Drawings and documents
Published accounts: journal notice
Notice in the monthly list of patents, with remarks
Journal of the Franklin Institute, new ser., vol. 5 (1830), p. 303 · View the page
38. For an improvement in Hascalls's improved Grist Mill; William Coleman, Euclid, Cayahoga county, Ohio, February 25.
Remarks. This is another addition to the list of portable grist mills, which have become so numerous as to leave but little chance of any essential variation in their construction, and, consequently, to render it difficult for the patentee to tell in what the novelty of his invention consists; all the account we shall pretend to give of the present invention, is contained in the claim set up. "What I claim, is, the reducing the face of the running stone to a plain surface; (whereas Hascall's is cone shaped,) and the making nearly a plain surface to the bed, or standing stone; (whereas Hascall's is deeply concave) and for resting the running stone upon up the top of a convex spindle in a tapering mortise, by which the stone gains an undulatory motion, (whereas Hascall's is fixed firmly to the spindle, and has no other than a horizontal motion.) The stone may be hung upon a bail in the ordinary manner of hanging mill stones. I also claim the invention of a portable frame, by which the whole mill becomes portable, (whereas Hascall's is fixed to a certain spot.) And I also claim the right of applying 'Coleman's portable' mill to all the uses above mentioned." Mr. Coleman seems to think that every variation from Hascall's mill must be a novelty, and will, therefore, entitle him to the claim of an invention. Mr. Hascall made one stone conical, and adapted the other to it. Mr. Coleman brings them both back again to the ordinary form of the face of mill stones, and makes a claim. Mr. Hascall fixes his mill to the floor, or to the building, and Mr. Coleman differs from him, as many others have done, by allowing the frame work to be moveable, and claims to be an inventor. We think that an examination of the patent office, and of other sources of information upon such subjects, would have eventuated in convincing the patentee that portable grist mills, flat stones, and runners with an undulatory motion, were every day contrivances.
About this record
- Patentee
- DATAMP
- Date
- the Name and Date index of patents, DATAMP
- Invention
- DATAMP
- Listed in
- the Name and Date index of patents, DATAMP, Jim Shaw's X-patent list, the Journal of the Franklin Institute, Burke's List of Patents (1847)
- Burke's 1847 Patent Office list gives the same patent.