Drawings and documents
Published accounts: journal notice
Notice in the monthly list of patents, with remarks
Journal of the Franklin Institute, new ser., vol. 16 (1835), p. 242 · View the page
37. For Pannels for Carriages; Ebenezer Lester, city of Boston, March 18.
Remarks. (See the specification.)
Published accounts: journal notice
Notice in the monthly list of patents
Journal of the Franklin Institute, new ser., vol. 16 (1835), p. 263 · View the page
Remarks by the Editor. We have not heard any thing respecting this mill since the date of the patent, but at that period one of them was brought to Washington, and put into operation in the neighbourhood; we did not see it at work, but persons who did, and who are well acquainted with the manufacturing of meal, were surprised at the goodness and the quantity of the work performed by it, and were induced to speak highly of its merits, although much prejudiced against it previously to witnessing its operation. The disks, we think, did not exceed nine inches in diameter. Specification of a Patent for an improved mode of making, or preparing, the Pannels for Coaches, and other Wheeled Carriages. Granted to EBENEZER A. LESTER, Machinist, Boston, Massachusetts, March 18th, 1835.
Published accounts: specification
Specification printed in the Journal of the Franklin Institute
Journal of the Franklin Institute, new ser., vol. 16 (1835), p. 263 · View the page
Text of the specification as printed in the Journal, from OCR; not proofread.
Specification of a Patent for an improved mode of making, or preparing, the Pannels for Coaches, and other Wheeled Carriages. Granted to EBENEZER A. LESTER, Machinist, Boston, Massachusetts, March 18th, 1835. To all whom it may concern, be it known, that I, Ebenezer A. Lester, of the city of Boston, in the State of Massachusetts, have invented a new and improved mode of making, or preparing, the pannels for coaches, and other wheeled carriages, or vehicles, in which pannels are employed. And I do hereby declare that the following is a full and exact description of my said invention, or improvement. My improvement consists in making the pannels of metal, instead of wood; and for this purpose I prefer to use sheet iron, as combining lightness and strength, whilst it is less costly than most of the other metals. Sheets of zinc, copper, or other metal, or metallic alloy, may also be used. The frame for the insertion of the pannel may be grooved in the usual manner, and the pannel, properly raised and formed, inserted in these grooves when the frame is put together; the pannels are then to be painted and finished. I intend sometimes to finish such pannels by japanning them, as tea trays and other articles are japanned; and in this case it will be best, instead of grooving the frames, to form rebates therein, so that when the body of the carriage, or other vehicle, has been completely painted and varnished, the pannels can be put into the frames from within, and secured there by means of strips of wood, or metal, or in any other manner which may be found convenient. As, from the motion of a carriage, the pannels are subjected to a degree of friction which might remove the painting, or japanning, so that the edges of the metal would rust, or corrode, by the insinuation of moisture; to prevent this, I intend to insert into the groove, or rebate, some elastic material, such as India rubber, India rubber cloth, or any other substance which may answer this intention. I have thus described, in a manner sufficiently full to direct a competent workman, the nature of my said improvement, and the manner in which I intend to carry the same into effect; and I do hereby declare that what I claim as my invention, or improvement, is simply the making of the pannels of coaches, and other wheeled carriages, or vehicles, of metal, instead of wood, no other change being made in the formation of such carriages, excepting such as may be necessary to adapt the frame-work to such pannels. EBENEZER A. LESTER. Report to the Directors of the London and Birmingham Railway Company, accompanied by Experiments on the Transverse Strength, &c. of Malleable Iron, with reference to its use for Railway Bars. By PETER BARLOW, Prof. Royal Mil. Acad., Woolwich. (Concluded from p. 199.) Comparative Strength of differently formed Parallel Rails. Let A BCD (fig. p. 265) represent any rectangular rail with a bottom table; n n its neutral axis; c the centre of compression, cn being of hn. Now, the tension of each fibre being as its distance from the neutral axis, and that of the lower fibre being given equal tx d to t, the tension at any variable distance x will be (d being taken to denote the whole depth n s,) and therefore the sum of all the tensions will be t fx. x. d x (1) which, therefore, become known, x being taken within its proper limits, according to the figure of the section. But as the effective resistance of each fibre is also as its depth t below the line nn, the sum of all the resistances will be .dx (2) x being taken here also within its proper limits. And then to find the centre of tension, or that point into which, if all the tensions were collected, the whole resistance would be the same as in the acfx. d x tual case, this would be given by the formula, (3) which is fx. d x precisely the expression for the centre of oscillation of a disc of the same figure. We have hence the following general rule for finding the resistance or the weight which any given bar or rail will support at its middle point, within the limits of its elastic power, that is, Calling the integral of formula (1) = A Ditto ditto formula (2) = B formula (3) = D Ditto ditto And the distance cn = C then, referring the sum of all the resistances B to the common centre of compression, we have D:D + C :: B : B(D+C) which is the whole effect. D For those who understand the integral calculus, this solution is sufficient; but as this article will, probably, be consulted principally by practical men, it will be more convenient to give a specific solution for a rail, embracing under one general figure all the usual forms, the only variations being in the depth, breadth, and thickness, of the parts. The breadths Let ABCD represent such a section, of which all the dimensions are given, as also the position of nn the neutral axis, the point c which is the centre of compression, en being two-thirds of n h, and the point m which is in the centre of rs. nn and mm are also known. Then the resistance of the whole section referred to the common centre of compression c, may be considered to be made up of the three resistances. 1st. Of the middle rib, continued through the head and foot tables, vtzw. AvhwB n n x EN F G H m m m Cts2D 2nd. Of the head A EFB, minus the breadth of the centre rib. 3d. Of the lower web, GCDH, also minus the continuation of the centre rib. Now, t being taken to represent the tension of iron per square inch, just within its limits of elasticity, we shall have: 1. Resistance of v tzw = hs.ns.pq.t 2. Resistance of AE FB = hx.nx.(nn-pq) rs2 nx ns = ', and ' + cn = 8'', then t Now, let n m + 12 n m 8 3. Resistance of GCDH=nm.rs.(mm-pq)可 t These three resistances being computed, let their sum be called s, 4 s T and the clear bearing l; then = w, the load the bar ought to sustain at its middle point, for an indefinite time, without injury to its elasticity. Trapezoidal Rail. Produce the sloping sides till they intersect the neutral axis in p q. Then the rule for the head A EF B, and middle rib, vt zw, VOL. XVI.-No. 4. — ОстоBER, 1835. 34 A vhw B 7 ng E F CSD will be the same as given above; and for the two sides, p C t, q D z, the formula is, 1 3 (ns + cn) × (CD-pq) n s* t. The sum of this, with that of the head and middle rib, multiplied by 4, and divided by l, as before, will be the weight required. Another general and very curious mechanical method of finding the resistance of a railway bar, is also suggested by the remark in p. 264, viz : that the centre of tension is the same as the centre of oscillation of a disk of the form of the section, cut off at its neutral axis, which in words may be given as follows: Find the centre of oscillation, and the centre of gravity, of the area below the axis, by the usual mechanical methods, and call the distance of the former below the neutral axis o, that of the latter g, the area a, the depth d', and the distance cn = c, the tension t, and bearing l, as usual, then the weight the bar will support will be, W 4. (o+c) agt ld' The preceding rules, however, will be generally more convenient, particularly when some of the dimensions become fixed, as necessarily happens in such cases as we are considering. For instance, whatever figure may be given to the transverse section, the head may generally be supposed to occupy two-fifths of it; and, therefore in the larger rails, to have about two inches section, and to be one inch deep, that the lower web, when there is one, is the same depth as the head, and that the neutral line bisect the head, or upper table.f With these as fixed dimensions, the preceding formulæ, page 265, are reduceable to words at length. They apply, however, only to the larger rails; for other cases, it will be best to have recourse to the general rules. * This includes the small dotted part of the triangular sides in the head and in the sides, but the amount is so very inconsiderably in error, as to be nearly or wholly insensible in the result. † We have the means of computing the position of the neutral line by the data obtained from the experiments, p. 193, which show that in rectangular bars the area is divided in the ratio of 1 to 4, or the area into the distance of the centre of gravity of the two parts as 1 to 42. But in inquiries of this kind, the less we have to depend on theory the better. I have, therefore, deduced the above position from the experiments on actual railway bars, p. 270, by considering the distance n h as unknown, and equating the formula in this shape with the mean elastic strength, which is found to be 84 tons. The equation is, therefore, 1 3 {5 (5-х) 9+ 11. (1-x) 5 X 2 } = 84 × 33 4 Whence we find x = 47, which may be considered as .5, without sensible error. Resistance of the Head, or Upper Table. 1. Subtract the thickness of the middle rib from 2 inches, and multiply the remainder by 10. 2. Subtract half an inch from the whole depth, and multiply the remainder by 12. Then the former product, divided by the latter, will be the resistance in tons due to the head, not including the continuation of the middle rib. Resistance of the Centre Rib. Multiply the whole depth of the rail by the whole depth, minus half an inch, and that product by 10 times the thickness of the rib; and the last product divided by 3, will be the resistance in tons of the middle rib continued through the whole depth, i. e., through the upper and lower tables." Resistance of the Lower Web. 1. Multiply the whole depth of the rail, minus 1 inch, by the thickness of the bottom web, minus the thickness of the rib, and that product by 10. 2. From the whole depth of the rail subtract 1 inch, and to 12 times the square of the remainder add 6 times the remainder, and call this the first number. From this subtract twice the remainder, and add 1, and call this the second number. Then say, as the first number is to the second, so is the product obtained in the former part of the rule to the resistance of the lower web, not including the continuation of the middle rib. Lastly, the sum of these three resistances multiplied by 4, and divided by the clear bearing length, will be the weight the rail will sustain without injury. A few examples, worked at length, are given below, to illustrate the rules. Examples. (1) In Mr. Stephenson's rail the greatest depth is 5 inches, with a plain rib, whose thickness is .9 of an inch. Here, Resistance of Head (2-.9) × 10 = 11) 2 11 Ditto of Rib, = 2(5) × 12 = 54) 54 4 × 5 × 9 × 10 3 0.20 67.50 67.7 4 x 67.7 And 33 8.21 tons, the greatest weight. .22 4* X = .066 3 Deflection with this weight 4.5 * See pp. 122 and 196. (2) Parallel rail of the same depth and weight, viz: 50 lbs. per yard. Here the thickness of centre rib = .78. Hence, Resistance of Head (2-.78)×10=12.22 Ditto Rib, 4×5×.78×10 3 } Tons 12.2 54 0.225 58.500 58.725 4×58.725 And 33 7.11 tons, the greatest weight. .22 Deflection with this weight =.048 4.5 (3) Parallel rail with bottom web, the depth being still 5 inches, the thickness of the rib. 6 of an inch thickness, or breadth of section of lower web 1.32, the weight being 50 lbs. Resistance of Head, (2--.6)×10=14) 14 Tons (5)×12=54) 0.26 54 4×5×.6×10 45.00 3 Ditto of Rib, Lower Web, (5--1×.72×10=28.8 12(3-1)+24-216-1st No.2 216-7-209=2d As 216: 209 :: 28.8:27.94 73.20×4 And 33 = 8 tons, the greatest weight. 22 Deflection with this weight .048. 4.5 ξ • 27.94 73.20 (4) As another example, let us take a parallel rail of 50 lbs. per yard, depth 4 inches, thickness of rib ths of an inch, and of the bottom web 1.39. Resistance of Head, (2-.7)×10=13) 13 (4)×12=48 48 4×4×.7×10 Ditto of Rib, 3 Ditto of Lower Web, (1.39.7)×10=24.15 12(3)+21=168=1st No. Tons 0.27 42.00 168-6-162=2d No. As 168: 162:: 24.15: 23.28 23.28 65.55 4x65 55 33 8 tons, nearly the greatest weight. Deflections with this weight = 0.55. .22 4 Remarks on the above Results. It appears from these results, that it is always possible to produce a parallel rail of good practical proportions, which shall be as strong as a fish-bellied rail of the same weight; and this being the case, I am decidedly convinced, after hearing and well weighing every argument that has been advanced in favour of the latter form, that the parallel rail is the best. First.-Because, although it is not stronger nor stiffer in the middle point than the fish-bellied rail, it is both stronger and stiffer, in a very sensible degree, in every other point. Second.--The deflection of a parallel rail during the passage of a load, is less every where than in the middle, which is not the case in the fish-bellied rail. The rise and fall of the carriage, therefore, after passing over a support, is more rapid in one case than in the other; and to this, rather than to a want of equable strength throughout, I am disposed to attribute the many failures of fish-bellied rails within a short distance of their point of support. There is, however, or has been hitherto, an actual want of equable strength towards the point of support in rails of this form, which cannot fail to have facilitated these fractures; but which Mr. Stevenson, by a judicious and scientific distribution of the metal, has avoided, and no doubt such fractures would be with his rail less common; but the objection I offer above applies not merely to the fish-bellied rail, but to the truly elliptical form itself, if it were possible to arrive at it. Thirdly. The parallel rail is the best, because it enables the engineer to keep the blocks and chairs of the two rails directly opposite to each other, so that the wheels of the carriage shall pass over both supports at the same time,--a point, I believe, not hitherto much attended to, but which is, I conceive, of great importance. There can be no doubt the motion of a locomotive carriage consists of a succession of ascents and descents; and it must be evident how much easier and better the motion would be, to have the opposite wheels both rising and both falling together, than to have one always rising while the other is falling, and the contrary. The difference is similar to that of a vessel keeping her head to the waves, and crossing their direction obliquely. And every one who has never been further than Margate must have experienced this difference. It may be observed that the waves of the railway, or the deflections of the rails, are very small; but I would observe, also, that the weights and velocities of the carriages are very great, and that it is very desirable every possible cause of momentum should be removed, particularly when it is as easy to do it as not to do it, as is the case with parallel rails, because they can always be cut to determinate lengths, but which cannot be done in the fish-bellied rails, in consequence of the occasional slipping of the bar in the rolls. At all events, their length cannot be varied at pleasure, which the former will admit of, and which is necessary, in going round sweeps, to preserve the blocks always parallel. For example, in going round a sweep of 800 feet, to keep the supports parallel, the rails of the inner course require to be about an inch shorter than the outer ones, and they are as easily cut into lengths of fourteen feet eleven inches, as of fifteen feet, which is not practicable in the other form. The above is my decided conviction relative to the longitudinal figure of the rails. I entered upon the inquiry without prejudice; I felt sensible of the honour which the general meeting had done me in confiding the question to my investigation; and I have given to it (after obtaining the requisite data) all the attention necessary to arrive at a certain conclusion. The following experiments were made on different rails, and the results may be compared with the preceding calculations. Experiments on the Resistance and Deflection of Railway Bars. Mr. Stephenson's Fish-bellied Rail, 50 lbs per yard. Bar No. 1. Bar No. 2. Deflections Deflections Deflections Deflections Weights. by for Weights. by for Index. each ton. Index. each ton. 1234567 .035 .045 .010 12 .014 .022 .008 .055 .010 3 .030 .008 .065 .010 4 .042 .012 .071 .006 5 ,050 .008 .076 .005 6 .062 .012 7 .087 .011 7 .075 .013 7 .095 .016 8 .085 .010 9* .101 .016 10 11 * Elasticity injured. .300 Bar No. 4. Bar No. 3. (Deflections Deflections (Deflections | Deflections Weights. by Index. for Weights. by for each ton. Index. each ton. 1 .018 1 .045 2 .025 .007 2 .056 .011 3 .038 .013 3 .065 .009 4 .054 .016 4 .075 .010 5 .062 .008 5 .084 .009 6 .069 .007 6 .095 .011 7 .080 .011 7 .105 .010 8 .094 .014 8 .110 .005 8 .100 .012 9 .116 .006 9* .112 .018 10 .125 .009 9 .118 .018 11 .165 10 .126 .014 11 .160 .034 17 destroyed Mean deflection per ton, Bar No. 1, .0097 No. 2, .0101 No. 3, .0110 No. 4, .0090 Mean, .0100 Bar No. 5, Fish-bellied. Great depth, 5 inch. Less ditto, 3. Thickness of rib, 9-10. Head estimated, 2 by 1. Bar No. 6, Fish-bellied. Great depth, 34 inch. Less ditto, 24. Thickness of rib, 7-10. Head estimated, 2 by . Table Continued. Bar No. 7, Fish-bellied. Great depth, 3 inch. Less ditto, 2. Thickness of rib, 6-10. Head estimated, 2 by. Weight Deflec'n Deflec'n in by for each tons. Index. ton. Weight Deflec'n Deflec'n || Weight Deflec'n Deflec'n in tons. by for each Index. half ton. in tons. by for each Index. half ton. 1 .030 0.5 .120 0.5 .033 2 .260 1.0 .140 .020 1.0 .060 .027 Readjs'd 3 .270 .010 1.5 .170 .030 1.5 .062 4 .290 .020 2.0 .180 .010 2.0 .090 .028 5 .300 .010 2.5 .200.020 2.5 .120 .030 6 .320 .020 3.0 .230 .030 3.0 .155 .035 7 .335 .015 3.5 .280 .050 3.5 .240 8 .410 .060 4.0 .420 .140 4.0 Mean deflection Mean deflection Mean deflection per ton to 7 .015 per half ton to .022 tons, 3 tons, per half ton to 2 tons, .030 Ditto with 7 tons, .107 | Ditto with 3 tons, .066 || Ditto with 2 tons, .060 Comparison of the above Results with the Formulæ, page 265, viz: 1 Rib, 3 1 hs.ns.pq.t Head,hx.nx nn-Pq t ns Bar No. 5. hs Here, { = 5, ns = 4.5, pq = .9, t = 10 hx = 1, nx = .5, nn-pq 1.1 1 = Hence, × 5 × 4.5 x9 67.5 1 이 × 1 × 0.52 X = 11 = .20 45 67.7 x 4 = 82 tons 33 .22 4 4.5 ××.066, deflection Bar No. 6. Here, hs = 3.25, ns = 2.88, pq .7, t = 10 hx = .75, nx = .375, nn - pq = 1.3 1 Hence, × 3.25 x 2.88 × 7 = 21.84 1 13 3 × 75 × .3752 × = • 15 2.88 21.99 S 4 s 23 tons 33 .22 2.88 4 = .092, deflection 이 Bar No. 7. Here, Shs Hence, hx 1 1 = 3, ns = 2.75, pq = .6, t = 10 .5, nx = .25, пп - -pq= 1.4 = × 3 × 2.75 × 6 16.50 = 14 = .05 이 ×.5 ×.253 X 275 16.55 4 s = 2.06 tons 33 .22 4 X =.106 deflection. 2.75 3 Notes and Illustrations. In order to avoid embarrassing the detail of the experiments with mathematical solutions, I have generally only stated the equations, and their results, in the preceding paper; but as, in its present form, some persons may wish to see the solutions themselves, I shall add here such as involve any difficulty, or which require any illustration. The first which occurs is the integration of the differentialx d x d3 (21x-x²) 13 This may be put under the form, Or making 2 1 13 d3 x² -3 (21x - x²)dx p under the form, 13 d3 (x-d) z Now the part under the integrating sign in a series becomes, f 1 xdx ท p = 7 2 5.3x² 7 2 x 3 3 5 3 x d x 2 3x2 P 2.2 2p² 7.5.3xdx f 4.2p3 6.4.2p = 5 X 5.3 x d x f 52p4.2p 27.5.3x2 9 6.4.2
About this record
- Patentee
- DATAMP
- Date
- the Name and Date index of patents, DATAMP
- Invention
- DATAMP
- Listed in
- the Name and Date index of patents, DATAMP, Jim Shaw's X-patent list, the Journal of the Franklin Institute, Burke's List of Patents (1847), the Journal of the Franklin Institute, Journal
- Burke's 1847 Patent Office list gives the same patent.