 

42-51 Valuation, pp. 55-63 (Business Enterprise) (8)

 

52-62    Valuing Intangible Assets, Reilly & Schweihs, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1998, Chapter 2, pp. 29-38 (9)

 

 

OVERVIEW OF THE COURSE

 

         “The Problem” – P&G’s business enterprise value its book value

Intangible Assets & Intellectual Property

Accounting Principles

Valuation Theory & Practice

Tax, Litigation & Finance

Working With a Valuation Expert

 

 

WHY VALUATIONS ARE NECESSARY

 

Transaction Support

Buyer Considerations

What should I pay?

Seller Considerations

What should I ask?

               Why do these questions arise?

                     IP is in its embryonic, formative stage

                        Mode of exploitation is questionable

                     Is there justification for additional capital investment?

                        Can outside capital be attracted?

Fair Market Value vs. Fair Market Royalty


Litigation Support

Business Damages

Infringement Damages

Injunctions

Stockholder Suits

Malpractice Suits

 

Regulatory Requirements

SEC/IPO

Fairness Opinions

Solvency Opinion - Fraudulent Conveyance

Shareholder Rights

Rate-Setting

 

Accounting Requirements

Allocation of Purchase Price

Purchased R&D

Economic Remaining Life Analysis

Net Realizable Value

Balance Sheet Cosmetics

 

Income Taxes

Federal Income

Allocation of Purchase Price

Transfer Pricing

Holding Companies

 

State Taxes

Holding Companies

Transfer Pricing?

 

Estate Taxes

Closely-Held Stock

Intellectual Property

 

Gift Taxes

Closely-Held Stock

 

Ad Valorem Taxes

Intangible Assets/Intellectual Property

 

Financial

Collateral

Bankruptcy

 

IMPORTANCE OF IP ASSETS

Less dependence on “bricks and mortar”

Large segments of world business depends on it (e.g., Microsoft, Intel, Disney, Coca-Cola)


 

INTANGIBLE ASSETS AND INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY DEFINED

Rights

Contractual – receiving, providing

Relationships

Non-Contractual

Intellectual Property

Undefined

Goodwill

Elements of a Going Concern

 

 

THE BUSINESS ENTERPRISE AND THE ASSETS THAT COMPRISE IT

Business Enterprise

Business Value Equation

Specific Elements of the Business Enterprise

Monetary Assets

Tangible Assets

Intangible Assets

Business Asset Characteristics 

Important Characteristics of Risk, Financing, and Liquidity

Monetary Assets

Tangible Assets

Intangible Assets

      The Balance Sheet View

Valuation Balance Sheet

 

      The Critical Relationship of the Business Enterprise and its Underlying Assets


JUNE 3, 2000

 

TOPICS

Basic Accounting Concepts

Financial Analysis

Assignment: Analysis of Merck

 

READING ASSIGNMENT

 

63-72      Accounting Principles, Weygandt, Kieso & Kimmel, John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1999, pp.

                    23-30  (B/S I/S Glossary)

 

73-77      Accounting Principles, pp. 441-444 (Intangibles)

 

78-97      Accounting Principles, pp. 516-534 (Principles)

 

98-122    Accounting Principles, pp. 820-843 (Financial Statement Analysis)

 

123-166   Procter & Gamble 1999 Annual Report (44)

 

167-206 The Valuation of Technology, F. Peter Boer, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, 1999, pp. 45-83 (Accounting) (38)

 

BASIC ACCOUNTING CONCEPTS

Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (“GAAP”)

FASB -            Financial Accounting Standards Board

SFAS - Statement of Financial Accounting Standards

APB -          Accounting Principles Board

APB  - Opinions

AICPA -         American Institute of CPA’s

SAP -          Statements of Position

GAP -   Gordon’s Accounting Principles

 

Accounting for Public Companies

Investors/Lenders/Regulators

Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”)

Managed for Short-Term Profits and Minimum Taxes

 

Accounting for Private Companies (“closely-held”)

Private Owners Do This to Save Money and Minimize New Investment

Records - None Except Tax Returns

Managed for Maximum Cash Flow and Minimum Taxes

 

Accounting Statements

Prepared by company, checked by auditor

Auditor performs an attest function, or an independent check of management’s reporting

Includes a generous portion of judgement

Use P&G examples

Timing is important

Not always audited

May be exceptions

 

Balance Sheet

“A Snapshot of Past Transactions Accumulated Over Time”


                        Assets

Current Assets

Cash, investments (“cash equivalents”)

Accounts receivable

                              Inventory

Raw material

Work in process

Finished goods

 

                        Deferred Taxes, prepaid expenses

                        How the Value of the Elements Can Vary

                              Investments realizable?

                              Receivables collectible?

                              Inventory good?

SS pipe

                                       Paint brushes

                                          Finished goods in China

                              Usually not too bad to use book value = real value – will be conservative.

 

Plant, Property & Equipment

Its Elements

Land

Land improvements

Buildings

Leasehold Improvements

Machinery and Equipment

Vehicles

Reserves

Depreciation = Capital Recovery ¹ Loss in Value

How the Value of the Elements Can Vary

Goodwill & Other Intangibles

Accounting rules

Amortization (up to 40 years)

 

                  Liabilities

                  Current Liabilities

                        Accounts payable, accrued liabilities, taxes payable, debt due within one year

Long-Term Debt

Deferred income taxes, other non-current liabilities

Common Equity (Shareholders’ Equity)

 

               Tax Balance Sheet

PP&E differences

Intangibles

 

Income Statement

“A Period’s-Worth of Transactions

Revenues

Characteristics of¼

Sources

Volatility

Cost of Goods Sold

Characteristics of...

Sources

Volatility


Operating Expenses

Characteristics of...

Sources

Volatility

Selling, General & Administrative Expenses

Characteristics of...

Sources

Volatility

Interest

Other income

Taxes

Net Income

 

Concept of Timing

Accruals

Depreciation

Amortization

Reserves (financial)

 

Statement of Cash Flows

Definition of Cash Flow

Net income

+ Non-cash expenses

+ New debt incurred

+ Net equity sold

Gross Cash Flow

- Capital expenditures

- Debt repayment

- Dividends paid

Net Cash Flow

Importance - (“Happiness is positive cash flow”)

Importance of Cash Flow in Valuation

 

International Accounting Issues

Must know there are differences

Accounting for goodwill, research and development

 

Relationship of Accounting Amounts and Value

Accounting as a Closed System of Recording Transactions

Valuation Measures the Economic Results of Those Transactions

 

Accounting Issues Related to IP

U.K. Controversy

New SEC Considerations

International Accounting Harmonization

 

FINANCIAL ANALYSIS

 

Measures the Results of Fund Commitments

Internally-generated

Debt/Equity

 

         Principle Analysis Tools

                  Comparative financial statements – track year to year changes

                  Trends in the form of index numbers

                  Common-size financial statements

               Ratio analysis

                  Specialized analyses

 

Key Ratios

Short-term Liquidity

      Current ratio

      “Acid test” ratio

      Inventory turnover

Capital structure – long-term solvency

      Debt to equity ratio

      Interest coverage

Return on Investment

      Return on total assets

      Return on equity

Operating performance

      Gross margin ratio

      Net income to sales ratio

Asset Utilization

      Sales to accounts receivable

      Sales to inventories

      Sales to fixed assets

Market Measures

      Price-earnings ratio

      Earnings yield

      Dividend yield

      Dividend payout ratio

Growth Rates

      Sales

      Net income

      Cash flow

 

“Follow the Dollars”

 

Comparables and Benchmarks

Comparability - Commensurate Risks

Surrogates

 

DISCUSSION OF CLASS ASSIGNMENT


JUNE 9, 1999

 

TOPICS

Basic Valuation Concepts

Introduction to Valuation Methods

 

CLASS PROBLEM – READING

 

207-270 Merck Annual Report 1997 (55)

 

271-272  Standard & Poor’s 500 Industrials, Composite Financials (2)

 

273-277  Standard & Poor’s Stock Reports – Merck & Co. (5)

 

 

READING ASSIGNMENT

 

278-298    Damodaran on Valuation, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 1994, pp. 319-339 (Options Theory) (30)

 

299-325    Damodaran on Valuation, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 1994, pp. 340-365 (Options in Valuation) (30)

 

326-349 Valuation, pp. 151-174 (Principles) (23)

 

350-400 Valuing Intangible Assets, Chapters 19, 21, 23, 24 (43)

 

 

HAND IN ASSIGNMENT

 

DISCUSSION OF ASSIGNMENT

         Description of the business

         Calculation of financial ratios

 

BASIC VALUATION CONCEPTS

Premise of Value

Cost of Reproduction New

Cost of Replacement

Book Value

Tax Basis

Fair Market Value

 

Valuation

Valuation of the Business Enterprise

Valuation of the Assets of the Business Enterprise

“Break-Up Values”

 

INTRODUCTION TO VALUATION METHODS

Valuation Methods

Three Commonly Accepted Methods

Cost Approach

Market Approach

Income Approach


 

Cost Approach

Ingredients - General Theory

The Difficulties of Obsolescence

Cost Approach Applied to Intellectual Property (e.g. software)

Cost Approach Cautions

 

Market Approach

Ingredients

The Market Approach as a Check

The Market Approach as a Measure of Economic Obsolescence

Market Approach for Intangibles

 

Income Approach

Ingredients

Income Capitalization Theory & Mathematics

Present Value Concepts

 


JUNE 10, 2000

 

 

TOPICS

Valuation Methods (continued)

 

 

READING ASSIGNMENT

 

401-436 Valuation, pp. 215-224, 257-271, 297-306 (Income Cap.) (32)

 

437-461 Valuation of Technology, pp. 291-313 (Decision Treas & Options) (22)

 

462-474   Damodaran on Valuation, op. cit., pp. 20-42 (Discount Rates) (21)

 

475-487    Cost of Capital, Shannon P. Pratt, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, 1998, pp. 3-14 (11)

                 (Cost of Capital)

 

 

DISCOUNTED CASH FLOW ANALYSIS

 

A TRADEMARK VALUATION

Class Exercise

 

INCOME APPROACH – PULLING IT ALL TOGETHER

         Class Exercise – Valuation of Merck

               Merck business enterprise

               Merck monetary, tangible and intangible assets

               Merck intangibles – workforce, trademarks, computer software, patents

                        Illustrate how to make them “fit”

 

 


JUNE 16, 2000

 

TOPICS

Royalty Rates and Licensing

Litigation Damages

 

READING ASSIGNMENT

 

488-504         Valuation, pp. 333-348 (Royalties) (15)

 

505-530                   Trademark Valuation, Gordon V. Smith, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 1997, Chapter 7

                   (Trademark Royalties), pp. 159-183 (24)

 

531-543                   Trademark Valuation, Gordon V. Smith, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 1997, Chapter 8, pp. 189-200

                   (Monetary Relief) (11)

 

544-571                   Intellectual Property Infringement Damages, 2nd Edition, Russell L. Parr, John Wiley & Sons,

                   Inc., 1999, pp. 75-101 (Incremental Profits) (26)

 

572-586                   Intellectual Property Infringement Damages, 2nd Edition, Russell L. Parr, John Wiley & Sons,

                   Inc., 1999, pp. 105-119 (Georgia-Pacific) (14)

 

 

Be Prepared to Discuss How the Court Dealt with Damages in This Patent Case:

 

587-618           Georgia-Pacific Corporation v. United States Plywood Corporation, 318 F. Supp. 116 (1970) (31)

 

 

Be Prepared to Discuss How the Court Dealt with Damages in This Trademark  Case:

 

619-624           Zazu Designs, a Partnership v. Loral, S.A., 979 F. 2d 499 (1992) (5)

 

 

 

Optional Reading:

 

Valuation, pp. 96-112 (Tax Issues) (16)

 

Federal Income Taxation of IP Transfers, FitzGibbon and Long, XXVIII Res Gestae 362 (1985) (9)

 

Geoffrey, Inc. v. South Carolina Tax Commission, 437 S.E. 2d 13 (1993, cert. denied) (5)

 

“State and Local Taxation of Intangibles Generates Increasing Controversy,” Walter Hellerstein, 80 Journal of Taxation, 296 (1994) (10)

 

“Valuation of Intangible Assets for Bankruptcy and Reorganization Purposes,” Robert F. Reilly, American Bank Institute Journal, January 1994 (3)

 

Trademark Valuation, Gordon V. Smith, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 1997, pp. 215-226 (Special Situations) (11)

 

 


 

THE LICENSING TRANSACTION

 

ROYALTIES

Defined

Estimating

Use of Present Value Principles

Cost Approach

Market Approach

Income Approach

Discounted Cash Flow

 

LITIGATION DAMAGES

Patent

Trademark


JUNE 17, 2000

 

TOPICS

Taxation of IP

Less Common Valuations

Finding, Selecting, and Working With a Valuation Expert

Case Studies

 

 

READING ASSIGNMENT

 

Review: 

 

625-657             Corporate Valuation: A Business and Professional Guide, Gordon V. Smith, John Wiley & Sons,

                   Inc., 1988, pp. 175-206 (Appraisal Report) (31)

 

658-674       Valuation, pp. 96-112 (Tax Issues) (16)

 

 

To Be Reviewed in Class:

 

675-684       Connecticut Yankee Atomic Power Company v. Town of Haddam  (10)

 

685-737       Barnes Family v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue (USTC), transcript of expert witness cross examination

 

738-758    Long Island Lighting Company v. The Assessor and The Board Assessment for the Town of Brookhaven (21)

 

 

Optional Reading:

 

“Valuing a Business,” Pratt, Chapter 32, pp. 761-781 (20)

 

“Security Interests in Intellectual Property: A Unified System of Perfection,” Lisa M. Vaccaro, 6 Hofstra Prop. L. Journal 215, 1993

 

“Creating and Perfecting Security Interests in Intellectual Property,” Thomas M. Ward, Maine Bar Journal, May 1994

 

“Intellectual Property as Security or Collateral,” Maureen C. Kassner C 602 ALI-ABA 327, April 11, 1991

 

“Insurance Coverage for Intellectual Property Disputes: Analysis of Recent Developments,” Jordan S.  Stanzler, 10 No. 6 Computer Law 23, 1993 (10)

 

 

TAXATION OF INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY

Transfer Pricing

Capital Gains

Royalties

 

LESS COMMON VALUATIONS

Bankruptcy

Fraudulent Conveyance

Collateral

 

THE VALUATION ENGAGEMENT

Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (“USPAP”)

Ethical Standards

Minimum Work Standards

Client Relationship

Minimum Reporting Standards

 

Investigation/Data Gathering

 

Analysis

Exogenous Data

Calculations

Correlation

 

Report Writing

Elements of a Report

As of Date

Property Description

Appraisal Purpose

Premise of Value

Information Relied Upon

Valuation Methods Used and Not Used

Full Exposition of Facts Relied Upon

Full Exposition of Analysis/Calculations

Logical Progression to Conclusion

Appraiser Qualifications

Draft for Factual Review

Final With Limiting Conditions, Qualifications

 

 


 

FINDING, SELECTING AND WORKING WITH A VALUATION EXPERT

 

Finding an Appraiser/Witness

 

Interviewing a Potential Appraiser/Witness

 

Engaging a Potential Appraiser/Witness

Do You Want (Need) Two Appraisers?

Pros and Cons of This Approach

How to Structure It

 

Establishing an “Early Warning System”

 

Who is the Client?

 

Confidentiality Agreements

 

Financial Arrangements

 

Monitoring the Engagement

 

Advocacy

 

How Much Room is There Really?

 

Where are the Likely Soft Spots?

 

 

CASE STUDIES – DISCUSSION

 

Connecticut Yankee Atomic Power Company v. Town of Haddam

 

Barnes Family v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue (USTC), transcript of expert witness cross examination

 

Long Island Lighting Company v. The Assessor and The Board of Assessment for the Town of Brookhaven