Drawings and documents
Published accounts: journal notice
Notice in the monthly list of patents, with remarks
Journal of the Franklin Institute, new ser., vol. 4 (1829), p. 279 · View the page
The Corresponding Secretary, Dr. Hays, communicated to the meeting letters from J. G. V. De Moléon, Chief Engineer of the Domains of France; from the Franklin Institute of Rochester, New York; from the Maclurian Lyceum of Science of Philadelphia; and two from the American Institute of New York. W. R. Johnson submitted for examination two modifications of apparatus for igniting spongy platina, by hydrogen gas, on which apparatus some observations were offered. 1 Franklin Institute Monthly Meetings. The following queries were submitted for discussion, which were read, and laid on the table, viz. 1st. What is the best construction of Barker's mill, and what its maximum effect? 2nd. What is the true mode of computing the power of high pressure steam engines? 3d. What is the proper height of a carriage wheel, with an axis of a given diameter, in order to be most efficacious in aiding the draught of horses in transportation? 4th. What is the absolute centrifugal force of a body revolving in a circle of a given diameter d, with a given velocity v? 5th. What is the rationale of the action of hydrogen gas on spongy platina, as discovered by Doëbereiner? 6th. Which will move down an inclined plane with the greatest velocity, a wheel of two, or one of four feet in diameter, supposing their weights the same, and the matter of each to be all disposed around in its periphery? (Extract from the Minutes.) W. HAMILTON, Secretary, pro tem. S. J. ROBBINS, Chairman. TO THE FRANKLIN INSTITUTE. The following is submitted as an answer to some of the questions formerly proposed for discussion. August 17th, 1829.
Remarks. Very respectfully, CHARLES POTTS. Quest. What shaped aperture will deliver the greatest quantity of water in a given time and under a given head? The obvious extent and importance of this question, has called forward many of the most celebrated philosophers and mathematicians to its investigation. Numerous and diversified experiments have been instituted, from some of which I shall endeavour to select such practical results as have been obtained, and which seem most likely to answer to the conditions of the question. In the discharge of water through simple apertures, either in the sides or bottom of a reservoir, it is evident that with respect to the resistance which tends to diminish the full or natural discharge, we can have very little doubt whether the shape of the aperture ought, in order to present the least rubbing surface, to be square, triangular, or otherwise, since we know that of all equal areas, the circle has the least peremiter or circumference. Hence, if we suppose the water to be discharged through an orifice made in a thin plate, that discharge will be the greatest when the aperture has a circular form. The experiments of Bossut confirm this conclusion in a very satisfactory manner. Answer to Query on Adjutages. This might be submitted as a full answer to the question, were we to limit it to the phraseology of its expression: but as I conceive not only apertures, but also such contrivances as are denominated adjutages, from their property of promoting the discharge of water, to be implied in the question, I shall extend the inquiry on this construction. Newton first noticed that running water delivered through apertures did not preserve an equal section, but that the column after leaving the aperture gradually decreased in thickness for a distance about equal to the diameter of the orifice, after which it increased. This contraction of the effluent stream, which is evidently owing to the filaments of water in the reservoir being drawn towards the aperture by forces acting in different directions, is what demands particular attention, inasmuch as the proper shape of the adjutage called for in the proposition is found to depend upon it. One of the primary objects in the experimental researches of Bossut and Michellotti, was to determine the different effects of this contraction under different circumstances. Michellotti, after carefully examining the form which the water naturally assumed in its effluent state, determined the figure or shape of that part of the natural jet between the vena contracta and the reservoir, to be that formed by the revolution of the trochoid (cycloid) around the axis of the jet, with dimensions having the following ratio. Diameter of the outer orifice (vena contracta) Do. inner Length of the axis 36. = 46. = 96. The effect of this adjutage was such as to give a discharge of 983 when the natural discharge would have been 1000. According to the results deduced by Eytelwein, a conical tube approaching to the figure of the contracted vein produced a discharge equal to .98 of the full velocity, which agrees in a striking manner with the preceding. With the view of showing more fully the effect of short tubes on the discharge of water, and also of drawing a comparison with the above mentioned adjutage, I shall quote the results of several experiments instituted by professor Venturi on this head. These experiments are considered highly important in practical hydraulics. The same quantity of water, 4.845 English cubic feet, flowed out of the same vessel, which was kept constantly full, through the following adjutages, in the time annexed, which is expressed in seconds. The altitude of the water above the centre of the aperture of the adjutage was always equal to 34.642 English inches. Through a simple circular aperture, Fig. 1, in a thin plate, diameter = 1.6 inches, in 41." Fig. 1. VOL. IV. No. 4.-OCTOBER, 1829. 36 Answer to Query on Adjutages Fig. 2. Through a cylindrical tube, Fig. 2, diameter as above, and 4.8 inches long, in 31." Fig. 3. Through the tube, Fig. 3, which differs from the preceding in being contracted in the middle, in 31." 1 Through the short conical adjutage, Fig. 4, which is only the first part of the preceding, in 42." Through the pipe, Fig. 5, which consists of a cylindrical tube adapted to the small end of the above, and of the same diameter, AD being 3.2 inches long, in 42.5." Through a like adjutage, but longer, AD being 12.8 inches, in 45." Through the like, AD being 25.6 inches, in 48." Through an adjutage, Fig. 6, consisting of the simple tube, Fig. 2, placed over the conical part of Fig. 4, in ۱ $2.5." Through the double cone, Fig. 7, the dimensions of which AB = EF = 1.6 inches, AC = 0.977 inches, CD 1.376 inches, and the length of outer cone = 4.351 inches, in 27.5."B = Through the adjutage, Fig. 8, consisting of a cylindrical tube 3.2 inches long and 1.376 inches in diameter interposed between the two conical parts of the preceding, in 28.5." Fig. 4. Fig. 5. AD Fig. 6. Fig. 7. C D Fig. 8. E F From these experiments, it appears that the effect of the double coned adjutage, Fig. 6, which was the best in these experiments, was Answer to Query on Crank, &c. such as to increase the discharge through the simple circular aperture about one-third. This adjutage, however, does not equal that found by Michellotti. For, we have the time in which the quantity of water answering to this case would have been discharged by theory equal 25.5." Hence, the effect of this adjutage gives a discharge of only .92 of the full velocity, whereas that found by Michellotti, as has been observed, is .983. From the experiments of Venturi, we further observed that the velocity of the water through a simple conical adjutage was considerably augmented by the addition of another similar tube; hence the inquiry might be suggested, whether the adjutage as determined by Michellotti, might not be improved by the addition of a small tube beyond the vena contracta. This question, however, and many others appertaining to this subject, I have no doubt will shortly be satisfactorily solved by this Institute. Quest. Will a double velocity of water, when the quantity is given, produce more than a double effect? This question is easily answered in the negative; for it is evident that as the momentum or effect is as the quantity of water and its velocity directly; when the velocity is doubled the effect will be doubled only. This question is analogous to the one preceding, relating to the double impulse, which has already been answered by a member at the last meeting. Quest. Does the production of a rotary, from a rectiliner motion, by means of a crank, involve a loss of power? The simplicity of the crank, as the means of changing the rectilinear into that of a rotary motion, and vice versa, is much in its favour. It is, however, as will be shown in the sequel, an unprofitable servant, particularly when it is desirable to economize power. Suppose the rectilinear force to be directed towards the centre of the shaft whereon the crank is fixed, which is the most ordinary relation between the two motions; and, that the rectilinear force is transmitted to the crank by a connecting rod. It is evident that in the progress of motion, the connecting rod and crank form all possible angles with each other in the period of each revolution. Hence it must be obvious, from a well known law in mechanics, viz. "that the force or energy of action is as the sine of the angle of incidence," that the power which is transmitted to the crank must be extremely variable. Thus, when the crank and connecting rod are in the same right line, the rectilinear force has no tendency whatever to turn the crank; this occurs twice in every revolution, viz. when the crank is on the centres. When the crank, however, has made the least angle with the connecting rod, the force or energy begins to operate on the crank to turn it round, and to increase, as the angle formed by the crank and connecting rod decreases, until they make a right angle, or the connecting rod becomes a tangent to the crank's revolution, at which place the effective force transmitted to the crank becomes a maximum, or the greatest possible. But even here we may observe, when Answer to Query on Girders. the rectilinear force is applied as in the supposition, the whole of the energy is not transmitted to the crank (inasmuch as the direction of the rectilinear force does not fall perpendicular on the crank at the same moment) but approximates to it as the ratio between the lengths of the crank and connecting rod is increased. Hence the advantage of long connecting rods. With the view of exhibiting more clearly the variability of the force exerted by the crank, I shall assume the following proportions as existing between the parts of the engine. Length of the connecting rod equal 3, that of the crank equal. If, now, we represent the measure of the rectilinear force by unity, we shall have the effective force transmitted to the crank during the period of one revolution, as in the following table, commencing from that point when the connecting rod and crank form one extended right line. From this table, which is sufficiently accurate for the purpose of comparison, we have the average force transmitted to the crank equal to of the rectilinear force, hence it follows, that the production of a rotary from a rectilinear motion, by means of a crank, 62 involves a loss equal to of the power. TABLE. The angle made by con. rod and crank. Effective force of the crank. Decimals. When the crank has moved. Degrees. Deg. min. 0. 180. 00 .0000 10. 168. 20 .1736 20. 156. 40 .$420 30. 145. 14 .5000 40. 133. 51 .6428 50. 122. 40 .7660 60. 111. 42 .8660 70. 101. 00 .9396 80. 90. 33 .9848 80. 24' 90. 00 .9863 90. 80. 25 .9860 100. 70. 33 .9848 110. 61. 00 .9596 120. 51. 42 .8660 130. 42. 40 .7660 140. 33. 51 .6428 150. 25. 14 .5000 160. 16. 43 .3420 170. 8. 20 .1736 180. 0.00 .0000 Quest. Which is most advantageous in sustaining the floor of a room 24 feet wide; a girder consisting of a single piece of timber 15 inches in depth, or another composed of 2 pieces of the same length and width, one ten, and the other five inches in depth, laid one upon the other; and what is the relative advantage gained by each? The lateral strength of beams being to each other as the breadth and square of the depth, we have, by assuming the given breadth of the beams = b, and the depth of the largest beam = 15 inches = d; the relative strength of the single girder = bd; and the relative strength of the compound girder, which is equal to the sum of its parts, equal b× (d)² + b x (d), that is, equal to bd. Hence, if we put unity for the absolute strength of the single girder, we shall have the absolute strength of the compound girder equal : or, in other words, the single beam will be the strongest. Quest. What is the proper figure of a wall to resist the pressure of earth acting at an angle of 45 degrees? D B Let the wall be represented by the line ABC, in the adjoining figure. Put the perpendicular height of the wall BC = a. The variable abscissa BE = x, and its corresponding ordinate DE = y. Now the mean of the pressure on BE or x is at x; and the effect of the pressure at this point to overturn or break the wall at C, is as the number of particles (x) and the lever a --x. That is, the effect of the pressure at this point will be as (a - x) x. C The fluxion of the force, therefore, at this point, is adx - xdx. Hence the fluxion of the effect of all the forces on the line BE, will be (adx - xdx) x = axdx - xdx. Wherefore, by integrating, we shall have | axdx - xdx = ax2 x³. Therefore, when x = a, we have the whole effect to break the wall at C equal a³. Hence it follows that the effect of the pressure to break the wall is in the triplicate ratio of the height; that is, the effect at C, is to the effect at any other point E, as BCs to BE³. Now the strength of the wall to resist fracture in any point, as at E for instance, being as the square of the thickness DEº, it follows that the wall, in order to be equally strong throughout its height, must have ³ always proportional to y³. As this property is known to exist between the abscissa and ordinates of the semi-cubical parabola, this, therefore, is the proper figure (ADB) required by the question. With regard to the given angle at which the earth is supposed to act, we may observe that this tends only to affect the energy, and not the relation of the pressure throughout the height of the wall. FOR THE JOURNAL OF THE FRANKLIN INSTITUTE. Observations on the Force of Bodies in Motion, in reply to the remarks of J. P. E. upon that subject. Ат р. 212 of the last number of the Journal of the Franklin Institute, there is a communication signed J. P. E., intended as a Observations on the Force of Bodies in Motion. reply to some remarks in the preceding number, on the power of heavy bodies in motion, the writer of which commences with "Proposition 1st, if a double velocity in the same quantity of water gives a double force, then it will raise, when applied to mill wheels, double the weight to double the height, in the same time." If the writer intends, in the foregoing proposition, that when the float-boards of wheels are moving with a double velocity, and they be struck by the same quantity of water with a double force, the effect will be as stated, he is correct; but it does not follow that when the same quantity has struck with a double force, that it will have struck the floats with a double velocity; or, when it is known that one wheel is struck by the same quantity of water at velocity one, and another wheel be struck by the same quantity at velocity two, in a given time, it does not follow that the same number of particles will expend their force at the same instant on each wheel. Suppose a water wheel to be 10 feet in diameter, and containing 30 float-boards, to be propelled by a quantity of water, whose volume is 1 foot wide, 4 inches deep, and 30 feet long, moving on the wheel at velocity one, and that this will cause the wheel to make one turn in 20 seconds, and suppose some given section of this volume to act on the wheel at the same time, say 1 foot, then the wheel will be urged round by the force of one-thirtieth of the whole quantity of water throughout the whole time of the operation. Then, suppose another wheel 20 feet diameter, with 60 float-boards, to be propelled the same length of time, by the same quantity of water moving with velocity two, it is evident that the volume of water must be 60 feet long, 1 foot wide, and two inches deep, and that no greater length of this volume can act on the wheel at the same time, than in the first case, viz. one foot, which will be one section for each float-board, and a force equal to one-sixtieth part of the whole volume will act through the whole time, the result will not be changed by assuming a greater or less length of the volumes of water to act at the same time on both wheels, nor by using wheels of equal size. I therefore conclude, that when a particle of water strikes the float-board of a wheel with a double velocity, it impresses on it more than a double force. J. P. E. says, that "the following experiment, which is laid down in the books, I consider as direct proof, that the momentum of bodies is as their velocity, and not as the square of their velocity, as the writer above mentioned endeavours to prove. I took two balls of soft clay, one double the weight of the other, and hung them by strings of equal length, to a nail in the wall. I then drew them in opposite directions from the line of direction, the smallest to double the distance of the other, and let them fall towards each other; when they met, all motion ceased; proving that the double velocity of the smaller body, which it is known to acquire, in the present circumstances, exactly counterbalanced the double weight of the other body, with half the velocity." Here he leaves no room to doubt his meaning of the word momentum, as being synonymous with power; and, consequently, that a double velocity of water gives a double power, which leaves him in the dilemma, of having endeavoured to support that a double power of water will produce a quadruple effect, as he says a double velocity is known to do. Were it not for the above experiment, I should have supposed that he considered the question at issue to regard the simple forces of bodies in motion, without regard to their utmost power; this, however, cannot be the question, for the forces of bodies in motion do not exist, excepting when some resisting force opposes their motion. It is evident that the simple force of a body, whatever be the quantity of matter, or its velocity, when acting on another body, must always be equal to the force with which the latter body resists it, until the body in motion be stopped: for, if 100 lb. of matter, moving with any given velocity, strike one pound at rest, the simple force exerted must be equal to the inertia of the one pound; but if it had struck fifty pounds, the force would have been equal to the inertia of fifty pounds; and if the body at rest be unmoved by the collision, and it, as well as the moving body, were perfectly hard and perfectly non-elastic, then the force impressed would be exactly equal to the power of the moving body; but as we have no materials perfectly hard and non-elastic, the force impressed by collision can never equal the momentum of the moving body; hence the question at issue does not apply exclusively to simple forces. With respect to friction, J. P. E. says, "I performed a number of experiments in the presence of the gentleman whose opinions are here controverted, which I need not now detail, all showing that the spaces passed over by a body on a horizontal plane, when the body comes to rest, are as the squares of the velocity; that is, with a double velocity, a body will move four times as far, and with a triple velocity, nine times as far, &c. before it comes to rest."
Published accounts: journal notice
Notice in the monthly list of patents
Journal of the Franklin Institute, new ser., vol. 4 (1829), p. 338 · View the page
30. For manufacturing Felt for Cloth, Padding, Carpets, &c.; John Barker, Bridgwater, Oneida county, and Leonard Kinsley, Catskill, New York, August 25.
About this record
- Patentee
- Jim Shaw's X-patent list
- Date
- Jim Shaw's X-patent list
- Invention
- the Name and Date index of patents
- Listed in
- the Name and Date index of patents, Jim Shaw's X-patent list, the Journal of the Franklin Institute, Burke's List of Patents (1847)
- The sources give different dates; the date shown is the one most of them agree on.
- The Franklin Institute's journal gives a different date.
- Burke's 1847 Patent Office list gives the same patent.
- Residence from Burke's 1847 Patent Office list; the standard lists give none.